Investigation of intrinsic properties of high-quality fiber Fabry--Perot resonators

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14408
• Title: Investigation of intrinsic properties of high-quality fiber Fabry--Perot resonators
• Authors: Germain Bourcier, Stephane Balac, Safia Mohand-Ousaid, Julien Lumeau, Antonin Moreau, Vincent Crozatier, Pierre Sillard, Marianne Bigot, Laurent Bigot, Olivier Llopis, Arnaud Fernandez
• Classification: physics.optics
• Institutions: LAAS-CNRS Toulouse, IRMAR University of Rennes, Fresnel Institute Marseille, and other institutions in France
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14408

Abstract

This paper investigates the optimization of intrinsic properties of fiber Fabry-Perot (FFP) resonators with lengths of several centimeters through adjustment of mirror reflectivity and intracavity waveguide dimensions. Experimental measurements demonstrate loaded quality factors exceeding 10⁹, with optimal values reaching 4×10⁹, intrinsic quality factors greater than 10¹⁰, and intrinsic finesse on the order of 10⁵. The paper also demonstrates applications in laser frequency fluctuation stabilization.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Optical resonators are key devices in numerous application domains, including optical communications, frequency standards, quantum sensing, and biosensors. Resonator performance is primarily determined by two interrelated parameters: finesse (F) and quality factor (Q), which are affected by intracavity losses, coupling, and resonator dimensions.

Limitations of Existing Technologies

1. Ultra-low expansion (ULE) Fabry-Perot resonators: Possess extremely high Q and F values (10⁹ < Q < 10¹¹, F > 10⁵), but are bulky and primarily used for ultra-stable laser implementation in linear regimes
2. Whispering gallery mode (WGM) resonators: Achieve quality factors up to 10⁸ with finesse exceeding 10⁶, but face challenges in manufacturing and reproducible coupling control
3. Integrated ring resonators: Utilize silicon photonics technology with intrinsic quality factors exceeding 10⁸, but require high integration standards
4. Fiber ring cavities: Provide high quality factors (~10¹⁰) and reliable coupling, but their long fiber lengths make them sensitive to thermal and mechanical perturbations

Research Motivation

FFP resonators, composed of several centimeters of optical fiber and two dielectric mirrors, bridge fiber ring cavities and integrated resonators, combining advantages of both technologies: flexibility, reproducibility, robustness, and easy coupling through standard FC/PC connectors.

Core Contributions

1. Quantified intracavity losses caused by mirror diffraction: This represents the fundamental limitation on optimal finesse at maximum storage efficiency for FFP resonators
2. Experimentally and numerically verified the impact of effective mode area on finesse: Using fibers with different effective mode areas and mirrors with different reflectivities
3. Achieved record-breaking performance metrics: Intrinsic quality factors exceeding 10¹⁰ and intrinsic finesse exceeding 10⁵
4. Demonstrated practical applications: Application in laser frequency noise suppression

Methodology Details

Device Design

The FFP resonator consists of a fiber sample with length L ≅ 7 cm, producing a free spectral range FSR = c/(2n_g L) = 1.45 GHz. Dielectric mirrors several micrometers thick are fabricated at both ends using plasma-assisted electron beam deposition, with each mirror composed of λ/4 stacks of Nb₂O₅ (n_H = 2.18) and SiO₂ (n_L = 1.47).

Characterization Methods

RF spectroscopy techniques are employed to characterize the resonator:

• Narrow-linewidth external cavity laser diode (ECL) locked to resonant modes
• Detection of adjacent side modes through Mach-Zehnder modulator, vector network analyzer, and photodetector
• Magnitude and phase of S21 parameters provide precise replication of the FFP optical complex transfer function

Parameter Extraction

Parameters are extracted using the Yariv universal model based on transmission matrix formalism:

• Intracavity loss factor: a = a_p a_d² a_a² (propagation loss, diffraction loss, absorption loss)
• Mirror reflectivity: r ∈ 0,1

Key equations:

δf₁/₂ = (c/2πn_g L) Arccos(2aR/(1+(aR)²))  (1)
T_max = a(1-R)²/(1-aR)²                     (2)

Numerical Analysis Methods

Numerical investigation based on Gaussian mode analysis:

1. Decompose the fundamental cavity mode into plane wave expansion
2. Process spatial coordinates using 2D Fourier transforms
3. Calculate global Fresnel coefficients of Bragg mirrors
4. Compute intracavity losses due to mode mismatch through overlap integrals

Experimental Setup

Sample Preparation

Four groups of resonators were prepared with mirror reflectivity R = 99.86%, but with different effective areas A_eff of the fundamental mode (LP01), ranging from 13 to 198 μm². For few-mode fibers (FMF) and multimode fibers (MMF), specific fiber mode adapters were used to match the LP01 mode and prevent excitation of higher-order modes.

Measurement System

• External cavity laser (RIO Planex @1.55 μm)
• Mach-Zehnder modulator
• Vector network analyzer
• Photodetector
• EDFA amplifier (for δf₁/₂ measurement)

Evaluation Metrics

• Finesse: F = FSR/δf₁/₂
• Quality factor: Q = ν₀/δf₁/₂
• Power enhancement factor: PEF = (1-R)/(1-aR)²

Experimental Results

Impact of Effective Area on Performance

Experimental results show finesse increasing rapidly with A_eff, reaching a plateau value of approximately 1800 in MMF-based FFP samples, corresponding to intracavity loss a_dB = 3.12×10⁻³ dB (a = 0.9996). Numerical calculations indicate that diffraction loss dominates when A_eff < 80 μm², beyond which FFP finesse remains constant, limited only by fiber background loss and mirror absorption.

Mirror Reflectivity Optimization Results

Three groups of resonators with A_eff = 198 μm² MMF were prepared with reflectivities of 99.93%, 99.96%, and 99.99%:

• Maximum quality factor: 3.9×10⁹ (at R = 99.99%)
• Corresponding finesse: 29,400
• Record intrinsic quality factor: Q_int = 1.4×10¹⁰
• Record intrinsic finesse: F_int = 1.1×10⁵

Laser Stabilization Application

Laser frequency stabilization achieved using Pound Drever Hall (PDH) electronic feedback system:

• 7 cm long MMF resonator (F = 30×10³, Q = 4×10⁹)
• 2 cm long ceramic-tube MMF resonator (F = 5×10³, Q = 2×10⁸)
• Ceramic-tube resonator demonstrates superior mechanical stability
• Stabilized laser linewidth: 240 Hz (2 cm ceramic-tube resonator)

Related Work

Optical Resonator Technology Comparison

1. ULE Fabry-Perot: High Q and F but bulky
2. WGM resonators: High Q but difficult coupling control
3. Integrated ring resonators: Silicon photonics-based but high integration requirements
4. Fiber ring cavities: High Q but environmentally sensitive
5. FFP resonators: Balance between performance and practicality

Technology Development Timeline

Since their first appearance in 2009, FFP resonators have gained importance, demonstrating broad application prospects in optical frequency comb generation, nonlinear optics, and laser stabilization.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Diffraction loss dominates small mode area performance: Diffraction loss is the limiting factor when A_eff < 80 μm²
2. Achieved record-breaking performance: Intrinsic quality factor 1.4×10¹⁰, intrinsic finesse 1.1×10⁵
3. Importance of coupling optimization: Mirror reflectivity must be adjusted according to fiber effective area to maximize power enhancement factor
4. Practical application potential: Demonstrates promising prospects in laser stabilization

Limitations

1. Mechanical sensitivity: Unpackaged 7 cm resonators are sensitive to mechanical perturbations
2. Manufacturing precision requirements: Requires high-precision fiber end-face polishing and FC/PC connectors
3. Environmental stability: Further improvements in mechanical and thermal stability needed

Future Directions

1. Improve mechanical and thermal stability of FFP resonators
2. Explore fiber designs with larger effective areas
3. Optimize packaging technology to enhance environmental stability
4. Expand applications in nonlinear and quantum optics

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Systematic investigation: Comprehensive analysis of effective area and reflectivity effects on performance
2. Theory-experiment combination: High agreement between numerical simulations and experimental results
3. Record-breaking performance: Breakthrough in FFP technology performance
4. Practical validation: Demonstrates real-world application in laser stabilization
5. Technical innovation: RF spectroscopy characterization technique provides precise parameter extraction methodology

Weaknesses

1. Environmental stability: Mechanical sensitivity of long resonators limits practical applications
2. Manufacturing complexity: High-reflectivity mirror fabrication requires precision processes
3. Application scope: Primarily demonstrates linear applications; nonlinear application potential insufficiently explored

Impact

1. Technology advancement: Provides important guidance for FFP resonator technology development
2. Application expansion: Offers new solutions for high-precision optical systems
3. Theoretical contribution: Deepens understanding of fiber resonator physics mechanisms

Applicable Scenarios

1. Precision laser frequency stabilization
2. Optical frequency standards
3. High-precision spectroscopic measurement
4. Quantum optics experiments
5. Nonlinear optics research

References

The paper cites 20 important references covering key works in optical resonators, laser stabilization, nonlinear optics, and related fields, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.