On the quantum chromatic number of Hamming and generalized Hadamard graphs

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14209
• Title: On the quantum chromatic number of Hamming and generalized Hadamard graphs
• Authors: Xiwang Cao, Keqin Feng, Hexiang Huang, Yulin Yang, Zihao Zhang
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14209

Abstract

Quantum coloring has important applications in quantum cryptography and information theory. This paper investigates the quantum chromatic number of Hamming graphs and generalized Hadamard graphs, explores the separation properties between quantum and classical chromatic numbers of these graphs, and determines the quantum chromatic numbers for certain classes of graphs. For upper bounds on the quantum chromatic number, the authors develop a linear programming method based on Hamming schemes to construct orthogonal representations with unit norm. For lower bounds, the authors determine the minimum eigenvalues of these graphs, thereby deriving corresponding spectral bounds.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of Quantum Chromatic Number: The quantum chromatic number is an important concept in graph theory with widespread applications in quantum information theory and communication. It was first introduced by Patrick Hayden and has demonstrated unique advantages in quantum cryptography.
2. Classical-Quantum Separation: Hadamard graphs provide striking examples of quantum advantage, with quantum chromatic number χQ(Ωn) ≤ n, while classical chromatic number χ(Ωn) ≥ (1 + ε)^n, exhibiting exponential separation.
3. Limitations of Current Research:
   • Non-trivial lower bounds for quantum chromatic numbers are rarely known
   • Computing quantum chromatic number is NP-hard in general cases
   • Apart from trivial classical graphs, only a few infinite graph families have their quantum chromatic numbers explicitly determined
4. Research Motivation: Inspired by recent work of Cao, Feng, and Tan, the authors investigate the quantum chromatic number of general q-ary Hamming graphs and natural generalizations of Hadamard graphs.

Core Contributions

1. Development of Linear Programming Method: Construction of orthogonal representations on Hamming schemes to provide upper bounds for quantum chromatic numbers
2. Extension of Upper Bound Results: Generalization of upper bounds from the binary case d ≥ n/2 to the general case d ≥ (q-1)n/q
3. Resolution of Open Problems: Treatment of the case d < (q-1)n/q, answering open questions posed in prior work
4. Establishment of Lower Bounds: Derivation of Plotkin-type lower bounds for Hamming graphs through determination of minimum eigenvalues
5. Complete Determination of Quantum Chromatic Numbers for Generalized Hadamard Graphs: Full determination of quantum chromatic numbers in two specific cases

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Investigation of the quantum chromatic number of q-ary Hamming graphs H(n,q,d) and generalized Hadamard graphs Ω_n^(G), where:

• H(n,q,d) is a q-ary Hamming graph of length n and distance d
• Ω_n^(G) is a generalized Hadamard graph with respect to additive group G

Core Technical Methods

1. Linear Programming Method for Constructing Orthogonal Representations

Basic Idea: Utilization of the Bose-Mesner algebra structure of Hamming schemes to construct orthogonal representations with unit norm through linear programming.

Key Lemma 3.1: Upper bounds for quantum chromatic number can be obtained through feasible solutions of the following linear programming problem:

minimize Σ(i=0 to n) (q-1)^i (n choose i) c_i
subject to Σ(i=0 to n) c_i > 0
         Σ(i=0 to n) c_i K_i(d) = 0
         c_0, c_1, ..., c_n ∈ ℕ

where K_i(j) is the Krawtchouk polynomial of degree i.

2. Spectral Method for Determining Lower Bounds

Hoffman-type Bound: For a graph G, χQ(G) ≥ 1 - λ₁/λₙ, where λ₁ and λₙ are the largest and smallest eigenvalues, respectively.

Key Techniques:

• Utilization of eigenvalue representations for Abelian Cayley graphs
• Computation of eigenvalues through character theory
• Determination of exact values of minimum eigenvalues

3. Generalized Krawtchouk Polynomials

For combinatorial graphs, generalized Krawtchouk polynomials are defined as:

K_i^(G)(j) = [z^i] ∏(h∈G) (Σ(g∈G) φ_h(g)z_g)^(j_h)

Technical Innovations

1. Unified Linear Programming Framework: First systematic application of linear programming methods to quantum chromatic number research for Hamming graphs
2. Treatment of General Cases: Not only addresses d ≥ (q-1)n/q but also resolves the difficult case d < (q-1)n/q
3. Precise Eigenvalue Analysis: Determination of minimum eigenvalues of key graphs through deep algebraic analysis
4. Generalization of Hadamard Graphs: Extension of classical Hadamard graphs to arbitrary finite Abelian groups

Main Theorems

Theorem 1.1 (Upper Bounds)

For positive integers n, q, d with q ≥ 2 and d ≤ n:

1. If d ≥ (q-1)n/q, then χQ(H(n,q,d)) ≤ q^d
2. If (q-1)n/q - √((q-1)n/q) < d < (q-1)n/q, then χQ(H(n,q,d)) ≤ 2(q-1)²(n choose 2)
3. If d = δn with 0 < δ < (q-1)/q, then χQ(H(n,q,d)) ≤ q^(h_q((q-1-(q-2)δ-2√((q-1)δ(1-δ)))/q)n+o(n))

Theorem 1.3 (Lower Bounds)

For positive integers n, q, d with q ≥ 3 and d ≤ n:

1. If d = (q-1)n/q, then χQ(H(n,q,d)) ≥ (q-1)(n-1) + 1
2. If d ≥ ((q-1)n+1)/q, then χQ(H(n,q,d)) ≥ qd/(qd-(q-1)n)

Theorem 1.5 (Generalized Hadamard Graphs)

1. If (q-1)n/q is even, then there exists N(q) such that for all n ≥ N, χQ(Ω_n^(Z_q)) = n
2. If both n and q are prime powers, then χQ(Ω_n^(F_q)) = n

Technical Details Analysis

Determination of Minimum Eigenvalues

Key Lemma 4.4: For sufficiently large n, the minimum eigenvalue of Ω_n^(Z_q) is:

K_{n/q}^(Z_q)(n-2,1,0,...,0,1) = -(n choose n/q,...,n/q)/(n-1)

Proof Strategy:

1. Simplification of analysis through cyclic symmetry
2. Coverage of all possible combinations through case analysis
3. Application of Stirling approximation and asymptotic analysis

Effectiveness of Linear Programming Method

Construction Process:

1. Definition of projection operators E_i = Σ_{x∈S_i} |φ_x⟩⟨φ_x|
2. Construction of matrix M = Σc_iE_i
3. Derivation of orthogonal representations through matrix decomposition
4. Utilization of constraints to ensure orthogonality of adjacent vertices

Experimental Results and Analysis

Main Results

1. Exponential Separation: The first two cases exhibit exponential separation between quantum and classical chromatic numbers
2. Precise Bounds: For the case d = (q-1)n/q + 1, the exact value χQ = (q-1)n + 1 is obtained
3. Asymptotic Behavior: The third case yields MRRW-type upper bounds, but does not achieve exponential separation

Numerical Examples

For specific parameters:

• H(n,3,(2n/3)): (2(n-1)+1) ≤ χQ ≤ 2n, with gap of 1
• General cases have gaps of (q-2) awaiting reduction

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Quantum Chromatic Number Concept: Introduced by Hayden, independently introduced by Cameron et al.
2. Hadamard Graph Research: Provides classical examples of quantum advantage
3. Binary Hamming Graphs: Recent work by Cao, Feng, and Tan provides direct motivation for this paper

Technical Comparison

• Traditional Methods: Primarily rely on constructive proofs and analysis of special graph classes
• Innovation in This Paper: Systematic linear programming framework and spectral analysis methods
• Generalizability: Extension from binary to general q-ary cases

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Establishment of a complete system of upper and lower bounds for quantum chromatic numbers of Hamming graphs
2. Partial determination of quantum chromatic numbers for generalized Hadamard graphs
3. Demonstration of exponential separation phenomena between quantum and classical chromatic numbers
4. Provision of constructive proof methods and computational techniques

Limitations

1. Gap Problem: χQ(H(n,q,(q-1)n/q)) still has a gap of (q-2)
2. Finiteness Conditions: Results for generalized Hadamard graphs require n to be sufficiently large
3. Computational Complexity: Practical computational efficiency of linear programming methods is insufficiently discussed

Future Directions

1. Gap Reduction: Complete determination of exact values of χQ(H(n,q,(q-1)n/q))
2. Scope Extension: Investigation of exponential separation for more general cases with d < (q-1)n/q
3. Algorithm Improvement: Development of more efficient algorithms for quantum chromatic number computation

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Deep results combining combinatorics, algebra, and quantum information theory
2. Methodological Innovation: First systematic application of linear programming methods in this field
3. Completeness: Provides comprehensive analytical framework for both upper and lower bounds
4. Generalizability: Extension from special cases to general theory

Weaknesses

1. Technical Threshold: Requires deep background in algebra and combinatorics
2. Practical Applicability: Primarily theoretical results; practical application scenarios require further exploration
3. Computational Complexity: Some proofs rely on "sufficiently large n" without explicit bounds

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important theoretical tools for quantum graph theory
2. Methodological Contribution: Linear programming methods may be applicable to other graph classes
3. Open Problems: Proposes multiple valuable directions for future research

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Information Theory: Design of quantum communication protocols
2. Combinatorial Optimization: Quantum algorithms for graph coloring problems
3. Coding Theory: Applications related to Hamming codes

Open Problems

The paper proposes three important open problems:

Problem 5.1: Polynomial vs. Exponential Bounds

For d = δn with 0 < δ < (q-1)/q, is it always true that ξ'(H(n,q,d)) ≤ poly(n)?

Problem 5.2: Exact Value Determination

How can the gap of (q-2) between upper and lower bounds of χQ(H(n,q,(q-1)n/q)) be reduced?

Conjecture 5.3: Minimum Eigenvalue

For all feasible n, is the minimum eigenvalue of Ω_n^(Z_q) always -(n choose n/q,...,n/q)/(n-1)?

These problems provide clear research directions for further development in this field.