The Predictive Power of the Calculated Line Lists of Carbon Monoxide

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14747
• Title: The predictive power of the calculated line lists of carbon monoxide
• Authors: E. S. Medvedev, V. G. Ushakov
• Affiliation: Federal Research Center of Problems of Chemical Physics and Medicinal Chemistry, Russian Academy of Sciences
• Classification: physics.chem-ph astro-ph.EP astro-ph.GA astro-ph.SR
• Submission Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14747

Abstract

This paper validates the predictive capability of semi-empirical irregular dipole moment functions (2022 and 2025 versions) developed by the authors through comparison with the latest measurement results of the 0-0, 1-0, 3-0, and 7-0 vibrational bands. The study demonstrates the ability to predict unobserved spectral line intensities and describe observed spectral lines not used in the fitting procedure.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Context

1. Spectral Database Requirements: Spectral databases such as HITRAN and ExoMol require collection of molecular spectral line parameters, including not only observed spectral lines but also predicted data for unobserved lines.
2. Challenges in Predictive Capability: The functional form of molecular functions strongly influences calculation results, particularly for high overtone transitions, making accurate prediction of unobserved spectral lines an extremely challenging task.
3. Importance of CO Molecule: Carbon monoxide, as an important atmospheric and astrophysical molecule, requires precise spectroscopic data for applications in atmospheric remote sensing, astrophysics, and related fields.

Research Motivation

• To validate the predictive capability of semi-empirical irregular dipole moment functions
• To assess the accuracy of different spectral line lists in describing experimental data
• To provide reliable prediction methods for spectral databases

Core Contributions

1. Validation of Predictive Capability: Through comparison with the latest high-precision experimental data, the paper demonstrates that semi-empirical irregular dipole moment functions can effectively predict the intensities of unobserved spectral lines.
2. Systematic Performance Comparison: Comparative analysis of three different line lists (LL1, LL2, LL3) with the HITRAN2020 database.
3. High-Precision Verification: Utilization of extremely high-precision intensity ratio data (experimental error as low as 0.003%) measured using methods developed by Li et al.
4. Theoretical Method Advantages: Demonstration of the superiority of semi-empirical irregular and rational dipole moment functions compared to polynomial fitting methods for predicting high overtone transitions.

Methodology Details

Types of Dipole Moment Functions

The authors developed three types of dipole moment functions:

1. Regular Dipole Moment Function (LL1): Single-valued function with no branch points in the complex plane
2. Irregular Dipole Moment Function (LL2): Multi-valued function with branch points
3. Rational Dipole Moment Function: Ratio of two polynomials

Spectral Line List Construction Process

LL1 Construction

• Utilization of all available experimental data at the time
• Integration with ab initio calculated dipole moment functions
• Restriction to transitions with Δv ≤ 6

LL2 Construction

• Use of the same input dataset as LL1
• Adoption of irregular dipole moment functions
• No Δv restrictions
• Error estimation provided through rational dipole moment functions

LL3 Construction

• Exclusion of 1-0 band data with systematic errors
• Inclusion of 7-0 band measurement data from Balashov et al.
• Inclusion of high-precision 3-0 band data from Bielska et al. and Hodges et al.

Technical Innovations

1. Irregular Dipole Moment Functions: Introduction of multi-valued functions with branch points enables better description of physical behavior in high overtone transitions.
2. Semi-Empirical Approach: Combination of experimental data and ab initio calculations balances accuracy and predictability.
3. Error Estimation Mechanism: Qualitative error estimates provided through comparison of irregular and rational dipole moment function results.

Experimental Setup

Validation Datasets

The paper employed multiple independent high-precision experimental datasets for validation:

1. 0-0 Band: Pure rotational transition data from Tretyakov et al.
2. 1-0 Band: Latest measurement results from Bailey et al.
3. 3-0 Band:
   • CRDS and CMDS measurements from Huang et al.
   • Intensity ratio measurements from Li et al.
   • Dispersive heterodyne cavity ringdown spectroscopy measurements from Cygan et al.
4. 7-0 Band: Measurement data from Balashov et al.

Evaluation Metrics

1. Relative Deviation: Δ = 100(O-C)/O, where O is the observed value and C is the calculated value
2. Conformity Rate Within Experimental Uncertainty: Percentage of spectral lines falling within experimental error ranges
3. Einstein A Coefficient: Used for comparison of high overtone transitions

Comparison Methods

• HITRAN2020 database
• Sixth-order polynomial dipole moment function from Zobov et al.
• Other ab initio dipole moment functions

Experimental Results

Main Results

Absolute Intensity Comparison (Table 1)

• 0-0 Band: All line lists performed perfectly with relative deviations <0.1%
• 1-0 Band: LL3 performed excellently (-0.4%), while LL1 and LL2 failed due to early data with systematic errors
• 3-0 Band:
  • LL1 performed satisfactorily
  • LL2 and LL3 performed better, with most spectral lines showing deviations <0.2%
• 7-0 Band: LL3 completely within experimental uncertainty, LL2 predictions with deviations <14% (far smaller than the estimated 30% theoretical uncertainty)

Performance Statistics

• LL3: 70% of spectral lines within experimental uncertainty ranges
• HITRAN2020: Significantly poorer performance, particularly for high overtone transitions

Intensity Ratio Verification (Table 2)

Ultra-high-precision intensity ratio measurements from Li et al. demonstrate:

• Differences between observation and calculation far exceed experimental error
• Differences above R(15)/P(15) ratio <0.1%
• Differences below R(15)/P(15) ratio <0.2%
• Sufficient precision for practical applications

NIDL Analysis (Figure 1)

• Irregular and rational dipole moment functions perfectly follow NIDL (Natural Intensity Distribution Law)
• Zobov et al.'s polynomial method does not follow NIDL
• Absolute standard deviation only 0.05

Key Findings

1. Predictive Capability Validation: LL2 predictions prior to 7-0 band measurements show high agreement with subsequent experimental results
2. Systematic Improvement: LL3 shows significant improvement over LL2 due to inclusion of new high-precision data
3. Method Advantages: Semi-empirical irregular dipole moment functions outperform existing ab initio methods in predicting unobserved spectral lines

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Ab Initio Calculations: Multiple research groups have developed different ab initio dipole moment functions
2. Experimental Measurements: Continuous development of high-precision spectroscopic measurement techniques
3. Database Construction: Ongoing updates to databases such as HITRAN and ExoMol

Advantages of This Work

1. Predictive Capability: Compared to other ab initio methods, this paper's approach has demonstrated reliable predictive capability
2. Precision Assessment: Provides quantitative error estimation mechanisms
3. Broad Applicability: Covers a wide range of transitions from fundamental to high overtone bands

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Confirmation of Predictive Capability: Semi-empirical irregular dipole moment functions can reliably predict intensities of unobserved spectral lines
2. Precision Level: Achieves sub-percentage or experimental precision levels for all observed bands (0-0 to 7-0)
3. Practical Value: Provides sufficiently accurate predictions for spectral databases and practical applications

Limitations

1. Ultra-High Precision Requirements: For 0.003% level experimental precision, additional parameters may be required for refitting
2. High Overtone Uncertainty: Theoretical uncertainty for higher overtone transitions remains substantial
3. Method Complexity: Mathematical treatment of irregular functions is more complex than conventional polynomials

Future Directions

1. Higher Precision Fitting: Semi-empirical refitting targeting ultra-high precision experimental data
2. Extended Applications: Generalization of the method to other important diatomic molecules
3. Theoretical Development: Further understanding of the physical significance of irregular dipole moment functions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: Introduction of irregular dipole moment functions represents an important methodological innovation
2. Comprehensive Validation: Thorough verification using multiple independent high-precision experimental datasets
3. Practical Value: Provides reliable prediction tools for spectral databases
4. Theoretical Insights: NIDL analysis reveals fundamental differences between different methods

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical Foundation: Physical interpretation of irregular dipole moment functions requires further development
2. Computational Complexity: More complex implementation compared to simple polynomial methods
3. Parameter Optimization: Parameter optimization strategies need improvement for extreme precision requirements

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for molecular spectroscopy
2. Practical Value: Directly serves applications in atmospheric science, astrophysics, and related fields
3. Methodological Significance: Demonstrates advantages of semi-empirical methods in molecular spectral prediction

Applicable Scenarios

1. Spectral Database Construction: Provides high-quality predicted data for databases such as HITRAN
2. Atmospheric Remote Sensing: Supports precise measurement of atmospheric CO concentrations
3. Astrophysics: Provides fundamental data for spectral analysis of stellar and planetary atmospheres
4. Experimental Planning: Provides theoretical guidance for high overtone transition experiments

References

The paper cites 30 related references, primarily including:

• Core literature on HITRAN and ExoMol databases
• Latest experimental measurement results for CO molecular spectroscopy
• Theoretical development of ab initio dipole moment functions
• Methodological literature on high-precision spectroscopic measurement techniques

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality molecular spectroscopy paper that systematically validates the advantages of semi-empirical irregular dipole moment functions in CO molecular spectral prediction. The paper demonstrates clear methodological innovation, comprehensive experimental validation, and significant practical value for molecular spectral database construction and related application fields.