One loop corrections to the trilinear self coupling of the Higgs boson in the standard model with inclusion of singlet vector-like top quark

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14425
• Title: One loop corrections to the trilinear self coupling of the Higgs boson in the standard model with inclusion of singlet vector-like top quark
• Authors: Jin Zhang, Hong-Ying Jin, T.G. Steele
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14425v1

Abstract

This paper first evaluates the complete one-loop corrections to the trilinear self-coupling of the Higgs boson in the Standard Model (SM) using the zero-momentum approximation method, obtaining numerical results for the trilinear self-coupling and its correction factor κλ. Subsequently, the Standard Model is extended to include a singlet vector-like top quark partner, assuming the top quark partner mixes only with the top quark. Combined with the latest values of the Higgs boson trilinear self-coupling correction factor κλ reported by the ATLAS collaboration, the effects of the top quark partner mass and mixing parameters on the correction factor κλ are systematically analyzed. The results indicate that the upper limit of the singlet top quark partner is approximately 2800 GeV.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of Higgs self-coupling: The self-couplings of the Higgs boson (including trilinear λHHH and quartic λHHHH) play a crucial role in determining the shape of the Higgs potential in the Standard Model. This is not only essential for understanding the nature of electroweak symmetry breaking but also has profound implications for cosmological stability.
2. Experimental challenges: The cross section for Higgs pair production is extremely small compared to single Higgs production (approximately 10^-3), making direct measurement of the trilinear self-coupling highly challenging. Currently, the LHC can only provide interval constraints on the self-coupling correction factor κλ.
3. New physics exploration: Due to the extreme suppression of the Higgs pair production cross section, λHHH can serve as a valuable laboratory for testing new physics beyond the Standard Model.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical refinement: Although one-loop corrections to λHHH in the Standard Model and MSSM have been extensively studied, one-loop corrections arising from vector-like quarks (VLQs) models remain lacking.
2. Experimental relevance: Detecting VLQs is one of the objectives of LHC experiments. Observing VLQs through Higgs pair production would provide dual advantages.
3. Parameter constraints: Utilizing the latest ATLAS experimental constraints on κλ to constrain the parameter space of vector-like top quark models.

Core Contributions

1. First complete evaluation: The first complete evaluation of one-loop corrections to the trilinear self-coupling of the Higgs boson in the Standard Model using the zero-momentum approximation, obtaining κλ = 0.92.
2. Extended model analysis: Extension of the analysis to models including singlet vector-like top quark partners, systematically investigating the effects of new physics on Higgs self-coupling.
3. Parameter space constraints: Combining the latest ATLAS experimental data (-1.7 < κλ < 6.6), the allowed regions in the MT - sin θL parameter space are determined.
4. Mass upper limit: The upper limit of the singlet top quark partner mass is determined to be approximately 2800 GeV, consistent with perturbative unitarity constraints.

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Zero-Momentum Approximation

Due to the uncertainty in Higgs linear momentum making complete analysis difficult, the zero-momentum approximation method is employed:

$\Gamma_{HHH}(p_1^2, p_2^2, p_3^2) = \Gamma_{HHH}(0, 0, 0) + O(p_1^2, p_2^2, p_3^3) + \cdots$

This method greatly simplifies calculations and has been proven to yield good results.

Standard Model One-Loop Corrections

Feynman diagrams are classified into three categories:

1. Top quark loop corrections (Figure 3)
2. Massive gauge boson loop corrections (Figure 4)
3. Higgs boson loop corrections (Figure 5)

Using dimensional regularization under the D = 4 - 2ε convention, the complete one-loop result is:

$\Gamma^{SM}_{HHH} = \lambda_{HHH} + \frac{1}{(4\pi)^2}[\text{various corrections}]$

Numerical result: $\Gamma^{SM}_{HHH} = 175.89$ GeV, $\kappa_\lambda = 0.92$

Vector-Like Top Quark Extension

Mixing Mechanism

Mixing of the top quark with its singlet partner:

$\begin{pmatrix} t_L \\ T_L \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta_L & -\sin\theta_L \\ \sin\theta_L & \cos\theta_L \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} T^1_L \\ T^2_L \end{pmatrix}$

Coupling Constants

Couplings with the Higgs boson:

• $c_{tt} = c_L^2$
• $c_{TT} = s_L^2$
• $c_{tT} = c_{Tt} = s_L c_L$

where $s_L = \sin\theta_L$ and $c_L = \cos\theta_L$

New Contribution Calculations

Calculations of four new Feynman diagrams (Figure 6) contributions, including:

• Corrected top quark loops
• Loop diagrams containing one, two, and three top quark partner internal lines

Experimental Setup

Parameter Selection

Top Quark Partner Mass

Based on LHC direct search results, the following lower limits are adopted:

• ATLAS: MT > 1150 GeV
• CMS: MT > 1280 GeV
• This work: MT ≥ 1200 GeV

Mixing Parameters

Based on indirect constraints from Higgs couplings:

• Upper limit: sin θL < 0.40
• Range: 0.20 ≤ sin θL ≤ 0.40

Experimental Constraints

Using the latest ATLAS results:

• Observed value: -1.7 < κλ < 6.6
• Expected value: -1.8 < κλ < 6.9 (95% confidence level)

Numerical Analysis Method

1. Fix MT and vary sin θL
2. Fix sin θL and vary MT
3. Determine the allowed region in the MT - sin θL plane

Experimental Results

Main Results

Standard Model Results

At the renormalization scale μ = mt:

• Effective trilinear self-coupling: $\Gamma^{SM}_{HHH} = 175.89$ GeV
• Correction factor: κλ = 0.92

Vector-Like Quark Effects

1. Mass dependence (Figure 7):
   • MT = 1200 GeV: All κλ values are within the experimental allowed range
   • MT = 1400 GeV: Exceeds the expected upper limit when sin θL > 0.36
   • MT = 1600 GeV: Exceeds the limit at smaller mixing parameters
2. Mixing parameter dependence (Figure 8):
   • κλ increases rapidly with sin θL
   • Larger MT allowed range at smaller mixing parameters

Parameter Space Constraints

Allowed Region (Figure 9)

The allowed region in the MT - sin θL plane is determined:

• Under κλ = 6.6 constraint: MT ≤ 2750.11 GeV (at sin θL = 0.20)
• Under κλ = 6.9 constraint: MT ≤ 2792.52 GeV (at sin θL = 0.20)

Upper Limit Comparison

Comparison with perturbative unitarity constraints: $M_T^{(\text{Unitarity})} \lesssim \frac{550\text{ GeV}}{s_L^2}$

For sin θL = 0.40, MT ≤ 3438 GeV is obtained, consistent with the results of this work.

Important Findings

1. Mass upper limit: The upper limit of the singlet top quark partner mass is approximately 2800 GeV
2. Parameter correlation: Strong anti-correlation between mixing parameters and mass
3. Experimental consistency: Results are consistent with existing experimental constraints and theoretical expectations

Related Work

Higgs Self-Coupling Research

1. Standard Model calculations: Extensive one-loop and two-loop calculations exist
2. Extended models: Studies in MSSM and extended Higgs sector
3. Numerical tools: Development of the anyH3 package

Vector-Like Quark Research

1. Theoretical models: Singlet, doublet, and triplet VLQ models
2. Experimental searches: Direct and indirect searches at the LHC
3. Phenomenological studies: Combination with Higgs physics

Methodological Development

1. Zero-momentum approximation: Application in Higgs self-coupling calculations
2. Effective potential method: Simplification of multi-loop calculations
3. Renormalization schemes: Standard application of the MS scheme

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Standard Model benchmark: Establishes the one-loop benchmark value of the Higgs trilinear self-coupling in the Standard Model as κλ = 0.92
2. New physics effects: Vector-like top quarks significantly affect Higgs self-coupling, providing a pathway for detecting new physics
3. Parameter constraints: Successfully constrains the parameter space of theoretical models by combining experimental data
4. Mass limitations: Determines realistic upper limits on the mass of singlet top quark partners

Limitations

1. Approximation method: The zero-momentum approximation neglects higher-order momentum-dependent terms
2. Model simplification: Only considers the simplest singlet VLQ model
3. Mixing assumption: Assumes the top quark partner mixes only with third-generation quarks
4. One-loop approximation: Does not include two-loop and higher-order corrections

Future Directions

1. Model extension: Consideration of doublet and triplet VLQ models
2. Precision improvement: Inclusion of momentum-dependent terms and higher-order corrections
3. Experimental updates: Incorporation of future LHC Run 3 and HL-LHC data
4. Multi-parameter analysis: Consideration of combined effects with other new physics models

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Calculation completeness: First complete one-loop calculation of the Higgs trilinear self-coupling in the Standard Model
2. Method reasonableness: The zero-momentum approximation method has been verified as effective in this field
3. Experimental relevance: Closely combines with the latest experimental data, with strong practical significance
4. Result consistency: Maintains consistency with theoretical expectations and other constraints

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical limitations: The zero-momentum approximation may underestimate certain effects
2. Model scope: Limited to singlet VLQ models with restricted coverage
3. Parameter sensitivity: Results are relatively sensitive to input parameter choices
4. Uncertainty discussion: Theoretical uncertainties are not sufficiently discussed

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides important theoretical foundation for Higgs physics and new physics searches
2. Experimental guidance: Provides theoretical predictions for LHC experiments on Higgs pair production
3. Model constraints: Provides important parameter space constraints for vector-like quark models
4. Methodological demonstration: Demonstrates how to combine theoretical calculations with experimental data to constrain new physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Higgs physics research: Precise measurement and theoretical prediction of Higgs self-coupling
2. New physics searches: Constraints on vector-like quarks and other new physics models
3. LHC phenomenology: Higgs pair production research at hadron colliders
4. Future colliders: Provides theoretical benchmarks for HL-LHC and future collider experiments

References

The paper includes 86 references covering important works in Higgs physics, vector-like quarks, LHC experiments, and related fields, reflecting the comprehensiveness and timeliness of the research. Key references include the latest experimental results from ATLAS and CMS, theoretical calculations of Higgs self-coupling, and phenomenological studies of vector-like quark models.