The growth rate of closed prime magnetic geodesics on closed contact manifolds

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14608
• Title: The growth rate of closed prime magnetic geodesics on closed contact manifolds
• Authors: Lina Deschamps, Levin Maier, Tom Stalljohann
• Classification: math.SG (Symplectic Geometry) math.DS (Dynamical Systems)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14608

Abstract

This paper proves that for any given closed contact manifold, there exists an infinite-dimensional space of Riemannian metrics that can be identified with the space of bundle metrics on the induced contact distribution. For each such metric and all energy levels, the growth rate of the number of embedded periodic orbits of the corresponding magnetic geodesic flow is at least as fast as the number of geometrically distinct closed Reeb orbits with period less than $t$. As a corollary, for each closed 3-manifold that is not a graph manifold, there exists an open $C^1$-neighborhood of the set of non-degenerate contact forms such that every contact form in this neighborhood admits the aforementioned infinite-dimensional space of Riemannian metrics. For the corresponding magnetic systems, the number of closed prime magnetic geodesics exhibits at least exponential growth at all energy levels. Consequently, the restriction of the magnetic geodesic flow to any energy surface possesses positive topological entropy.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Classical Problem: The problem of counting closed geodesics has historically been a major driving force in geometry and calculus of variations, particularly in establishing growth rate results relative to length. This classical problem has also inspired growing interest in studying growth rates of Reeb flows and magnetic geodesic flows.
2. Theoretical Framework:
   • Reeb Flow: On a closed contact manifold $(M,α)$, the Reeb vector field $R_α$ is uniquely determined by the conditions $α(R_α) = 1$ and $dα(R_α, ·) = 0$
   • Magnetic Geodesic Flow: Following Arnold's pioneering approach, studying the dynamics of charged particles in magnetic fields
3. Core Challenge: The key distinction between magnetic geodesics and standard geodesics is that magnetic geodesics at different speeds cannot be simply reparametrized as unit-speed magnetic geodesics due to the nonlinear nature of the Lorentz force.

Research Motivation

This paper aims to establish deep connections between Reeb orbits in contact geometry and periodic orbits in magnetic geodesic flows, particularly regarding growth rate relationships. Such connections not only have theoretical value but also provide new perspectives for understanding complex dynamical systems.

Core Contributions

1. Established equivalence between Reeb orbits and magnetic geodesics: Proved that under specific Riemannian metric classes, constant reparametrizations of each Reeb orbit are simultaneously geodesics and magnetic geodesics
2. Constructed infinite-dimensional metric spaces: Identified infinite-dimensional Riemannian metric spaces that can be identified with bundle metric spaces on the contact distribution
3. Proved growth rate lower bounds: Established growth rate relationships between the number of periodic orbits of the magnetic geodesic flow and the number of Reeb orbits
4. Obtained exponential growth results: For closed 3-manifolds that are not graph manifolds, proved exponential growth of the number of closed prime magnetic geodesics
5. Established positive topological entropy: Proved that the restriction of the magnetic geodesic flow to energy surfaces possesses positive topological entropy

Detailed Methodology

Core Theorem

Theorem 1.1: Let $(M,α)$ be a closed contact manifold with Reeb vector field $R_α$. Define the infinite-dimensional space of Riemannian metrics $\mathcal{G}$ as the collection of all Riemannian metrics $g$ satisfying: $g(R_α, R_α) = 1 \quad \text{and} \quad R_α \perp_g \ker(α)$

Then for each $g ∈ \mathcal{G}$, the exact magnetic system $(M, g, dα)$ satisfies:

(a) Each constant reparametrization of every Reeb orbit of $(M,α)$ is simultaneously a geodesic of $(M,g)$ and a magnetic geodesic of $(M,g,dα)$

(b) For each energy level $κ ∈ (0,∞)$: $P^κ_t(M, g, dα) ≥ R_t(M,α) \quad ∀κ, t ∈ (0,∞)$

(c) If the Reeb flow has at least one closed Reeb orbit, then the Mañé critical value is: $c(M, g, dα) = \frac{1}{2}\|α\|^2_∞ = \frac{1}{2}$

Technical Innovations

1. Characterization of metric spaces: Established a bijection between the infinite-dimensional Riemannian metric space and bundle metric spaces on the contact distribution, providing a concrete geometric realization.
2. Application of Sullivan's result: Utilized Sullivan's result on geodesibility of Reeb flows, combined with specific metric constraints.
3. Vanishing property of Lorentz force: Proved that under the constructed metrics, the Lorentz force vanishes on $\ker dα = ⟨R_α⟩$, which is the key to establishing the equivalence.

Proof Strategy

The proof proceeds in three main steps:

1. Establishing bijection: Proved the existence of a bijection between $\mathcal{G}$ and $\text{Met}(ξ)$ (the space of bundle metrics on the contact distribution $ξ = \ker α$)
2. Applying Sullivan's theorem: Each $g ∈ \mathcal{G}$ makes all Reeb orbits unit-speed geodesics
3. Lorentz force analysis: Proved that the Lorentz force $Y$ vanishes on the line bundle spanned by the Reeb vector field, thereby establishing the equivalence between geodesics and magnetic geodesics

Main Application Results

Corollary 1.4 (Case of Three-Sphere)

For $M ∈ \{T^1S^2, S^3\}$, under appropriate conditions, the growth function $P^κ_t(M, g, dα)$ exhibits at least quadratic growth at all energy levels $κ$: $\liminf_{t→∞} \frac{\log(P^κ_t(M, g, dα))}{\log(t)} ≥ 2$

Corollary 1.7 (Exponential Growth for Non-Graph Manifolds)

Let $M^3$ be a closed 3-manifold that is not a graph manifold. There exists an open $C^1$-neighborhood $U$ of the set of non-degenerate contact forms such that for each $α ∈ U$ and corresponding metric $g ∈ \mathcal{G}$, exponential growth occurs at all energy levels: $\liminf_{t→∞} \frac{1}{t}\log(P^κ_t(M^3, g, dα)) ≥ c > 0$

In particular, the topological entropy of the magnetic geodesic flow on energy surfaces is positive.

Related Work

Relationship to Existing Results

1. Two-dimensional case: The dynamics of magnetic flows on two-dimensional manifolds are relatively well understood
2. Recent progress: The authors obtained results on the existence of finitely many closed prime magnetic geodesics in 13
3. Contribution of this paper: First establishes the existence and exponential growth of infinitely many closed prime magnetic geodesics at all energy levels

Comparison with 13

• Metric space: The Riemannian metric space considered in this paper is more rigid and smaller
• Dynamical results: By restricting to a smaller metric class, stronger dynamical statements are obtained
• Globality: The construction in this paper is global rather than local

Technical Details

Mañé Critical Value

For exact magnetic systems, the Mañé critical value is defined as: $c(L) := \inf \{κ ∈ \mathbb{R} | S_{L+κ}(γ) ≥ 0 \text{ for all } T > 0, γ ∈ C^∞(\mathbb{R}/T\mathbb{Z},M)\}$

where $L(q,v) = \frac{1}{2}|v|^2 - α_q(v)$ is the magnetic Lagrangian.

Variational Principle

Magnetic geodesics can be characterized via the variational principle: a curve $γ: [0,T] → M$ is a magnetic geodesic if and only if it is a critical point of the action functional $S_L$.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Established deep connections between contact geometry and magnetic geodesic flows
2. Proved the equivalence between Reeb orbits and magnetic geodesics under specific metric classes
3. Obtained precise lower bounds for the growth of magnetic geodesic numbers
4. Proved exponential growth and positive topological entropy for non-graph manifolds

Limitations

1. Restrictiveness of metric space: The considered metrics must satisfy specific orthogonality conditions
2. Energy level restrictions: Results primarily focus on positive energy levels
3. Dimensional restrictions: Some results are specific to three-dimensional cases

Future Directions

1. Generalization to more general magnetic fields and metrics
2. Study of dynamics below critical values
3. Exploration of connections with pseudoholomorphic curve theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Established new connections between contact geometry and magnetic geodesic flows
2. Technical Rigor: Proof methods cleverly combine contact geometry, Riemannian geometry, and dynamical systems theory
3. Profound Results: Obtained precise estimates on growth rates and positivity of topological entropy
4. Broad Applicability: Results apply to a large class of three-dimensional manifolds

Weaknesses

1. Metric Restrictions: The considered metric class is relatively small, limiting the generality of results
2. Proof Dependencies: Some key results depend on unpublished work by other authors
3. Computational Complexity: Computing the Mañé critical value and growth rates in practice may be difficult

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new research directions and tools for magnetic geodesic flow theory
2. Methodological Value: Demonstrates how to use contact geometry to study dynamical systems problems
3. Application Prospects: May have important implications for understanding chaotic behavior in complex dynamical systems

Applicable Scenarios

This method is particularly suitable for:

1. Three-dimensional manifolds with rich contact structures
2. Dynamical systems research in exact magnetic field settings
3. Problems requiring estimates of periodic orbit growth rates

References

The paper cites 24 important references spanning multiple fields including contact geometry, symplectic geometry, and dynamical systems theory, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.