A unified model of dark energy and inflation from the Markov-Mukhanov action

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14416
• Title: A unified model of dark energy and inflation from the Markov-Mukhanov action
• Authors: Hrishikesh Chakrabarty, Daniele Malafarina (Nazarbayev University)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), astro-ph.CO (Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: October 17, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14416

Abstract

This paper proposes a unified model of dark energy and inflation through the Markov-Mukhanov modification of the Einstein-Hilbert action. In this model, the matter sector is coupled to gravity through a scalar coupling function that depends solely on the matter energy density. The authors assume that the coupling function encodes ultraviolet corrections to the standard cosmological model and determine the coupling form that allows the dark energy component to become dynamical and act as an inflaton field in the early universe. Notably, to explain inflation, the model favors dark energy with an equation of state parameter $w$ close to but not equal to $-1$, which is consistent with recent DESI data.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

1. Unknown nature of dark energy: Observations show that the universe is currently undergoing accelerated expansion, but the nature of the "dark energy" causing this acceleration remains unknown
2. Early universe inflation mechanism: To solve the horizon and flatness problems, an accelerated expansion period (inflation) in the early universe is required, but the physical mechanism driving inflation remains unclear
3. Need for unified description: Existing models typically treat dark energy and inflation separately, lacking a unified theoretical framework

Research Significance

• Although the ΛCDM model is successful, it faces two major accelerated expansion problems
• Recent DESI observations suggest that dark energy may be dynamical ($w \neq -1$) rather than a cosmological constant
• A unified model can reduce free parameters and provide a more elegant cosmological description

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional models require introducing additional scalar fields (such as inflatons)
• Fine-tuning problem: requires spanning an enormous energy range of $\sim 10^{120}$ GeV$^4$
• Lack of a natural mechanism to unify early inflation and late-time acceleration

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a unified dark energy-inflation model based on the Markov-Mukhanov action, explaining both early inflation and late-time acceleration through a single matter-gravity coupling mechanism
2. Constructed two specific coupling function forms:
   • Model I: $\chi(\varepsilon) = 1 - \varepsilon/\varepsilon_c$ (LQC-like correction)
   • Model II: $\chi(\varepsilon) = 1/(1 + \varepsilon/\varepsilon_c)$ (geometric series summation)
3. Demonstrated consistency with DESI observational data: requiring dynamical dark energy with $w \approx -0.99$
4. Provided complete perturbation theory analysis: calculated scalar power spectrum and tensor-to-scalar ratio, compared with CMB observations

Methodology Details

Theoretical Framework

Based on the Markov-Mukhanov modified Einstein-Hilbert action: $S = \int d^4x \sqrt{-g} \left(\frac{R}{8\pi G_N} + 2\chi(\varepsilon)\mathcal{L}_m\right)$

where $\chi(\varepsilon)$ is a scalar coupling function depending solely on energy density $\varepsilon$.

Modified Field Equations

Variation yields the modified Einstein equations: $R_{\mu\nu} - \frac{1}{2}g_{\mu\nu}R = 8\pi G_N \tilde{T}_{\mu\nu}$

where the effective energy-momentum tensor is: $\tilde{T}_{\mu\nu} = (\varepsilon\chi)_{,\varepsilon} T_{\mu\nu} + (\varepsilon^2\chi_{,\varepsilon})g_{\mu\nu}$

One can define a running Newton constant and cosmological constant: $G(\varepsilon) = G_N(\chi\varepsilon)_{,\varepsilon}, \quad \Lambda(\varepsilon) = -8\pi G_N \varepsilon^2\chi_{,\varepsilon}$

Two Coupling Function Models

Model I (LQC-like Correction)

$\chi(\varepsilon) = 1 - \frac{\varepsilon}{\varepsilon_c}$

Leads to bouncing cosmology with:

• $G(\varepsilon)/G_N = 1 - 2\varepsilon/\varepsilon_c$
• $\Lambda(\varepsilon)/(8\pi G_N) = \varepsilon^2/\varepsilon_c$

Model II (Geometric Series Summation)

$\chi(\varepsilon) = \frac{1}{1 + \varepsilon/\varepsilon_c}$

Leads to asymptotic de Sitter initial state with:

• $G(\varepsilon)/G_N = 1/(1 + \varepsilon/\varepsilon_c)^2$
• $\Lambda(\varepsilon)/(8\pi G_N) = (\varepsilon^2/\varepsilon_c)/(1 + \varepsilon/\varepsilon_c)^2$

Technical Innovations

1. Phenomenological approach to non-minimal coupling: Does not depend on specific modified gravity theories, but constrains coupling function form through observations
2. Natural realization of dynamical dark energy: The coupling function causes the effective equation of state parameter to vary with energy density
3. Unified description mechanism: The same dark energy component exhibits different behavior at different energy scales

Experimental Setup

Cosmological Parameters

• Flat universe ($k = 0$)
• Matter components: matter ($w_m = 0$), radiation ($w_r = 1/3$), dark energy ($w_{DE} \approx -0.99$)
• Density parameters adopt benchmark values from Planck 2018

Observational Data

The following observational data are used for constraints:

1. Planck 2018 CMB data
2. BICEP/Keck (BK18) tensor perturbation data
3. Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) data
4. DESI BAO data

Evaluation Metrics

• Scalar spectral index $n_s$: characterizes the tilt of primordial perturbation power spectrum
• Tensor-to-scalar ratio $r$: ratio of tensor to scalar perturbations
• Slow-roll parameters: $\epsilon_1, \epsilon_2, \epsilon_3$ used to determine inflation conditions

Experimental Results

Main Results

Cosmic Evolution Behavior

• Model I: Exhibits bouncing behavior with bounce occurring at $\varepsilon = \varepsilon_c$
• Model II: Early asymptotic de Sitter state, capable of achieving natural inflation exit

Slow-roll Parameter Analysis

For Model II, the slow-roll parameters are: $\epsilon_1 = \frac{3}{2}(1+w)\left(\frac{1}{1+\varepsilon/\varepsilon_c}\right)$$\epsilon_2 = 3(1+w)\left(\frac{\varepsilon/\varepsilon_c}{1+\varepsilon/\varepsilon_c}\right)$

Requiring $\{\epsilon_1, \epsilon_2\} \ll 1$ necessitates $w \leq -1/3$, with optimal value $w \approx -0.99$.

Perturbation Theory Predictions

By solving the Mukhanov-Sasaki equation:

• Scalar power spectrum: $\mathcal{P}_R(k) = \frac{2^{2\nu-3}}{8\pi^2\epsilon_1 c_e}\left(\frac{\Gamma(\nu)}{\Gamma(3/2)}\right)^2\left(\frac{H}{m_{pl}}\right)^2\left(\frac{c_e k}{aH}\right)^{3-2\nu}$
• Spectral index: $n_s - 1 \simeq 3 - 2\nu$
• Tensor-to-scalar ratio: $r \simeq 16\epsilon_1 c_e$

Observational Comparison Results

• For $w = -0.99$ and appropriate effective sound speed $c_e \sim 0.1$, model predictions fall within the 1-2σ confidence interval of observations
• Approximately 60 e-foldings of inflation are required to solve the horizon problem
• The cosmological constant case with $w = -1$ is excluded

Key Findings

1. Necessity of dynamical dark energy: To be consistent with CMB observations, $w$ must deviate slightly from $-1$
2. Support from DESI data: The model's preferred $w \approx -0.99$ is consistent with DESI observations
3. Validity of unified mechanism: A single coupling function can simultaneously explain early inflation and late-time acceleration

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Quintessential inflation models: Using a single scalar field to describe both inflation and dark energy
2. Modified gravity theories: Such as $f(R)$ gravity, scalar-tensor theories, etc.
3. Holographic dark energy models: Dark energy models based on the holographic principle
4. Loop quantum cosmology (LQC): Bouncing cosmology from quantum gravity effects

Advantages of This Work

• Phenomenological approach: Does not depend on specific underlying theory, possessing greater universality
• Observation-driven: Directly connects with latest DESI and CMB data
• Mathematical simplicity: Introduces only one coupling function, avoiding complex multi-field dynamics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. The Markov-Mukhanov framework can provide a unified description of dark energy and inflation
2. Model II ($\chi(\varepsilon) = 1/(1+\varepsilon/\varepsilon_c)$) can achieve viable inflation
3. To be consistent with observations, dynamical dark energy ($w \approx -0.99$) is required, which aligns with DESI data
4. This model provides a new perspective for understanding gravity at high energies and large scales

Limitations

1. Assumption of effective sound speed: Assumes constant or slowly varying effective sound speed; actual situations may be more complex
2. Reheating mechanism: Does not discuss in detail the reheating process after inflation ends
3. Fine-tuning problem: Although reducing the number of fields, still requires appropriate choice of $\varepsilon_c$ value
4. Theoretical foundation: Lacks mechanism to derive the coupling function from more fundamental theory (such as quantum gravity)

Future Directions

1. Investigate more complex coupling function forms
2. Complete analysis including reheating dynamics
3. Explore relationships with other cosmological observations (such as gravitational waves)
4. Seek pathways to derive the MM action from fundamental theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High innovation: First systematic application of MM framework to unified dark energy and inflation problem
2. High observational relevance: Directly responds to DESI findings on dynamical dark energy
3. Rigorous mathematical treatment: Provides complete background and perturbation analysis
4. Strong predictive power: Gives testable observational predictions

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient physical mechanism depth: Physical origin of coupling function requires further clarification
2. Limited parameter space exploration: Focuses mainly on two specific coupling function forms
3. Insufficient numerical analysis: Lacks detailed numerical solutions and parameter scanning
4. Limited comparison with other observations: Does not sufficiently discuss consistency with other cosmological observations

Impact

• Theoretical significance: Provides new insights for unifying early and late-time cosmic acceleration
• Observational significance: Provides theoretical support for explaining DESI dynamical dark energy findings
• Practical value: Can be used to constrain high-energy physics and quantum gravity theories

Applicable Scenarios

• Phenomenological cosmology research
• Construction of unified dark energy and inflation models
• Observational tests of modified gravity theories
• Precision cosmological parameter estimation

References

This paper cites 51 important references, covering:

• Major CMB experiments including Planck, ACT, BICEP/Keck
• Large-scale structure observations such as DESI
• Classical literature on inflation theory and dark energy models
• Related work on loop quantum cosmology and modified gravity

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical cosmology paper that proposes an innovative solution to the unified dark energy and inflation problem. The paper's main value lies in providing a concise phenomenological framework capable of simultaneously explaining the universe's two accelerated expansion periods while being highly consistent with latest observational data. Although deeper understanding of the physical mechanism remains to be developed, it establishes an important foundation for further research in this field.