If You Hold Me Without Hurting Me: Pathways to Designing Game Audio for Healthy Escapism and Player Well-being

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14691
• Title: If You Hold Me Without Hurting Me: Pathways to Designing Game Audio for Healthy Escapism and Player Well-being
• Authors: Caio Nunes, Bosco Borges, Georgia Cruz, Ticianne Darin (Federal University of Ceará, Brazil)
• Classification: cs.HC (Human-Computer Interaction), cs.MM (Multimedia), cs.SD (Sound)
• Conference: CHI PLAY 2025 Workshop - Exploring Future Directions for Healthy Escapism and Self-Regulation in Games
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14691v1

Abstract

Escapism in games can both support recovery and lead to harmful avoidance behaviors. Self-regulation—combining autonomy and positive outcomes—is key to distinguishing between the two. This paper argues that audio, often overlooked, plays a central role in regulation by modulating arousal levels, marking transitions, and providing closure, yet its contribution to well-being remains underexplored. The paper identifies methodological and accessibility gaps limiting the recognition of audio's potential and outlines pathways to address these issues. It aims to encourage researchers and developers to more consciously integrate audio into the design and research of healthier escapist games.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Research Question

How can game audio design promote healthy escapism and enhance player self-regulation capabilities?

Problem Significance

1. Dual Nature of Escapism: Game escapism can provide stress relief and emotional regulation, yet may also reinforce avoidance behaviors and interfere with daily functioning
2. Critical Role of Self-Regulation: Based on Self-Determination Theory (SDT), self-regulation capacity determines whether escapist gaming supports recovery or becomes harmful
3. Unique Potential of Audio: Audio possesses universality and low cognitive load processing characteristics, enabling unconscious influence on arousal and emotional states

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Fragmented Research: Game audio research primarily focuses on immersion and emotion, rarely connecting to well-being or self-regulation processes
2. Methodological Blind Spots: Self-report measurements frequently conflict with physiological data, making it difficult to draw conclusions about coping and stress recovery
3. Missing Accessibility: Systematic evaluation and transparency regarding audio design for sensitive populations (e.g., autistic players) are lacking

Research Motivation

The authors contend that audio is not a peripheral function but a core designable mechanism supporting healthy escapism, yet currently lacks systematic research and design guidance.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework Construction: Establishes the theoretical position of audio in healthy escapism, positioning it as a key design element for self-regulation
2. Problem Identification: Systematically identifies methodological and accessibility gaps hindering audio's role in player well-being
3. Design Guidance: Proposes three specific future research directions, providing pathways for audio to support self-regulation and positive emotional outcomes
4. Interdisciplinary Integration: Connects game research, audio technology, psychology, and accessibility design across multiple domains

Methodology

Research Approach

The paper adopts a position paper format, primarily employing literature review and theoretical analysis to construct its arguments.

Theoretical Foundation

Self-Determination Theory (SDT) Framework

• Self-Regulation Definition: The degree to which behavior is experienced as autonomous, reflecting choice and volition rather than external pressure
• Healthy Escapism Criteria:
  • Autonomy: Players can autonomously decide when to start, how long to continue, and when to disengage
  • Positive Outcomes: Psychological relief is supported by physiological recovery

Unique Attributes of Audio

1. Universal Processing: Unlike visual cues requiring focused attention, sound possesses universality and lower cognitive load
2. Unconscious Influence: Capable of unconsciously influencing arousal and emotional states
3. Temporal Structuring: Audio's rhythm transition capability provides subtle yet substantive means to support player awareness

Analytical Framework

Literature Review Methodology

• Game Audio Assessment Research: Reviews relevant literature on audio and player experience evaluation
• Autistic Player Gaming Research: Analyzes 49 game studies involving autistic players, finding only 14% (n=7) explicitly assessed audio

Gap Identification Method

Through systematic literature analysis, two major gap categories are identified:

1. Methodological Gaps: Inconsistency between self-report and physiological data, lack of personalization, audio neglect in high-sensory environments
2. Accessibility Gaps: Missing design transparency, overlooked diverse auditory needs

Experimental Setup

Literature Analysis Scope

• Game Audio Research: Systematic review of research on audio and player experience evaluation
• Special Population Research: Focused analysis of 49 game studies involving autistic players

Evaluation Dimensions

1. Methodological Completeness: Assessment of whether studies employ multimodal evaluation methods
2. Design Transparency: Analysis of whether studies clearly report audio design intentions
3. Accessibility Considerations: Examination of whether diverse auditory needs are addressed

Experimental Results

Key Findings

Methodological Fragmentation

• Measurement Inconsistency: Players may report feeling calm while arousal markers remain elevated
• Assessment Limitations: Lack of reliable methods to determine audio's impact on recovery

Severe Accessibility Deficiency

• Autistic Player Research: Only 7 of 49 studies (14%) explicitly assessed audio
• Missing Design Transparency: Studies merely indicate sound presence without clarifying how audio was produced or its regulatory purpose

Insufficient Self-Regulation Support

• Lacking Design Intent: No designs leveraging audio to create natural stopping points
• Player Self-Management: Players employ workarounds such as muting or replacing game soundtracks

Specific Case Analysis

Positive Design Examples

• Safe Exit Points: Marked through transitions to calmer music in central areas
• Closure Themes: Clear ending themes following tasks
• Breathing Windows: Brief silences following high-tension moments

Negative Impact Cases

• Forced Avoidance: Repetitive or insufficiently tested audio reinforcing compulsive immersion
• Overstimulation: Potential overload for auditory-sensitive populations

Related Work

Game Escapism Research

• Motivation Theory: Escapism as a core element in player motivation models 4,7,19
• Healthy vs. Harmful Distinction: Kosa & Uysal's (2020) four-pillar theory of healthy escapism 9

Audio and Emotional Regulation

• Music Therapy Foundation: Well-documented connections between music and physiological responses 5,8
• Game Audio Research: Primarily focused on immersion, presence, arousal, and emotion 10

Accessibility Design

• Special Population Needs: Auditory sensitivity issues in autistic players 1,12
• Inclusive Design: Lack of standardized audio accessibility guidelines

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Central Position of Audio: Audio is not a peripheral function but a core designable mechanism supporting healthy escapism
2. Systemic Gaps Exist: Current research and design contain systemic gaps in methodology and accessibility
3. Significant Design Opportunities: Intentional audio design can substantially improve player self-regulation capabilities

Future Research Directions

1. Adopting Multimodal Assessment

• Integrating Multiple Measures: Combining self-report, behavioral tracking, and psychophysiological markers
• Behavioral Indicators: Muting, playlist swapping, and volume drops as practical scalable proxies
• Convergence Analysis: Identifying specific indicators of design success and overload/recovery

2. Transparent Reporting of Design Intent

• Explicit Regulatory Purpose: Report how audio was produced and what regulatory purpose it serves
• Specific Technical Decisions:
  • Adding low-beat loops after combat to support recovery
  • Brief silence windows after repeated failures encouraging pauses
  • Ending themes marking transitions to safe central areas

3. Promoting Research-Industry Collaboration

• Shared Agenda: Joint workshops, customizable regulatory audio pattern libraries
• Adaptive Audio Systems: Developing common production guidelines similar to existing accessibility standards

Limitations

1. Theoretical Nature: As a position paper, lacks empirical validation
2. Implementation Challenges: Complexity in translating theory to practical design implementation
3. Individual Differences: Significant individual variation in player responses to audio

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Innovative Perspective: First systematic connection of game audio to healthy escapism
2. Interdisciplinary Integration: Successfully integrates psychology, audio technology, game design, and accessibility research
3. Practical Value: Provides concrete actionable research and design directions
4. Social Significance: Addresses player well-being with important social implications

Weaknesses

1. Lack of Empirical Support: Primarily based on theoretical analysis, lacking experimental validation
2. Implementation Complexity: Translation pathway from theory to actual design remains unclear
3. Measurement Challenges: Specific implementation of multimodal assessment methods faces technical hurdles
4. Cultural Differences: Insufficient consideration of audio perception variations across cultural backgrounds

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Opens new research directions for game audio studies
2. Industry Value: Provides design guidance for game developers
3. Social Impact: Promotes healthier game development
4. Reproducibility: Provides clear research framework facilitating subsequent studies

Applicable Scenarios

1. Therapeutic Games: Particularly suitable for designing games for special populations
2. Casual Games: Helps design better relaxation and recovery experiences
3. Educational Games: Supports learner emotional regulation and focus management
4. Accessibility Design: Provides better gaming experiences for auditory-sensitive populations

Research Questions and Considerations

The paper concludes with four key research questions:

1. Measurement Combination: Which combinations of self-report, behavioral, and physiological measures best capture audio's regulatory effects?
2. Design Strategies: How can soundscapes, UI sound closure cues, and music be designed to make transitions between immersion and disengagement more conscious?
3. Player Control: What forms of player audio control promote genuine autonomy in shaping the escapist experience?
4. Standardized Patterns: Which standardized or repeated sound patterns are being unreflectively used, and how can their well-being impacts be better understood?

This paper opens an important new direction for game audio design, closely connecting technical design with player well-being, and provides both theoretical foundations and practical guidance for constructing healthier gaming experiences.