Exploring a cosmic ray inverse-Compton origin to the SZ-to-X-ray pressure deficit in the cool core cluster ZwCl 3146

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14820
• Title: Exploring a cosmic ray inverse-Compton origin to the SZ-to-X-ray pressure deficit in the cool core cluster ZwCl 3146
• Authors: Emily M. Silich, Jack Sayers, Philip F. Hopkins, Charles Romero, Brian Mason, John Orlowski-Scherer, Craig L. Sarazin
• Classification: astro-ph.HE (High Energy Astrophysics), astro-ph.CO (Cosmology and Extragalactic Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: October 17, 2025 (Draft version)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14820v1

Abstract

This study investigates the possibility that ~GeV cosmic rays injected by central active galactic nuclei (AGN) produce non-negligible continuum X-ray signals through inverse-Compton (IC) scattering with cosmic microwave background photons, signals that can be easily misinterpreted as thermal bremsstrahlung continuum from the intracluster medium (ICM). This is particularly important for the cooling flow problem in cool core galaxy clusters. The research employs ZwCl 3146 (z=0.291), a relaxed cool core system, comparing pressure profiles derived through X-ray and thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) observations. Within the central 100 kpc of ZwCl 3146, a ~30% deficit in PSZ/PX relative to unity is measured, with statistical significance of ~3.3σ, consistent with predictions from AGN-driven cosmic ray injection models.

Research Background and Motivation

The Cooling Flow Problem

The core regions (r ≲ 100 kpc) of cool core galaxy clusters exhibit radiative cooling timescales shorter than several Gyr, yet the cooling rates inferred from X-ray observations far exceed the star formation rates observed in the central brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs). This discrepancy is known as the "cooling flow problem."

Limitations of Existing Solutions

Current self-regulated feedback models require fine-tuning between ICM thermodynamics and AGN accretion rates. While plausible tuning mechanisms have been proposed, the underlying physical processes remain unclear.

New Perspective from Cosmic Ray Inverse-Compton Scattering

• Low-energy cosmic rays (E ~ 0.1-1 GeV) have long lifetimes (~Gyr) and can diffuse to large radii (~100 kpc)
• IC scattering of these cosmic rays with CMB photons produces ~keV X-ray emission
• This emission exhibits spectral characteristics similar to thermal continuum and may be mistaken for ICM thermal radiation

Core Contributions

1. First Observational Evidence: Detection of statistically significant (3.3σ) SZ-X-ray pressure ratio deficit in ZwCl 3146
2. Systematic Analysis: Comprehensive assessment of various systematic errors and physical processes that could produce the pressure ratio deficit
3. Theoretical Verification: Demonstration that observational results are consistent with cosmic ray-IC model predictions
4. Methodological Innovation: Establishment of an observational method utilizing SZ-X-ray pressure ratios to test cosmic ray contributions
5. Spectral Verification: Confirmation of cosmic ray-IC presence through dual-component X-ray spectral fitting

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Compare gas pressure profiles independently measured through SZ observations and X-ray observations in the same galaxy cluster, testing the contribution of cosmic ray-IC scattering to X-ray emission.

Observational Data Processing

SZ Data Analysis (MUSTANG-2)

• Utilizes MUSTANG-2 on the Green Bank Telescope with 10″ FWHM resolution
• Employs time-domain analysis methods to recover pressure profiles
• Fits annular surface brightness profiles and point source models using MCMC chains

X-ray Data Analysis (Chandra)

• Uses Chandra observations (ObsIDs 909 and 9371) with total exposure time of 86 ks
• Implements data reduction using CIAO 4.16
• Performs spherically symmetric deprojection analysis
• Conducts spectral fitting using tbabs × apec model

Pressure Profile Calculation

SZ Pressure (PSZ)

PSZ directly reflects thermal electron pressure: PSZ ∝ ∫ ne dl

X-ray Pressure (PX)

PX is calculated from density and temperature: PX = ne · kT where ne is derived from apec normalization and temperature is obtained from spectral fitting

Technical Innovations

1. Large-radius Normalization: Utilizes pressure ratios at >100 kpc to normalize away X-ray calibration uncertainties
2. Systematic Error Quantification: Quantifies effects of halo triaxiality, gas clumping, etc., through numerical simulations
3. Dual-component Spectral Fitting: Verifies spectral consistency of the cosmic ray-IC component

Experimental Setup

Target Selection

ZwCl 3146 was selected as the research target for the following reasons:

• Massive, relaxed cool core galaxy cluster (M500 ≃ 7.7×10¹⁴ M⊙, z=0.291)
• High X-ray cooling rate (~1000 M⊙ yr⁻¹)
• Deep, high-resolution X-ray and SZ observational data available
• Relatively low millimeter-wave brightness of the central AGN

Data Quality

• Chandra: 86 ks total exposure time with excellent angular resolution (~0.25″)
• MUSTANG-2: 61σ significance detection with 10″ resolution

Analysis Parameters

• Cosmological parameters: H₀ = 70 km s⁻¹ Mpc⁻¹, Ωm,0 = 0.3
• X-ray energy band: 0.5-7 keV
• Radial range: 25-625 kpc, divided into 11 annular intervals

Experimental Results

Main Results

Significant pressure ratio deficit detected within the central 100 kpc of ZwCl 3146:

• Pdef ≡ ⟨PSZ/PX⟩r≤100kpc = 0.72 ± 0.08
• Statistical Significance: ~3.3σ
• Continuous declining trend in pressure ratio with decreasing radius

Theoretical Model Comparison

Observational results are consistent with predictions from Hopkins et al.'s cosmic ray model:

• Models with cosmic ray injection luminosity LCRs ~ 10⁴⁴ erg s⁻¹ predict Pdef ≃ 0.7
• This injection luminosity is energetically consistent with the jet kinetic power of ZwCl 3146's AGN (~6×10⁴⁵ erg s⁻¹)

Systematic Error Analysis

Contributions of various systematic effects to the pressure ratio:

Spectral Fitting Verification

Dual-component model (ICM + cosmic ray-IC) fitting results:

• Thermal pressure ratio: Pth/PX = 0.45⁺⁰·¹¹₋₀.₁₁ (spectral method)
• SZ pressure ratio: PSZ/PX = 0.51⁺⁰·¹⁴₋₀.₂₀ (SZ method)
• Results from both methods agree within error bars
• Cosmic ray-IC to thermal emission flux ratio in 0.5-1.0 keV band ~3.3

Related Work

Cooling Flow Problem Research

• Classical studies established the discrepancy between X-ray cooling rates and star formation rates
• Multiple theoretical models of AGN feedback mechanisms (acoustic waves, gravitational waves, cosmic ray heating, etc.)

Role of Cosmic Rays in Galaxy Clusters

• Radio observations confirm the presence of substantial cosmic rays in cool core galaxy clusters
• High-energy leptons produce radio emission; low-energy leptons form ancient cosmic ray halos (ACRHs)
• Theoretical predictions and spectral characteristics of cosmic ray-IC emission

SZ-X-ray Comparative Studies

• Advantages of using SZ observations to measure true thermal gas pressure
• Applications of multi-wavelength observations in galaxy cluster physics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Significant SZ-X-ray pressure ratio deficit detected in ZwCl 3146 (30%, 3.3σ)
2. This deficit is consistent with cosmic ray-IC model predictions, supporting the existence of non-thermal X-ray components
3. Systematic error analysis indicates that other effects cannot explain the observed deficit magnitude
4. Spectral analysis verifies the possible existence of cosmic ray-IC components

Limitations

1. Sample Size: Analysis based on only a single galaxy cluster
2. Theoretical Uncertainties: Significant uncertainties in theoretical predictions of cosmic ray-IC spectral shapes
3. Systematic Errors: Some systematic effects (e.g., halo triaxiality) may be underestimated
4. Spectral Constraints: Limited ability of X-ray spectroscopy to constrain cosmic ray-IC parameters

Future Directions

1. Expanded Sample: Conduct similar analyses on more cool core galaxy clusters
2. Theoretical Refinement: Improve theoretical models of cosmic ray transport and IC emission
3. Observational Improvements: Utilize deeper X-ray and SZ observational data
4. Joint Analysis: Develop comprehensive fitting methods combining spectral and radial information

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High Innovation: First observational study utilizing SZ-X-ray pressure ratios to test cosmic ray contributions
2. Rigorous Methodology: Comprehensive systematic error analysis and multiple verification methods
3. Theory Integration: Excellent agreement between observational results and theoretical predictions
4. Advanced Techniques: Utilizes state-of-the-art high-resolution observational facilities and analysis techniques
5. Clear Presentation: Logical structure with accurate technical detail descriptions

Weaknesses

1. Statistical Significance: While reaching 3.3σ, higher significance would be more convincing for such an important discovery
2. Sample Limitations: Results from a single object are difficult to generalize to the entire galaxy cluster population
3. Model Dependence: Conclusions depend to some extent on specific cosmic ray theoretical models
4. Systematic Assessment: Evaluation of certain systematic effects may be insufficient

Impact

1. Scientific Significance: Provides a new physical mechanism for solving the cooling flow problem
2. Methodological Value: Establishes a new observational method for testing non-thermal X-ray components
3. Theoretical Advancement: Promotes theoretical development of cosmic ray physics in galaxy clusters
4. Observational Guidance: Provides guidance for future multi-wavelength observational strategies

Applicable Scenarios

1. Cool Core Cluster Research: Particularly suitable for relaxed systems with strong AGN activity
2. Multi-wavelength Astrophysics: Data analysis for joint SZ and X-ray observations
3. Cosmic Ray Physics: Study of cosmic ray transport and radiation processes at galaxy cluster scales
4. Cluster Evolution: Understanding the role of AGN feedback in galaxy cluster evolution

References

This paper cites extensive related research, primarily including:

• Hopkins et al. (2025a,b): Cosmic ray-IC theoretical models
• Romero et al. (2020, 2023): MUSTANG-2 observations and data analysis
• Classical literature on the cooling flow problem (Fabian 1994, McNamara & Nulsen 2007, etc.)
• Technical literature on SZ observations and X-ray observations

This research provides important observational evidence for understanding non-thermal processes in galaxy clusters. While analysis based on a single object has limitations, its innovative methodology and compelling results open new directions for future development in this field.