Stellar population astrophysics (SPA) with the TNG. The Phosphorus abundance on the young side of MilkyWay

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14791
• Title: Stellar population astrophysics (SPA) with the TNG. The Phosphorus abundance on the young side of MilkyWay
• Authors: Mingjie Jian, Xiaoting Fu, Valentina D'Orazi, Angela Bragaglia, S. Bijavara Seshashayana, He Zhao, Ziyi Guo, Karin Lind, Noriyuki Matsunaga, Antonino Nunnari, Giuseppe Bono, Nicoletta Sanna, Donatella Romano, Marina Dal Ponte
• Classification: astro-ph.SR (Stellar and Stellar Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: Preprint, October 17, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14791

Abstract

This study presents phosphorus abundance measurements for 102 giant stars (including 82 stars in 24 open clusters and 20 Cepheid variables) based on high-resolution near-infrared spectra obtained with GIANO-B. Despite the importance of phosphorus in astrophysics and biology, its abundance evolution remains poorly understood due to scarcity of observational data. By combining precise stellar parameters from optical wavelengths, robust spectral line selection, and measurement methodologies, the research team measured phosphorus abundances using available P I spectral lines. The analysis confirms the trend of P/Fe declining with increasing Fe/H near solar metallicity in clusters and Cepheids, consistent with previous studies. The study also reports the P/Fe-age relationship in open clusters older than 1 Gyr, indicating a time-dependent enrichment pattern.

Research Background and Motivation

Scientific Questions

The role of phosphorus in Galactic chemical evolution remains unclear, facing the following challenges:

1. Observational Difficulties: Observable phosphorus spectral lines are primarily located in ultraviolet and infrared wavelengths, with sparse optical lines, making abundance measurements based on optical spectroscopy nearly impossible
2. Data Scarcity: High-quality phosphorus abundance measurements are extremely limited due to severe interstellar extinction affecting ultraviolet observations
3. Theory-Observation Discrepancy: Existing Galactic chemical evolution models struggle to fully explain the observed phosphorus abundance distribution patterns

Research Significance

The importance of phosphorus research is demonstrated through:

1. Galactic Archaeology Value: Phosphorus abundance patterns can reveal the chemical evolution history of different Galactic components
2. Nucleosynthesis Theory Verification: Phosphorus is primarily produced by massive stars; its abundance distribution can verify stellar nucleosynthesis theory
3. Biological Significance: Phosphorus is an essential element for life; understanding its distribution in the Galaxy is crucial for studying the origin of life

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Small Sample Sizes: Previous studies typically involved fewer than dozens of stars
• Large Age Uncertainties: Age determination for field stars is difficult, with errors typically reaching several billion years
• Wavelength Coverage Constraints: Single-wavelength observations cannot simultaneously obtain precise stellar parameters and phosphorus abundances

Core Contributions

1. Large-Sample High-Precision Measurements: First systematic phosphorus abundance measurements for 102 stars, including member stars of 24 open clusters
2. Discovery of "V-Shaped" Evolutionary Pattern: Reveals a unique "V-shaped" structure in the phosphorus abundance-age relationship, reflecting two distinct chemical evolution mechanisms
3. Technical Method Innovation: Develops an analysis pipeline combining optical and near-infrared simultaneous observations, significantly improving measurement precision
4. Theoretical Explanation Framework: Proposes a theoretical explanation based on multi-zone Galactic chemical evolution, distinguishing between early rapid enrichment and recent slow enrichment phases

Methodology Details

Observational Data Acquisition

The study uses the GIARPS mode of the TNG telescope, simultaneously obtaining:

• GIANO-B: Near-infrared spectrum (0.9-2.45 μm, R=50,000)
• HARPS-N: Optical spectrum (0.383-0.690 μm, R=115,000)

This synchronized observation eliminates temporal variations affecting spectral line measurements.

Stellar Parameter Determination

Adopts stellar parameters determined by Dal Ponte et al. (2025) based on HARPS-N spectra:

• Effective temperature (Teff)
• Surface gravity (log g)
• Iron abundance (Fe/H)
• Microturbulence velocity (Vmic)

Phosphorus Abundance Measurement Procedure

Spectral Line Selection Strategy

Develops an automated spectral line selection method based on synthetic spectra:

1. Feature Definition: Defines feature regions with width 4Vbroad/c for each P I spectral line
2. Quality Assessment: Evaluates spectral line applicability using three parameters:
   • Feature dominance > 0.4 (P line contribution ratio)
   • Feature depth > 0.006 (maximum absorption depth)
   • Atmospheric absorption depth < 0.1 (avoiding atmospheric contamination)

Abundance Fitting Method

Uses PySME code for spectral synthesis and abundance fitting:

1. Masking Strategy: Classifies pixels into three categories: continuum, spectral lines, and bad pixels
2. χ² Minimization: Minimizes χ² between observed and synthetic spectra in the line region
3. Quality Control: Excludes spectral line measurements with excessively small equivalent widths or systematic deviations

Technical Innovations

1. Multi-Wavelength Coordination: First systematic combination of optical stellar parameters and infrared phosphorus abundance measurements
2. Automated Pipeline: Develops an automated spectral line selection and abundance measurement pipeline applicable to large samples
3. Molecular Line Treatment: Develops specialized handling strategies for CN and CO molecular line contamination

Experimental Setup

Target Sample

• Open Clusters: 82 giant stars in 24 clusters, with ages ranging from 0.04-4.27 Gyr
• Cepheid Variables: 20 stars (17 field stars + 3 cluster members), with ages determined through period-age relationships
• Standard Stars: Sun and Arcturus used for method verification

Data Quality

• Signal-to-Noise Ratio: Average S/N > 200
• Spectral Resolution: R = 50,000 (GIANO-B)
• Wavelength Coverage: Includes 27 usable P I spectral lines

Analysis Tools

• Spectral Synthesis: PySME + MARCS model atmospheres
• Spectral Line Data: VALD3 database
• Atmospheric Correction: TelFit software package

Experimental Results

Solar Phosphorus Abundance Verification

Measured solar phosphorus abundance A(P) = 5.46 ± 0.20, consistent with Scott et al. (2015) value of 5.38, verifying method reliability.

Main Observational Results

P/Fe-Fe/H Relationship

Within the metallicity range Fe/H = -0.1 to +0.15:

• Confirms the trend of P/Fe declining with increasing Fe/H
• P/Fe decreases from ~0.3 to ~0, leveling off near solar metallicity
• Consistent with results from Nandakumar et al. (2022) and other studies

"V-Shaped" Age-Abundance Relationship

Discovers a unique "V-shaped" relationship between phosphorus abundance and age:

1. Old Clusters (> 1 Gyr):
   • Both A(P) and P/Fe increase with age
   • Linear fitting shows significant positive correlation (p < 0.05)
   • M67 (4.27 Gyr) displays the highest phosphorus abundance
2. Young Clusters and Cepheids (< 1 Gyr):
   • Phosphorus abundance remains relatively flat with slight upward trend
   • Reflects recent slow chemical evolution processes

Spatial Distribution Analysis

Within the Galactic disk (Rgc = 7-10 kpc), phosphorus abundance shows no significant correlation with current spatial position, reflecting radial migration effects of stars in the Galaxy.

Theoretical Interpretation

Rapid Enrichment History of Old Clusters

Clusters older than 1 Gyr exhibit phosphorus abundance increasing with age, reflecting:

1. Different Star Formation Histories: Gas clouds during old cluster formation experienced faster and more intense enrichment processes
2. Massive Star Contribution: Rapid enrichment requires higher star formation rates or more "top-heavy" initial mass functions
3. Multi-Zone Evolution: The Galaxy is not a single uniform system; different regions have different chemical evolution histories

Local Evolution of Young Objects

The flat phosphorus abundance trends in young clusters and Cepheids suggest:

1. Common Chemical History: These objects formed near the Sun, sharing similar recent chemical evolution histories
2. Low-Mass Star Contribution: During relatively quiescent evolution stages, contributions from low-mass stars such as AGB stars become important
3. Single-Zone Model Applicability: Recent local evolution can be described using simple single-zone chemical evolution models

Comparison with Related Work

Historical Research Review

• Caffau et al. (2011): First systematic phosphorus abundance study, sample of 20 F-type dwarfs
• Roederer et al. (2014): Extended to metal-poor regions using HST observations
• Hawkins et al. (2016): First large-scale APOGEE survey data analysis
• Nandakumar et al. (2022): High-resolution study using IGRINS

Advantages of This Study

1. Sample Advantage: First large-scale systematic study of open cluster member stars
2. Age Precision: Achieves high-precision ages using cluster isochrone fitting
3. Time Span: Covers broad age range of 0.04-4.27 Gyr
4. Advanced Technology: Synchronized optical-infrared observations improve parameter precision

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Trend Confirmation: Verifies the universal trend of P/Fe declining with increasing metallicity
2. Discovery of "V-Shaped" Pattern: First revelation of dual evolutionary modes in the phosphorus abundance-age relationship
3. Theoretical Explanation: Proposes a physical explanation framework based on differences in star formation history
4. Method Verification: Establishes a reliable multi-wavelength phosphorus abundance measurement method

Limitations

1. Metallicity Range: Sample primarily concentrated near solar metallicity, lacking extremely metal-poor stars
2. NLTE Effects: Currently lacks non-local thermodynamic equilibrium corrections for phosphorus
3. Theoretical Uncertainties: Uncertainties in nucleosynthesis yields affect theoretical interpretation
4. Sample Bias: Giant star sample may have selection effects

Future Directions

1. Sample Expansion: More observations of metal-poor and metal-rich stars needed
2. NLTE Calculations: Development of non-local thermodynamic equilibrium theory for phosphorus
3. Nucleosynthesis Improvement: More precise stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis models
4. Other Elements: Comparative studies of age-abundance relationships for other elements

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High Scientific Value: First systematic revelation of phosphorus dual evolutionary modes, significant for Galactic chemical evolution research
2. Method Innovation: Developed multi-wavelength coordinated analysis method has broad application prospects
3. Excellent Data Quality: High-resolution spectra and precise age determination ensure result reliability
4. Reasonable Theoretical Explanation: Explanation framework based on multi-zone chemical evolution has physical foundation

Weaknesses

1. Sample Limitations: Relatively narrow metallicity range limits universality of conclusions
2. Theory Dependence: Some explanations depend on theoretical model assumptions
3. Statistical Testing: Statistical significance of certain trends requires verification with larger samples
4. Systematic Errors: Potentially unconsidered systematic error sources may exist

Impact Assessment

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new observational constraints for Galactic chemical evolution research
2. Method Promotion: Developed analysis pipeline applicable to other element studies
3. Theory Advancement: Promotes development of multi-zone chemical evolution models
4. Technical Demonstration: Provides exemplar for large survey project data analysis

Applicable Scenarios

1. Galactic Archaeology: Study chemical evolution history of different Galactic components
2. Stellar Physics: Verify and improve stellar nucleosynthesis theory
3. Observational Astrophysics: Provide analysis methods for future large survey projects
4. Comparative Planetology: Understand phosphorus distribution in planetary systems and conditions for life origin

References

This study cites important literature from multiple fields including Galactic chemical evolution, stellar spectroscopy, and nucleosynthesis theory, particularly:

• Caffau et al. (2011, 2016, 2019): Pioneering work on phosphorus abundance measurements
• Nandakumar et al. (2022): Recent high-resolution phosphorus abundance research
• Scott et al. (2015): Standard solar phosphorus abundance values
• Cantat-Gaudin et al. (2020): Open cluster parameters and ages
• Related nucleosynthesis yield and chemical evolution model literature

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality observational astrophysics paper that systematically reveals for the first time the dual evolutionary modes of phosphorus in the Galaxy. The research employs advanced methods, excellent data quality, and scientifically significant conclusions. Although there is room for improvement in sample coverage range and theoretical interpretation, it makes important contributions to Galactic chemical evolution research with substantial academic value and application prospects.