Beam-commissioning-oriented optics study of HFRS Phase-I based on measured magnetic field data

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14343
• Title: Beam-commissioning-oriented optics study of HFRS Phase-I based on measured magnetic field data
• Authors: Ke Wang, Li-Na Sheng, Xue-Heng Zhang, Bei-Min Wu, Ming-Bang Lü, Dong-Sheng Ni, Jing Yang, Xiang Zhang, Fu-Qiang Liu, Qing-Gao Yao, Xiao-Wei Xu, Ya-Jun Zheng, Guo-Dong Shen, Geng Wang, You-Jin Yuan, Jian-Cheng Yang, Liang Lu
• Classification: physics.acc-ph (Accelerator Physics)
• Institutions: Institute of Modern Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences; Sino-French Institute of Nuclear Engineering and Technology, Sun Yat-sen University, et al.
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14343

Abstract

The construction of the High-energy Fragmentation Separator (HFRS) Phase-I has been completed, with beam commissioning anticipated to commence in autumn 2025. Based on measured magnetic field data, this paper presents first-order and higher-order beam optics calculations for HFRS Phase-I and evaluates its experimental performance in preparation for beam commissioning. First-order optics are calculated using sliced magnetic field data, while higher-order aberrations are corrected using a custom-developed program. Monte Carlo particle tracking is employed to analyze the beam phase space at the focal plane. Results demonstrate that higher-order aberrations are well corrected, secondary beams are effectively separated with high transmission efficiency, and valuable guidance is provided for the forthcoming HFRS Phase-I beam commissioning.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The HFRS (High-energy Fragmentation Separator), as an important experimental terminal of China's HIAF (High-Intensity Heavy-ion Accelerator Facility), is a two-stage radioactive beam time-of-flight separator. Prior to beam commissioning, precise calculation of beam optical properties and assessment of experimental performance are essential to ensure proper device operation.

Problem Significance

1. Engineering Verification Requirements: Following completion of HFRS Phase-I construction, precise optical calculations are needed to verify whether design specifications meet expectations
2. Beam Commissioning Preparation: Provision of accurate magnet setting parameters and operational strategies for beam commissioning in autumn 2025
3. Experimental Performance Assessment: Evaluation of separator performance in terms of separation capability and transmission efficiency under different operational modes

Limitations of Existing Methods

Traditional beam optics calculations typically rely on idealized hard-edge magnetic field models, neglecting edge effects, magnetic field uniformity, and multipole field components of actual magnets, resulting in insufficient computational accuracy.

Research Motivation

This study performs high-precision optical calculations based on measured magnetic field data, accounting for all physical characteristics of real magnets, thereby providing more accurate theoretical guidance for beam commissioning.

Core Contributions

1. Sliced Optics Calculation Based on Measured Data: First application of measured magnetic field data from all HFRS magnets for sliced optics calculations, considering edge effects and effective lengths and other realistic factors
2. Development of Higher-Order Aberration Correction Program: Development of a third-order aberration correction program based on COSY/GICOSY, MOCADI, and Optuna, supporting multi-process computation and checkpoint restart functionality
3. Comprehensive Performance Assessment: Evaluation of HFRS separation performance in both dispersive and achromatic modes through Monte Carlo simulation
4. Beam Commissioning Parameter Determination: Provision of precise excitation current parameters for quadrupole, sextupole, and octupole magnets for the forthcoming beam commissioning

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Measured magnetic field data from 95 magnets of various types (including 14 dipole magnets, 42 quadrupole magnets, 17 sextupole magnets, 9 octupole magnets, etc.) Output: First-order and higher-order beam optics parameters, magnet excitation current settings, separation performance assessment results Constraints: Satisfaction of design acceptance (momentum acceptance ±2%, angular acceptance ±30 mrad(H)/±25 mrad(V))

Technical Architecture

1. Magnetic Field Data Processing

• Enge Function Fitting: Description of magnet edge field distribution using Enge function

  F(z) = 1 / (1 + exp(a₁ + a₂(z/D) + ... + a₆(z/D)⁵))
  

• Multipole Field Component Measurement: Measurement of magnet multipole field components using harmonic coil method with precision below 6.0E-4
• Radial Field Coefficient Extraction: Acquisition of radial magnetic field distribution in dipole magnets

2. Sliced Optics Calculation

• Magnet Segmentation: Division of each magnet into segments at approximately 10mm intervals
• Superposition Field Consideration: Accounting for magnetic field superposition effects between adjacent magnets
• Software Tools: Utilization of MAD-X and COSY INFINITY for first-order optics calculations

3. Higher-Order Aberration Correction

• Custom Program: Development of third-order aberration correction program based on COSY/GICOSY, MOCADI, and Optuna
• Optimization Algorithm: Utilization of Optuna for sextupole and octupole magnet strength optimization
• Data Storage: Employment of SQLite database for computation data storage, supporting checkpoint restart

Technical Innovation Points

1. Full Sliced Optics Method: Compared to traditional hard-edge models, the sliced method accurately accounts for edge effects and magnetic field superposition
2. Measured Data-Driven Approach: All calculations based on measured magnetic field data, avoiding theoretical model deviations
3. Integrated Correction Program: Integration of multiple professional software tools, achieving efficient higher-order aberration correction workflow

Experimental Setup

Magnet System Parameters

HFRS Phase-I magnet system comprises:

• 14 dipole magnets (3 radiation-resistant type + 11 ferrite type)
• 42 quadrupole magnets (3 radiation-resistant type + 39 conventional type)
• 17 sextupole magnets and 9 octupole magnets
• Maximum magnetic rigidity 13.2 Tm

Computational Tools

• MAD-X: First-order optics calculation
• COSY INFINITY: Higher-order optics calculation and particle tracking
• MOCADI: Monte Carlo performance assessment

Assessment Cases

Two typical physics cases selected for performance evaluation:

1. ¹³²Sn Separation: Generated via ²³⁸U fission, testing achromatic mode separation capability
2. ¹⁰⁰Sn Separation: Generated via ¹²⁴Xe fragmentation, testing dispersive mode separation capability

Experimental Results

Primary Optical Parameters

Transfer Matrix Elements (dispersive mode example):

• PF2 focal point: (x,x)=1.62, (x,δ)=-2.80, momentum resolution ~800
• MF1 focal point: (x,x)=-2.63, (x,δ)=3.70, momentum resolution ~700
• MF4 focal point: (x,x)=-1.50, (x,δ)=0, achromatic focusing

Acceptance Test Results

• Momentum Acceptance: 2.4% (satisfying ±2% design requirement)
• Horizontal Angular Acceptance: 29 mrad (satisfying ±30 mrad design requirement)
• Vertical Angular Acceptance: 27 mrad (satisfying ±25 mrad design requirement)

Aberration Correction Effects

Monte Carlo tracking of 300,000 particles demonstrates that focal plane beam phase space analysis shows:

• Significant improvement in third-order aberrations
• More regular beam envelope, beneficial for improving transmission efficiency and momentum resolution

Separation Performance Assessment

¹³²Sn Separation (Achromatic Mode)

• Primary Beam: ²³⁸U³⁵⁺ @ 833 MeV/u
• Target Thickness: 1850 mg/cm² graphite
• Energy Degrader Configuration: 3 wedge-shaped aluminum degraders
• Separation Effect: Excellent separation and purification of ¹³²Sn achieved

¹⁰⁰Sn Separation (Dispersive Mode)

• Primary Beam: ¹²⁴Xe⁵⁴⁺ @ 1098 MeV/u
• Target Thickness: 5000 mg/cm² graphite
• Transmission Efficiency: 80% transmission efficiency maintained at MF6 endpoint
• Separation Effect: Effective separation of ¹⁰⁰Sn achieved

Transmission Efficiency Analysis

• ¹⁰⁰Sn: Relatively concentrated momentum distribution results in minimal transmission loss
• ¹³²Sn: Broad momentum distribution of fission products results in significant loss from PF0 to PF2 stage, consistent with fission reaction kinematics

Related Work

Separator Optics Design Field

• GSI's FRS: World's first large-scale fragmentation separator, establishing foundation of Bρ-ΔE-Bρ separation methodology
• RIKEN's BigRIPS: Employing superconducting magnet technology with important contributions to beam optics design
• GANIL's LISE: Accumulating rich experience in small-scale separator design

Advantages of This Work Compared to Related Studies

1. Measured Data-Driven: More accurate calculations based on measured magnetic field data compared to theoretical design
2. Comprehensive Aberration Correction: Systematic third-order aberration correction improving optical quality
3. Engineering Application Orientation: Direct service to forthcoming beam commissioning with strong practical utility

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Optical Design Verification: Calculations based on measured magnetic field data demonstrate that HFRS Phase-I optical design meets all technical specifications
2. Effective Aberration Correction: The developed higher-order aberration correction program effectively improves beam quality
3. Excellent Separation Performance: Simulations of two typical physics cases demonstrate HFRS possesses good separation capability and transmission efficiency
4. Commissioning Parameters Ready: Accurate magnet excitation parameters provided for beam commissioning

Limitations

1. Charge State Variation: Simulations do not account for effects of particle charge state changes in matter on transmission
2. Space Charge Effects: High-intensity beam space charge effects not considered
3. Phase-I Limitation: Current analysis limited to Phase-I's 13.2 Tm magnetic rigidity range

Future Directions

1. Phase-II Extension: Extension of methodology to Phase-II's 25 Tm magnetic rigidity range
2. Experimental Verification: Verification of calculation accuracy through beam commissioning experiments
3. Online Optimization: Development of online beam optics optimization system

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Advanced Methodology: Sliced optics method based on measured magnetic field data represents current state-of-the-art in beam optics calculations
2. Engineering Practicality: Research directly serves beam commissioning of major scientific facilities with important engineering value
3. Comprehensive Calculations: Complete optical calculations from first-order to third-order, accounting for all important physical effects
4. Software Development: Independently developed aberration correction program demonstrates innovation and practicality

Weaknesses

1. Physical Model Simplification: Simplified models employed in certain aspects (e.g., charge state variation)
2. Lack of Experimental Verification: Absence of experimental data verification due to beam commissioning not yet commenced
3. Insufficient Uncertainty Analysis: Relatively weak analysis of computational result uncertainties

Impact

1. Field Contribution: Provides important reference for optical design and commissioning of heavy-ion physics experimental facilities
2. Technology Promotion: Developed methods and programs applicable to similar beam optics systems
3. Talent Cultivation: Contributes to training of specialized technical personnel in related fields

Applicable Scenarios

• Beam commissioning of large-scale particle accelerators and separators
• Design optimization of beam optics systems
• Performance prediction for radioactive nuclear beam experiments

References

The paper cites 22 important references, primarily including:

• Design papers related to HFRS and HIAF
• Literature on professional software such as MAD-X and COSY INFINITY
• Fundamental beam optics theory literature
• Technical reports from related experimental facilities

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality accelerator physics technical paper with strong engineering application value. The research methodology is advanced, results are reliable, and it provides a solid theoretical foundation for successful HFRS commissioning. It makes important contributions to beam optics calculation methods and preparation for commissioning of major scientific facilities.