Thermal/Black hole phase transition and entanglement entropy in (2 + 1)D

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14579
• Title: Thermal/Black hole phase transition and entanglement entropy in (2 + 1)D
• Author: Meseret Asrat (International Center for Theoretical Sciences, Tata Institute of Fundamental Research)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14579

Abstract

This paper investigates a one-parameter family of holographic solutions in classical string theory in three-dimensional spacetime. In Euclidean space, these solutions smoothly interpolate between a cigar black hole times a (non-contractible) spatial circle and a thermal solution with a (non-contractible) temporal circle without producing conical singularities. The paper studies the phase transition process and holographic entanglement entropy.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of phase transition studies: In five-dimensional spacetime, a first-order phase transition (Hawking-Page transition) exists between AdS-Schwarzschild black holes and thermal AdS, corresponding to a confinement-deconfinement phase transition in the boundary gauge theory.
2. Peculiarity of the three-dimensional case: In three-dimensional spacetime, although a phase transition exists between BTZ black holes and thermal AdS₃, the thermal AdS solution is separated from the continuous black hole spectrum by a mass gap. The geometry cannot smoothly interpolate, and geometries in the gap possess conical singularities.
3. Limitations of existing approaches: Traditional three-dimensional black hole solutions cannot provide a smooth phase transition process, limiting the understanding of various phase transitions (Atick-Witten, Hagedorn, and Hawking-Page transitions) and related tachyon winding mode dynamics.

Research Motivation

This paper aims to construct a special class of holographic solutions with the following characteristics:

• Regular and smoothly connected
• Capable of smoothly interpolating geometries of different topologies
• Providing better theoretical tools for understanding phase transitions

Core Contributions

1. Construction of a new one-parameter solution family: Proposes a holographic solution family with parameter γ ∈ -1,1 that smoothly interpolates between cigar black holes and thermal solutions.
2. Realization of smooth phase transitions: Resolves the problem that geometries cannot smoothly interpolate in three dimensions, avoiding conical singularities.
3. Comprehensive entanglement entropy analysis: Systematically investigates the behavior of holographic entanglement entropy during phase transitions.
4. Introduction of entropy c-function: Employs an entropy c-function independent of ultraviolet cutoff as a probe for phase transitions.
5. Physical picture of topological changes: Reveals the process of topological transformation of spatial cross-sections from disks to cylinders.

Detailed Methodology

Solution Construction

Basic Solution Family

The paper starts from black string solutions and obtains special cases through coordinate transformations:

ds² = l²[dθ² - (γ + e^(2θ))²/((1 + e^(2θ))(γ² + e^(2θ))) dt² + (γ - e^(2θ))²/((1 + e^(2θ))(γ² + e^(2θ))) dx²]

B_tx = l²(1-γ²)e^(2θ)/((1 + e^(2θ))(γ² + e^(2θ)))

e^(2Φ) = g_s²e^(2φ), e^(2φ) = e^(2θ)/((1 + e^(2θ))(γ² + e^(2θ)))

where γ ∈ -1,1 is the temperature parameter.

Critical Special Values

• γ = 1: Corresponds to thermal AdS₃-related solutions with disk-shaped spatial cross-sections
• γ = -1: Corresponds to BTZ black hole-related solutions with cylindrical spatial cross-sections
• γ = 0: Possesses Z₂ symmetry, exchanging the two circles

Symmetry

The solution exhibits Z₂ symmetry: γ → -γ, τ ↔ x, reflecting the duality between temporal and spatial circles.

Holographic Entanglement Entropy Calculation

Continuous Smooth Surfaces

For an interval of length δL, entanglement entropy is given by the minimal surface area:

S_C = (l/4G_N) ∫ dx F² √((∂_x θ)² + G²)

where:

F² = ((1 + e^(2θ))(γ² + e^(2θ)))/e^(2θ)
G² = (γ - e^(2θ))²/((1 + e^(2θ))(γ² + e^(2θ)))

Piecewise Smooth Surfaces

When continuous surfaces do not exist, piecewise smooth configurations must be considered:

S_P = (l/4G_N)[y_∞ + (1 + γ²)ln(y_∞) - 1 + γ² + √(2(γ² + 1)(γ - 1)²) · (2πδL/L)]

Entropy c-function

Define a quantity independent of ultraviolet cutoff:

C = δL ∂S/∂δL

Experimental Setup

Numerical Computation Methods

• Set l/4G_N = 1/6
• Employ numerical integration to evaluate complex integral expressions
• Systematically scan parameter space γ ∈ -1,1 and interval lengths δL

Key Parameters

• γ₀ ≈ -0.5321: Critical parameter value
• γ₁ ≈ 0.06425: Parameter corresponding to minimum length
• L₀ = L/4: Minimum meaningful interval length (non-local scale)

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Classification of Phase Transition Behavior

Depending on γ values and interval length, the system exhibits different phase transition behaviors:

• γ ∈ (γ₀, 1): A maximum length L_max exists, beyond which continuous surfaces do not exist
• γ ≤ γ₀: Continuous surfaces always exist

2. Phase Transition Characteristics of c-function

• Continuity: The c-function is always positive and continuous
• Smoothness: Piecewise smooth in certain parameter regions
• Phase transition detection: Slope changes signal phase transition occurrence

3. Entanglement Entropy Jumps

At L_max, entanglement entropy undergoes discontinuous jumps, while the c-function remains continuous but becomes piecewise smooth.

Specific Numerical Results

Non-local Scale

For all γ values, entanglement entropy and c-function diverge as δL → L₀ = L/4, which is the non-local scale of the theory.

Maximum Interval Length

L_max satisfies the inequality: L⋆ ≤ L_max < L/2, where L⋆ reaches its minimum at γ = γ₁.

Related Work

Theoretical Background

1. Hawking-Page transition: Phase transition between five-dimensional AdS-Schwarzschild black holes and thermal AdS
2. BTZ black holes: Three-dimensional black hole solutions and their thermodynamic properties
3. Holographic entanglement entropy: Ryu-Takayanagi formula and its generalizations

Innovations of This Paper

Compared with existing work, this paper is the first to achieve:

• Smooth phase transitions without conical singularities in three dimensions
• Systematic analysis of entanglement entropy phase transitions
• Application of c-function as a phase transition probe

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Realization of smooth phase transitions: Successfully constructs a solution family that smoothly interpolates between cigar black holes and thermal solutions.
2. Mechanism of topological changes: The topological transformation of spatial cross-sections from disks to cylinders is realized through competing condensation of winding modes.
3. Entanglement entropy phase transitions: Both entanglement entropy and c-function can probe phase transitions but exhibit different continuity properties.
4. Universal non-local scale: L₀ = L/4 is a universal non-local scale independent of γ.

Limitations

1. Special cases: The study concerns a special subclass of black string solutions; generality remains to be verified.
2. Numerical computation: Most results rely on numerical calculations, lacking analytical expressions.
3. Physical interpretation: The deeper physical mechanisms of certain phenomena (such as piecewise smoothness of the c-function) require further investigation.

Future Directions

1. FZZ duality: Better understand winding mode dynamics using FZZ or related dualities.
2. Special case γ = 0: Deeper investigation of the case where θ lies on the real axis.
3. Physics of non-local scale: Understanding physical phenomena at L₀.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: First realization of smooth black hole-thermal solution phase transitions in three dimensions, solving an important theoretical problem.
2. Systematic analysis: Comprehensive and systematic analysis of entanglement entropy and c-function.
3. Numerical precision: Although relying on numerical computation, results are precise and reliable.
4. Clear physical picture: Connects phase transitions with topological changes, providing intuitive physical insight.

Weaknesses

1. Limited analytical results: Except for the γ = 0 case, analytical expressions are lacking.
2. Generality issues: Only studies solutions under specific parameter choices.
3. Experimental verification: As purely theoretical work, lacks experimental or numerical simulation verification.

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new tools for understanding phase transitions in three-dimensional gravity.
2. Methodological value: The method of using c-function as a phase transition probe has general applicability.
3. Foundation for future research: Establishes foundation for further research in related fields.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Holographic duality research: Applicable to phase transition studies in AdS/CFT correspondence.
2. String theory: Provides concrete examples of phase transitions and topological changes in string theory.
3. Condensed matter physics: May provide insights for quantum phase transitions in condensed matter systems.

References

The paper cites 15 important references, including:

• Original work on Hawking-Page transitions 3,4
• Classical literature on BTZ black holes 5,6
• Foundational work on holographic entanglement entropy 12-14
• Author's previous related work 1,2

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that achieves significant progress in the study of three-dimensional holographic phase transitions. Despite certain technical limitations, its theoretical innovations and systematic analysis endow it with important academic value.