MOND Theory and Thermodynamics of Spacetime

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14345
• Title: MOND Theory and Thermodynamics of Spacetime
• Authors: Ahmad Sheykhi, Leila Liravi (Department of Physics, Shiraz University, Iran)
• Classification: physics.gen-ph
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14345

Abstract

This paper employs a reverse engineering approach based on Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) theory to construct a general form of horizon-related entropy expressions based on the entropic nature of gravitation. Utilizing the thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence in a cosmological setting, the authors apply modified entropy expressions to derive corrected Friedmann equations through three methods: (i) the first law of thermodynamics, (ii) the entropic force scenario, and (iii) the emergent nature of gravity. The study confirms that the model ensures the generalized second law of thermodynamics for the universe bounded by the apparent horizon. The research reveals that MOND gravitational theory can be naturally derived from modifications to horizon entropy, filling a gap in the literature regarding the theoretical origin of MOND theory from the thermodynamic-gravitational conjecture.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Dark Matter Problem: The total luminous mass of galaxies and galaxy clusters cannot provide sufficient gravitational force to explain observed dynamical behavior, particularly the flat rotation curves of spiral galaxies
2. Dark Energy Problem: Type Ia supernovae observations confirm that the universe is accelerating, requiring the introduction of unknown dark energy components
3. Theoretical Origin of MOND: Although MOND theory successfully explains galactic rotation curves, its theoretical foundation remains questionable

Research Significance

• The two major challenges facing modern cosmology require a unified theoretical framework
• The thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence provides a new perspective for understanding the nature of gravity
• Understanding MOND theory from an entropic perspective helps reveal its underlying physical mechanisms

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional methods require introducing unobserved components such as dark matter and dark energy
• MOND theory lacks a solid theoretical foundation
• Existing thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence research primarily focuses on Einstein's gravitational theory

Research Motivation

This paper attempts to provide a theoretical foundation for MOND theory through the thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence by starting from entropy modifications, while establishing a unified framework capable of simultaneously addressing dark matter and dark energy problems.

Core Contributions

1. Constructed generalized entropy expressions based on MOND theory: Derived corrected forms of horizon entropy from MOND theory through reverse engineering
2. Established three equivalent derivation pathways: Derived corrected Friedmann equations from the first law of thermodynamics, the entropic force scenario, and the emergent nature of gravity
3. Proved the validity of the generalized second law of thermodynamics: Confirmed that the modified entropy expression satisfies thermodynamic constraints
4. Revealed the thermodynamic origin of MOND theory: Provided a theoretical foundation for MOND theory based on thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence
5. Provided a unified theoretical framework: Potentially capable of simultaneously addressing dark matter and dark energy problems

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Starting from MOND theory, construct modified horizon entropy expressions and derive corrected cosmological equations through thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence, providing a thermodynamic foundation for MOND theory.

Core Methodological Architecture

1. Entropy Modification Construction for MOND Theory

Generalized form of interpolation function:

μ(x) = x(1 + x^α)^(-1/α)

where x = a/a₀, α > 0 is a free parameter, and a₀ ≈ 10⁻¹⁰ m/s² is the MOND characteristic acceleration.

Entropy expression derivation: Through the entropic force scenario and boundary conditions:

Sₕ = (A/4G) × ₂F₁{1/α, 1/α, (α+1)/α, -(γA/4G)^α}

where ₂F₁ is the hypergeometric function and γ is an observationally constrained parameter.

2. Three Equivalent Derivation Methods

Method One: First Law of Thermodynamics Starting from dE = TₕdSₕ + WdV, combined with:

• Total energy: E = ρV
• Work density: W = ½(ρ - p)
• Apparent horizon temperature: Tₕ = κ/2π

Method Two: Entropic Force Scenario Based on Verlinde's entropic force theory:

F = T△S = -(GMm/R²)[1 + (γA/4G)^α]^(-1/α)

Method Three: Emergent Gravity Employing Padmanabhan's cosmic space emergence theory:

dV/dt = GRH(Nₛᵤᵣ - Nᵦᵤₗₖ)

Technical Innovations

1. Reverse engineering methodology: Inferring entropy modifications from known MOND phenomenology
2. Unified mathematical framework: Using hypergeometric functions to uniformly describe different types of entropy modifications
3. Multiple verification mechanisms: Consistency across three independent methods enhances result credibility
4. Parametric treatment: Introduction of free parameter α provides greater theoretical flexibility

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Framework

This paper primarily conducts theoretical derivations and mathematical verification, including:

1. Boundary condition verification: Confirming correct behavior of interpolation functions in different limits
2. Consistency verification: Ensuring all three methods yield identical corrected Friedmann equations
3. Thermodynamic constraint verification: Validating satisfaction of the generalized second law of thermodynamics

Mathematical Tools

• Hypergeometric function theory
• Differential geometry (FRW metric)
• Thermodynamics (surface gravity, entropy expressions)
• Cosmological perturbation theory

Special Case Analysis

• α = 1: Corresponds to Renyi entropy
• α = 2: Corresponds to deformed Kaniadakis entropy
• Small parameter expansion: Approximate treatment for β ≪ 1

Experimental Results

Main Results

Unified form of corrected Friedmann equation:

(H² + k/a²) × ₂F₁{1/α, -1/α, (α-1)/α, -β(H² + k/a²)^(-α)} = 8πG/3 ρ

Linear approximation form:

(H² + k/a²) - β/[α(1-α)] (H² + k/a²)^(1-α) = 8πG/3 ρ

Special cases:

• α = 1: (H² + k/a²) - (γπ/G)ln(H² + k/a²) = 8πG/3 ρ
• α = 2: (H² + k/a²) + ½(γπ/G)²(H² + k/a²)^(-1) = 8πG/3 ρ

Consistency Verification

All three methods (first law of thermodynamics, entropic force scenario, emergent gravity) yielded completely consistent corrected Friedmann equations, verifying theoretical self-consistency.

Generalized Second Law of Thermodynamics

Demonstrated that the total entropy change rate satisfies:

Tₕ(Ṡₕ + Ṡₘ) = 8π²GHR⁵(ρ + p)²(1 + βR^(2α))^(1/α) ≥ 0

ensuring satisfaction of thermodynamic constraints.

Theoretical Findings

1. Thermodynamic origin of MOND theory: Successfully derived MOND phenomenology from entropy modifications
2. Unified framework: Potentially capable of simultaneously addressing dark matter and dark energy problems
3. Parameter constraints: Constraint γ ≪ 1 derived from observational data
4. Scale dependence: Behavior of correction terms at different cosmological scales

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence: Pioneering work by Jacobson, Padmanabhan, and others
2. Entropic force theory: Verlinde's theory of gravitational entropic force origin
3. MOND theory development: Milgrom's modified Newtonian dynamics and its extensions
4. Modified cosmology: f(R) gravity, Gauss-Bonnet gravity, and others

Relationship to Existing Work

• Extends Verlinde's entropic force theory to the MOND scenario
• Generalizes thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence to modified gravitational theories
• Provides new theoretical foundation for MOND theory

Relative Advantages

1. Theoretical unity: Incorporates MOND theory into the thermodynamic-gravitational framework
2. Mathematical rigor: Provides complete mathematical derivations
3. Predictive power: Potentially explains multiple cosmological phenomena

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. MOND theory can be naturally derived from entropy modifications: Establishes connection between microscopic thermodynamics and macroscopic gravitational phenomena
2. Equivalence of three methods: Confirms universality of thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence
3. Satisfaction of thermodynamic constraints: Ensures physical reasonableness of the theory
4. Unified explanatory framework: Provides new perspective on dark matter and dark energy problems

Limitations

1. Parameter dependence: Theory contains free parameters requiring observational constraints
2. Approximate treatment: Limited validity range of small parameter expansions
3. Lack of observational verification: Requires more observational data to verify theoretical predictions
4. Unclear microscopic mechanisms: The deeper physical origin of entropy modifications remains to be explored

Future Directions

1. Cosmological consequences: Analyze cosmological predictions of corrected Friedmann equations
2. Observational constraints: Utilize observational data to constrain theoretical parameters
3. Perturbation theory: Study structure formation and perturbation growth
4. Generalization of Einstein field equations: Derive modified field equations from entropy modifications

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: First systematic attempt to provide theoretical foundation for MOND theory from thermodynamic perspective
2. Mathematical rigor: Complete mathematical treatment using hypergeometric functions
3. Methodological diversity: Consistency across three independent methods enhances credibility of results
4. Unification: Connects seemingly unrelated MOND theory and thermodynamics

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient observational verification: Primarily theoretical derivations lacking direct comparison with observational data
2. Unclear physical picture: Microscopic physical mechanisms of entropy modifications lack clarity
3. Excessive parameters: Theory contains multiple parameters requiring observational constraints
4. Limited applicability: Small parameter approximations restrict theoretical applicability range

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new theoretical foundation for MOND theory, potentially advancing related research
2. Interdisciplinary value: Connects cosmology, thermodynamics, and gravitational theory
3. Practical prospects: If supported by observations, could transform understanding of dark matter and dark energy
4. Methodological significance: Reverse engineering methodology applicable to other theoretical problems

Application Scenarios

1. Theoretical cosmology research: Provides new theoretical framework for modified cosmological models
2. Galactic dynamics: May improve theoretical understanding of galactic rotation curves
3. Gravitational theory development: Provides thermodynamic perspective for modified gravitational theories
4. Dark matter and dark energy research: Offers alternative theoretical explanation schemes

References

The paper cites 51 important references, including:

• M. Milgrom (1983): Original proposal of MOND theory
• T. Jacobson (1995): Pioneering work on thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence
• E. Verlinde (2011): Theory of gravitational entropic force origin
• T. Padmanabhan (2012): Theory of cosmic space emergence
• Multiple recent studies on modified entropy and thermodynamic cosmology

Overall Assessment: This is a theoretically significant work that successfully incorporates MOND theory into the thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence framework, providing new perspectives on understanding the thermodynamic nature of gravity. Although requiring further observational verification, its theoretical innovation and unifying character make it an important contribution to the field.