Bootstrapping Mirror Pairs: The Beginning of the End

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14489
• Title: Bootstrapping Mirror Pairs: The Beginning of the End
• Authors: Leyi Jiang, Jazz E. Z. Ooi, Richard Stone, Zhenghao Zhong
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14489

Abstract

Three-dimensional N=4 supersymmetric gauge theories possess a unique duality known as 3d mirror symmetry. Under this correspondence, the Coulomb branch of one theory is equivalent to the Higgs branch of its mirror dual, and vice versa. Over the past decades, efforts have been devoted to mapping the landscape of 3d mirror pairs, but progress has often been limited by the need to identify appropriate brane configurations. In this first part, the authors introduce a novel quiver-based algorithm called Growth and Fusion, which, together with Decay and Fission, Quiver Subtraction, and Quiver Addition, completes a quartet of Higgsing algorithms. These four algorithms collectively provide a systematic framework that circumvents the limitations of brane constructions, enabling us to determine the mirror dual of a given quiver and systematically bootstrap new 3d mirror pairs.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

The core problem addressed in this paper is how to systematically construct and discover mirror pairs of three-dimensional supersymmetric gauge theories, particularly those possessing Lagrangian descriptions.

Problem Significance

1. Theoretical Physics Foundation: 3d mirror symmetry is an important tool for understanding supersymmetric quantum field theories, where the interchange of Coulomb and Higgs branches provides an effective pathway for studying strongly coupled theories
2. Computational Advantages: Higgs branches are typically easier to study, while Coulomb branch calculations are difficult; mirror symmetry allows understanding one side's Coulomb branch by studying the other side's Higgs branch
3. Theoretical Completeness: Completely mapping the landscape of 3d mirror pairs is crucial for understanding the overall structure of supersymmetric theories

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Brane Construction Dependence: Traditional methods primarily rely on the Hanany-Witten D3-D5-NS5 brane system, but this approach is difficult to generalize to highly non-linear quivers
2. Scope Restrictions: Existing constructions are mainly limited to quivers with classical Dynkin diagram shapes (ABCD types)
3. Lack of Systematicity: Absence of systematic methods independent of brane configurations for generating new mirror pairs

Core Contributions

1. Completion of Algorithm Quartet: Introduction of the Growth and Fusion algorithm, which together with three existing algorithms (Quiver Subtraction, Decay and Fission, Quiver Addition) forms a complete system of Higgsing algorithms
2. Bootstrapping Framework: Provision of a systematic bootstrapping method capable of generating new mirror pairs from known ones
3. Breakthrough Beyond Brane Construction: Development of quiver algorithms independent of brane configurations, applicable to arbitrary unitary gauge group quivers
4. Discovery of New Category: Introduction and study of "sunshine quivers," a new class of circular non-linear quivers
5. Gluing Methods: Development of methods for constructing complex mirror pairs through gluing smaller quivers

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Given a quiver gauge theory composed of unitary gauge groups, the objectives are:

1. Determine its 3d mirror dual
2. Systematically generate new mirror pairs from known ones

Four-Algorithm Architecture

1. Growth and Fusion Algorithm (New Contribution)

This is the inverse process of Decay and Fission, used for anti-Higgsing of Coulomb branches:

Growth Rules:

• Single U(1) Addition: (a) Increase the rank of a unitary node by 1, or (b) Add a new U(1) node connected to the rest of the quiver
• Multi-node Addition: Add subgraphs with finite Dynkin diagram shapes, typically finite Dynkin diagrams of Lie algebras g

Fusion Rules:

• Graph Fusion: Given a quiver Q, one can add any quiver Q' as long as all gauge groups maintain "good" properties (i.e., for all gauge groups U(k_i), the total number of connected hypermultiplets ≥ 2k_i)

2. Coordination with Other Algorithms

• Quiver Subtraction: Higgsing algorithm for Higgs branches
• Decay and Fission: Higgsing algorithm for Coulomb branches
• Quiver Addition: Anti-Higgsing algorithm for Higgs branches

Sunshine Quiver Structure

Sunshine quivers consist of two key components:

1. Central Ring: A closed loop composed of unitary gauge nodes, connected through bifundamental hypermultiplets
2. Rays: Linear chains extending from ring nodes, terminating at flavor nodes

Notation: [n, {k₁,...,kₙ}, {m₁,...,mₙ}, {rⱼ,ₗ}]

• n: Number of gauge nodes in the ring
• kᵢ: Rank of the i-th ring node
• mᵢ: Multiplicity of ring edges
• rⱼ,ₗ: Collection of rays

Gluing Methods

Construction of complex sunshine quivers by gluing smaller known mirror pairs:

1. Select two good unitary quivers A and A' and their mirrors B and B'
2. Glue rank-1 flavor nodes of A and A' into a U(1) gauge node
3. Correspondingly glue U(1) gauge nodes of B and B'
4. Verify that the result forms a mirror pair

Experimental Setup

Verification Methods

1. Hilbert Series Computation: Verification of mirror symmetry by computing Hilbert series of Coulomb and Higgs branches
2. Global Symmetry Matching: Verification that global symmetry structures of both theories correspond
3. Consistency Checks: Verification of mirror relationships through comparison of Higgsing results of sub-theories

Specific Example Verification

The paper provides multiple concrete sunshine quiver mirror pairs, each verified through Hilbert series computation:

For example, for a basic 4-ring sunshine quiver:

[4, {1,1,1,1}, {1,1,1,1}, {r₁,₁, r₂,₁, r₃,₁, r₄,₁}]

Its Hilbert series:

HSc(t) = 1 + 4t² + 8t³ + 20t⁴ + 40t⁵ + 84t⁶ + ... = HSH(t)

confirms the self-dual property.

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Abelian Sunshine Quiver Families

• Successful construction of infinite families of abelian sunshine mirror pairs
• Establishment of duality relationships between ray lengths and bond multiplicities
• Duality relationships between ring node numbers and flavor numbers

2. Non-Abelian Extensions

• Successful construction of complex mirror pairs containing non-abelian gauge groups through gluing methods
• Verification of the effectiveness of the systematic construction process

3. Algorithm Verification

Verification of the consistency of the quartet of algorithms through concrete examples, such as the mirror pair generation process shown in equation (2.5).

Specific Numerical Results

The paper provides Hilbert series computation results for multiple mirror pairs, for example:

For complex sunshine quiver mirror pairs (3.23):

HSᵡc(t) = 1+18t²+2t³+146t⁴+56t⁵+813t⁶+564t⁷+3621t⁸+3516t⁹+13952t¹⁰+O(t¹¹) = HSʸH(t)
HSᵡH(t) = 1+11t²+8t³+80t⁴+104t⁵+458t⁶+742t⁷+2232t⁸+3872t⁹+9430t¹⁰+O(t¹¹) = HSʸc(t)

Discovered Method Limitations

The paper also identifies limitations of the gluing method: when involving special unitary gauge groups, the gluing method may fail, which is related to subtle properties of global symmetries.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Origins of Mirror Symmetry: 3d mirror symmetry was originally introduced by Intriligator and Seiberg
2. Brane Construction Methods: The Hanany-Witten brane system provided a geometric framework for understanding mirror symmetry
3. Dynkin Quiver Research: Previous work focused primarily on quivers with classical Dynkin diagram shapes

Algorithm Development

• Quiver Subtraction: Systematic study of Higgs branch Higgsing
• Decay and Fission: Development of Coulomb branch Higgsing algorithms
• Quiver Addition: Implementation of Higgs branch anti-Higgsing

Innovation of This Work

This paper provides for the first time a complete quartet of algorithms and is the first systematic method independent of brane constructions.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. The Growth and Fusion algorithm successfully completes the Higgsing algorithm quartet
2. The bootstrapping method provides a systematic framework for discovering new mirror pairs
3. Sunshine quivers represent a new theoretical category beyond Dynkin diagrams
4. The gluing method provides an effective tool for constructing complex mirror pairs

Limitations

1. Gauge Group Restrictions: Current methods are primarily applicable to unitary gauge groups; extensions to orthogonal and symplectic groups remain challenging
2. Gluing Method Limitations: The gluing method may fail when involving special unitary groups
3. Computational Complexity: Hilbert series computation for complex quivers remains difficult

Future Directions

The paper explicitly proposes several research directions:

1. Computer Implementation: Programming the algorithms for automated mirror pair discovery
2. Orthogonal-Symplectic Extensions: Extension of algorithms to SO and Sp gauge groups
3. Other Matter Content: Treatment of more complex matter content such as adjoint hypermultiplets
4. 4d Analogues: Exploration of similar programs for 4d mirror symmetry

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Completion of a complete system of Higgsing algorithms, filling an important theoretical gap
2. Methodological Innovation: Provision of the first systematic method independent of brane constructions
3. Practical Value: The bootstrapping framework has strong practical utility, enabling systematic discovery of new theories
4. Sufficient Verification: Proposed mirror pairs are thoroughly verified through Hilbert series computation
5. Clear Presentation: The paper has clear structure and accurate technical descriptions

Weaknesses

1. Scope Limitations: Primarily limited to unitary gauge groups; treatment of more general gauge groups requires further development
2. Computational Dependence: Still requires Hilbert series computation for final verification of mirror relationships
3. Complexity: For very complex quivers, practical application of the algorithm may face computational challenges

Impact

1. Field Contribution: Provides new systematic tools for 3d mirror symmetry research
2. Theoretical Value: Advances theoretical understanding of supersymmetric theories
3. Methodological Significance: Demonstrates how to transcend limitations of traditional brane construction methods
4. Foundation for Future Research: Provides solid theoretical foundation and practical tools for subsequent research

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Applicable to theoretical physicists studying 3d supersymmetric theories
2. Mathematical Physics: Valuable for mathematicians researching algebraic geometry and representation theory
3. Computational Physics: Can be developed into computational tools for systematically exploring theory space

References

The paper cites 36 related references, primarily including:

• Original mirror symmetry papers by Intriligator & Seiberg
• Related work on Hanany-Witten brane constructions
• Development history of various Higgsing algorithms
• Recent research on quiver theory and magnetic quivers

This paper represents significant progress in 3d mirror symmetry research. By introducing the Growth and Fusion algorithm to complete the theoretical toolkit and opening pathways for systematically discovering new mirror pairs, it makes important theoretical contributions and methodological innovations. Although some technical limitations remain, its theoretical contributions and methodological innovations establish an important foundation for future development in this field.