Complete two-loop Yukawa-induced running of the Higgs-gluon coupling in SMEFT

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14680
• Title: Complete two-loop Yukawa-induced running of the Higgs-gluon coupling in SMEFT
• Authors: Stefano Di Noi, Barbara Anna Erdelyi, Ramona Gröber
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14680

Abstract

This paper calculates the two-loop renormalization group equations (RGE) for the Higgs-gluon effective coupling in the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT). Specifically, the authors provide contributions from class-3 and class-7 operators in the Warsaw basis, completing the two-loop renormalization program for the Higgs-gluon coupling proportional to the top-quark Yukawa coupling, encompassing operators potentially generated at tree level. The study investigates the phenomenological implications for Higgs data fitting through both bottom-up and top-down approaches within UV models containing vector-like quarks.

Research Background and Motivation

Physical Background

Although the Standard Model is remarkably successful in describing fundamental particle interactions, numerous mysteries remain unsolved, such as the hierarchy problem and dark matter. This motivates physicists to search for physics beyond the Standard Model. Given the absence of direct evidence for new physics, the effective field theory (EFT) framework has become the most model-independent approach for describing potential beyond-Standard-Model effects.

Technical Motivation

1. Importance of Renormalization Group Equations: RGEs connect Wilson coefficients at different energy scales, which is crucial for global analyses combining measurements at different scales.
2. Necessity of Two-Loop Effects: With improved collider measurement precision, two-loop RGE effects may become significant, particularly in processes with large variations in renormalization scales.
3. Completeness Requirement: To ensure theoretical consistency at a given order in perturbative expansion, two-loop running effects of tree-level-generated operators must be considered.

Research Gap

While one-loop RGEs for six-dimensional operators have been completely calculated, the complete two-loop RGE remains incomplete. This paper fills the gap in two-loop contributions from class-3 and class-7 operators to the Higgs-gluon coupling running.

Core Contributions

1. First Calculation: Completes the two-loop RGE contributions of class-3 ($D^2H^4$) and class-7 ($DH^2\psi^2$) operators to the Higgs-gluon coupling $C_{HG}$ in SMEFT.
2. Theoretical Completeness: Combined with previous contributions from four-quark and Yukawa-type operators, completes the full two-loop renormalization program for tree-level-generated operators proportional to the top Yukawa coupling.
3. Phenomenological Analysis: Systematically investigates the phenomenological implications of two-loop running effects through Higgs data fitting.
4. UV Model Verification: Verifies the physical significance of theoretical calculations within the vector-like quark model framework.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Calculation of the divergent part of the process $gg \to H^*H$ at two-loop level, where $O_{HG} = (H^\dagger H)(G^A_{\mu\nu}G^{A,\mu\nu})$ enters at tree level. The RGE contribution is obtained by extracting the coefficient of the $1/\epsilon$ pole.

Computational Framework

Theoretical Setup

• Calculations performed in the unbroken phase, considering the $gg \to H^*H$ process
• Dimensional regularization scheme employed with spacetime dimension $D = 4-2\epsilon$
• Naive dimensional regularization (NDR) used for handling $\gamma_5$

Key Technical Insights

The authors discovered an important kinematic reduction: at one-loop level, the triangle diagram contribution from class-7 operators vanishes because the pure s-channel depends on $(p_1+p_2)$ while the scalar flow contraction yields $(p_1-p_2)$. This allows neglecting all two-loop diagrams where both external Higgs bosons connect to the effective vertex.

Computational Verification

Two independent computational pipelines employed:

1. Pipeline 1: FeynRules + FeynArts + FeynCalc + AMFlow + Blade
2. Pipeline 2: qgraf + FeynCalc + AMFlow + LiteRed2 + FiniteFlow

Technical Innovations

1. Kinematic Simplification: Discovery and exploitation of kinematic cancellation in s-channel diagrams, substantially simplifying computational complexity.
2. $\gamma_5$ Scheme Treatment: Systematic analysis of differences between NDR and BMHV schemes, demonstrating their equivalence in this calculation.
3. Redundant Operator Treatment: Careful consideration of redundant operator renormalization contributions and verification that they vanish.

Main Results

Two-Loop RGE Contributions

The complete two-loop RGE result is:

$\mu \frac{dC_{HG}}{d\mu} \supset \frac{g_s^2}{(16\pi^2)^2} \left[ Y_b Y_b^* (C_{Hb} - C_{HQ}^{(1)} - 3C_{HQ}^{(3)}) + Y_t Y_t^* (C_{HQ}^{(1)} - 3C_{HQ}^{(3)} - C_{Ht}) \right.$

$\left. + (C_{Htb}Y_b Y_t^* + C_{Htb}^* Y_b^* Y_t) - \left(C_{H\square} - \frac{1}{2}C_{HD}\right)(Y_b Y_b^* + Y_t Y_t^*) \right.$

$\left. + \frac{3}{2}[C_{tH}Y_t + C_{tH}^* Y_t^* + C_{bH}Y_b + C_{bH}^* Y_b^*] + \text{four-quark terms} \right]$

where the first two lines represent new results from this work.

Phenomenological Implications

Single-Parameter Fit Results

• Class-3 operator constraints ($C_{H\square}, C_{HD}$) are minimally affected by two-loop effects
• Among class-7 operators, $C_{HQ}^{(3)}$ shows significant constraint tightening
• $C_{Ht}$ and $C_{HQ}^{(1)}$ exhibit moderate improvement
• $C_{Htb}$ constraints weaken at two-loop level, suggesting cancellation effects

Two-Parameter Fits

Two-parameter fits reveal inter-operator correlations:

• Class-3 operators primarily enter observables through the linear combination $C_{H,\text{kin}} = C_{H\square} - \frac{1}{4}C_{HD}$
• $C_{HQ}^{(1)}$ and $C_{HQ}^{(3)}$ typically appear simultaneously in UV models
• Constraints on $C_{Ht}$ and $C_{Hb}$ show significant improvement

Vector-Like Quark Model Analysis

In concrete UV-complete models:

• Five models containing vector-like quark pairs are considered
• One-loop matching generates additional operators, weakening relative two-loop running effects
• When considering only tree-level matching, two-loop effects become more pronounced

Technical Details

Feynman Rules

The paper appendix provides complete Feynman rules for effective operators, including:

• Higgs-gluon-gluon vertex: $+4iC_{HG}\delta^{i_3i_4}\delta^{A_1A_2}(p_1^{\mu_2}p_2^{\mu_1} - g^{\mu_1\mu_2}p_1 \cdot p_2)$
• Feynman rules for various class-7 operators

Computational Verification

• Verification of infrared divergence cancellation
• Examination of scale-independent integral treatment
• Confirmation that redundant operator contributions vanish

Related Work

This paper builds upon and extends the following important works:

1. Jenkins, Manohar, Trott (2013-2014): Established the complete one-loop RGE framework
2. Di Noi et al. (2024): Two-loop contributions from four-quark operators
3. Di Noi, Gröber, Mandal (2024): Two-loop contributions from Yukawa-type operators

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Completes the calculation of class-3 and class-7 operator contributions to the two-loop RGE of the Higgs-gluon coupling.
2. Two-loop running effects can produce significant phenomenological implications for loosely constrained operators (such as $C_{HQ}^{(3)}$).
3. In concrete UV models, other operators generated through one-loop matching reduce the relative importance of two-loop running.

Limitations

1. Only third-generation quark contributions are considered.
2. Color-magnetic operator contributions are not included (generated only at loop level in weakly-coupled theory).
3. Phenomenological analysis is based solely on inclusive Higgs data, excluding electroweak precision measurements.

Future Directions

1. Complete the full two-loop SMEFT RGE calculation.
2. Extend results to analogous operators for electroweak bosons.
3. Assess two-loop effects in broader global fits.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: Results verified through two independent computational pipelines, with careful treatment of technical details such as $\gamma_5$ schemes.
2. Computational Innovation: Discovery and exploitation of kinematic reduction substantially simplifies computational complexity.
3. Phenomenological Relevance: Provides not only theoretical calculations but also systematic analysis of phenomenological implications.
4. Completeness: Fills an important theoretical gap by completing the two-loop renormalization program for tree-level operators.

Limitations

1. Scope of Applicability: Limited to third-generation quarks; contributions from light quark generations not considered.
2. Phenomenological Analysis: Based on relatively limited datasets, excluding broader experimental constraints.
3. UV Models: Only vector-like quark models considered; other types of UV completions not addressed.

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Establishes important foundation for complete two-loop SMEFT RGE calculations.
2. Phenomenological Value: Provides necessary theoretical tools for precise Higgs physics analysis.
3. Methodological Significance: Established computational framework applicable to similar problems.

Application Scenarios

1. Theoretical analysis of high-precision Higgs coupling measurements.
2. Global SMEFT fits over large energy scale ranges.
3. Phenomenological studies of concrete UV models.
4. Theoretical predictions for future collider experiments.

References

The paper cites 97 references, covering important works in SMEFT theoretical framework, renormalization group equation calculations, phenomenological analysis, and other relevant areas, reflecting the complete development trajectory of the field.