A Novel Beam Tracking Approach for Preventing Beam Collapse

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14350
• Title: A Novel Beam Tracking Approach for Preventing Beam Collapse
• Authors: Xiaocun Zong, Fan Yang, Shenheng Xu, Maokun Li (Department of Electronic Engineering, Tsinghua University)
• Classification: physics.app-ph
• Publication Date/Venue: 2025 (inferred from references)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14350

Abstract

To address the beam collapse problem caused by transient instability during switching transitions in beam tracking processes, this paper proposes a novel beam switching method based on row-by-row codebook switching. The paper first establishes an abstract model of the beam tracking application scenario and introduces the reconfigurable intelligent surface (RIS) employed. Subsequently, simulation comparisons are conducted between the traditional direct beam switching method and the proposed row-by-row switching codebook method, elucidating the advantages and limitations of the new approach. Experimental validation is performed using an RIS hardware platform constructed in a microwave anechoic chamber. Both simulation and experimental results demonstrate that by introducing intermediate state transitions, the method achieves beam tracking without beam collapse and without significant gain loss. Finally, the applicability scope and potential application scenarios of the proposed method are discussed.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

In wireless communication systems, when mobile terminals change position relative to base stations, continuous beam tracking must be maintained to ensure high-gain beam alignment and support high-speed communication. Existing beam tracking methods face the following challenges:

1. Beam Collapse Phenomenon: In RIS-assisted communication systems, beam switching is achieved by changing the state of PIN diodes on array elements. However, instantaneous switching state transitions introduce instability, causing beam pointing errors or beam collapse.
2. Communication Interruption Risk: Beam collapse interrupts communication processes, requiring beam reformation and reconnection.
3. Limitations of Existing Methods: Beam tracking schemes based on Kalman filtering remain primarily at the simulation research level, lacking practical application validation.

Research Motivation

This research aims to solve the problem of ensuring continuous high-gain reception when mobile terminals move along known trajectories, particularly eliminating beam collapse caused by switching instability and achieving seamless continuous beam tracking.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a novel beam switching method based on row-by-row codebook switching, effectively preventing beam collapse phenomena.
2. Established an abstract model of beam tracking application scenarios, providing theoretical foundation for RIS-assisted communication systems.
3. Constructed a complete RIS hardware testing platform, validating theoretical analysis in a microwave anechoic chamber environment.
4. Verified through simulation and experiment the effectiveness of the new method in avoiding beam collapse while maintaining high gain.
5. Analyzed the method's applicability scope, providing practical solutions for small-angle beam tracking applications.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Position change trajectory of mobile terminal (rotation from 0° to 10°) Output: Continuous stable beam tracking without beam collapse phenomena Constraints: Maintain high-gain reception, minimize signal strength loss

System Model

Scenario Modeling

• RIS rotates on a turntable at constant angular velocity of 10°/s
• Terminal remains stationary until RIS reaches 10° rotation
• Equivalent to scenario where terminal moves relative to fixed RIS
• Terminal located in far field, 20 meters from RIS base station

RIS Basic Parameters

• Configuration: 1-bit 16×16 array
• Operating Frequency: 5.8 GHz
• Array Element Size: λ/2
• Beamforming Principle: Control beam direction by calculating phase of each element

Phase calculation formula:

φmn^req = φ0 - k·u0·rmn - φmn_init  (1)

Radiation pattern expression:

E(θ,φ) = cos^q * Σ(m=0 to M-1)Σ(n=0 to N-1) Amn*e^(jφmn_init)*e^(jφmn)*e^(jk·u0·rmn)  (2)

Core Algorithm: Row-by-Row Switching Codebook Method

Problems with Traditional Methods

Direct beam switching requires most array elements to simultaneously change phase states, causing beam collapse during the switching process.

New Method Principles

1. Row-by-row Update Strategy: Compare codebooks of 0° and 10° beams, updating codebook row-by-row during RIS rotation.
2. State Retention Mechanism: When modifying a single row's codebook, other rows remain unchanged, keeping most array elements in their original states.
3. Progressive Transition: Achieve smooth beam transition from 0° to 10°, avoiding abrupt jumps.

Specific Implementation Process

• Time Synchronization: During 1-second rotation (0° to 10°), codebook is updated 16 times.
• Update Frequency: One row updated every 62ms, synchronized with turntable's constant rotation speed.
• Beam Evolution: As modified rows increase, 0° beam sidelobes gradually strengthen. After approximately 8 rows modified, two 8×16 subarrays form, eventually merging into a single wide beam that gradually redirects toward 10°.

Technical Innovation Points

1. Intermediate State Design: Introduce progressive state transitions rather than instantaneous switching.
2. Localized Update Strategy: Modify only partial array elements, maintaining overall beam stability.
3. Time Synchronization Mechanism: Synchronize codebook updates with physical motion, ensuring tracking continuity.
4. Dual-beam Fusion: Utilize characteristics of similar beam directions to achieve smooth transitions.

Experimental Setup

Hardware Platform

• Testing Environment: Microwave anechoic chamber B3, Electronic Engineering Building, Tsinghua University
• RIS Configuration: 16×16 reconfigurable intelligent surface
• Measurement Distance: Far-field environment, 20 meters distance
• Frequency Setting: 5.8 GHz center frequency

Evaluation Metrics

• Terminal Received Signal Level: Assess signal strength variation during beam tracking process.
• Beam Stability: Observe whether beam collapse phenomena occur.
• Gain Loss: Quantify performance loss of new method relative to traditional method.

Comparison Methods

• Traditional Direct Codebook Switching: Direct beam direction switching at 500ms moment.
• Proposed Row-by-Row Switching Method: Progressive codebook update strategy.

Implementation Details

• Simulation Parameters: Based on scenario model established in Section II.
• Experimental Parameters: RIS configuration and geometric relationships consistent with simulation.
• Measurement Method: Conduct both simulation and actual measurement simultaneously to validate theoretical analysis.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Simulation Results

• Traditional Method: Obvious beam collapse at 500ms switching moment, signal interruption.
• New Method: Maintains stable beam state, no beam collapse phenomena.
• Performance Trade-off: Row-by-row switching causes slight main beam strength reduction, but overall gain remains high.

Experimental Validation

• Measurement vs. Simulation: Measured signal level approximately 4dB lower than simulation results.
• Error Analysis: Differences mainly caused by unit insertion loss (~1dB), environmental effects, and antenna radome loss (~1dB).
• Trend Consistency: Measured and simulated variation trends are nearly identical, validating simulation method accuracy.

Key Findings

1. No Beam Collapse: Row-by-row switching method successfully avoids beam collapse problems in traditional methods.
2. High Gain Maintenance: Although slight gain reduction occurs, overall high-gain characteristics are preserved.
3. Smooth Transition: Achieves continuous beam tracking from 0° to 10°.
4. Experimental Validation: Hardware platform test results highly consistent with theoretical analysis.

Applicability Analysis

Small-Angle Tracking Advantages

• Beam Alignment: Beam directions before and after switching are similar, merging into single beam during transition.
• Dual-Beam Avoidance: Effectively mitigates beam collapse caused by state instability.

Large-Angle Tracking Limitations

• Dual-Beam Phenomenon: Row-by-row switching produces two different codebook segments, forming separated beams.
• Signal Attenuation: Target terminal may fall outside beam width, causing significant received signal level reduction.
• Applicable Conditions: Requires timely tracking, suitable for small-angle beam tracking scenarios.

Related Work

Existing Beam Tracking Schemes

1. Kalman Filter-Based Methods: Particle filter and Kalman filter schemes proposed by Chen T et al. (2022) and Song H L et al. (2020), primarily remaining at simulation research level.
2. Positioning System Methods: Dynamically calculate beam direction based on terminal's real-time position.
3. RSSI Variation Methods: Detect terminal movement through received signal strength indicator changes.

Advantages Relative to This Work

1. Practicality: Provides complete solution from simulation to hardware validation.
2. Stability: Effectively solves beam collapse problems in practical engineering.
3. Continuity: Achieves true seamless beam tracking.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Technical Feasibility: Row-by-row switching codebook method successfully prevents beam collapse in beam tracking.
2. Performance Advantages: Achieves continuous tracking while maintaining high gain with minimal loss.
3. Experimental Validation: Consistent simulation and measured results prove method effectiveness and reliability.

Limitations

1. Applicability Scope: Primarily suitable for small-angle beam tracking; large-angle switching effectiveness is limited.
2. Performance Trade-off: Slight gain loss exists, requiring balance between stability and performance.
3. Timing Requirements: Requires timely tracking, imposing certain requirements on system response speed.

Future Directions

1. Large-Angle Tracking: Research improved methods applicable to large-angle beam switching.
2. Adaptive Optimization: Automatically select optimal switching strategy based on tracking angle.
3. Multi-Scenario Applications: Extend to more complex mobile communication and radar detection scenarios.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Problem Targeting: Directly addresses practical engineering problems in RIS systems.
2. Method Innovation: Row-by-row switching strategy is simple, effective, and possesses good engineering practicality.
3. Complete Verification: Forms complete closed-loop from theoretical modeling to simulation analysis to hardware validation.
4. High Result Credibility: High consistency between simulation and experimental results enhances conclusion reliability.

Weaknesses

1. Limited Theoretical Depth: Lacks in-depth mathematical analysis of beam evolution during row-by-row switching.
2. Parameter Optimization: Does not discuss optimal selection of switching row numbers, update frequencies, and other parameters.
3. Limited Comparison Scope: Only compares with direct switching method, lacking comparison with other advanced methods.
4. Scenario Limitations: Primarily validates single scenario; applicability in diverse scenarios requires further verification.

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new solution approach for RIS beam tracking field.
2. Engineering Value: Directly solves critical technical problems in practical applications.
3. Application Prospects: Possesses important application value in 5G/6G mobile communications and intelligent reflecting surface technology.
4. Reproducibility: Clear method description and detailed experimental setup facilitate reproduction and promotion.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Mobile Communications: Dynamic beam management at 5G/6G base stations.
2. Radar Systems: Beam stability control in target tracking.
3. Satellite Communications: Ensuring continuous communication between mobile terminals and satellites.
4. Intelligent Transportation: Maintaining high-reliability communication links in vehicular networks.

References

This paper primarily references key literature in beam tracking and reconfigurable reflecting array antenna fields, including beam tracking algorithms based on particle filtering and Kalman filtering, as well as theoretical foundations and design methods for reconfigurable reflecting array antennas.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality applied physics paper addressing practical engineering problems. The proposed row-by-row switching codebook method is simple and effective, with feasibility validated through comprehensive simulation and experimental verification. Although there remains room for improvement in theoretical depth and parameter optimization, its engineering practicality and innovation make it an important contribution to the RIS beam tracking field.