Invisible neutron decay and light BSM particles

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14940
• Title: Invisible neutron decay and light BSM particles
• Authors: J.C. Helo, T. Ota, M. Hirsch
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14940

Abstract

In the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT), invisible neutron decay is generated by dimension-12 operators. By adding new light particles (such as right-handed neutrinos) to the Standard Model, invisible neutron decay operators can be constructed at lower dimensions. If invisible neutron decay is observed while charged lepton nucleon decay remains absent, this would point to the existence of new neutral degrees of freedom. This paper discusses four scenarios: (i) adding right-handed neutrinos to the SM; (ii) right-handed neutrinos and axion-like particles; (iii) right-handed neutrinos and (approximately) massless singlet scalars; (iv) right-handed neutrinos and light Z' bosons. The article provides general tree-level decompositions for generating d=(7-9) invisible neutron decay operators and briefly discusses LHC searches related to exotic states in these ultraviolet completions.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Current status of nucleon decay searches: Experiments such as Super-Kamiokande have pushed constraints on multiple nucleon decay channels beyond 10³⁴ years, including GUT-predicted decay modes such as p→ℓ⁺π⁰ and n→ν̄K⁰.
2. Theoretical challenges of invisible neutron decay: In the pure SMEFT framework, invisible neutron decay (such as n→3ν) requires d=12 operators, corresponding to new physics energy scales of approximately 13 TeV, making observation difficult.
3. Experimental constraints: The strongest current constraints on invisible neutron decay come from SNO+ (9.0×10²⁹ years), with future JUNO reaching 5×10³¹ years and THEIA potentially reaching 4×10³² years.

Research Motivation

By introducing light Beyond Standard Model (BSM) particles, invisible neutron decay operators can be constructed at lower dimensions (d=7-9), thereby increasing the possibility of observation. This approach is not only theoretically more natural but also provides new avenues for exploring new physics.

Core Contributions

1. Systematic analysis of four BSM extensions: Detailed investigation of scenarios with added right-handed neutrinos, axion-like particles, light scalars, and light vector bosons
2. Construction of low-dimensional effective operators: Provision of d=7-9 dimensional invisible neutron decay operators
3. Complete ultraviolet completion: Provision of tree-level decompositions for all relevant operators and possible UV models
4. Phenomenological analysis: Estimation of decay half-lives and discussion of LHC constraints
5. Important caveat: Identification of potential constraints from the n→π⁰ + missing energy mode on invisible neutron decay searches

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of how to construct low-dimensional effective operators producing invisible neutron decay after adding light BSM particles to the Standard Model, and analysis of their ultraviolet completion and phenomenological consequences.

Four Model Variants

Variant I: Right-handed neutrinos (d=9)

Addition of at least two right-handed neutrinos N_R, constructing two d=9 operators:

$O_1^N = \frac{c^{(1)}_{\alpha\beta\gamma ijk}}{\Lambda^5}(u_{R\alpha}^c d_{R\beta})(d_{R\gamma}^c N_{Ri})(N_{Rj}^c N_{Rk})$

$O_2^N = \frac{c^{(2)}_{\alpha\beta\gamma ijk}}{\Lambda^5}(Q_\alpha^c Q_\beta)(d_{R\gamma}^c N_{Ri})(N_{Rj}^c N_{Rk})$

Estimated half-life: $\Gamma(n\to\bar{N}_i\bar{N}_j\bar{N}_k) \simeq \frac{\beta_h^2 m_n^5}{6144\pi^3\Lambda^{10}} \simeq \frac{1}{9\cdot 10^{29}\text{yr}}\left(\frac{180\text{TeV}}{\Lambda}\right)^{10}$

Variant II: Right-handed neutrinos + axion-like particles (d=8)

Construction of two d=8 operators: $O_1^a = \frac{c^{(1,a)}_{\alpha\beta\gamma}}{\Lambda^4}(\partial_\mu a)(N_R\gamma^\mu d_{R\alpha})(u_{R\beta}^c d_{R\gamma})$

Estimated half-life: $\Gamma(n\to Na) \simeq \frac{\beta_h^2 m_n^3}{32\pi\Lambda^8} \simeq \frac{1}{9.0\cdot 10^{29}\text{yr}}\left(\frac{9.6\times 10^6\text{GeV}}{\Lambda}\right)^8$

Variant III: Right-handed neutrinos + light scalar (d=7)

$O_1^\phi = \frac{c^{(1,\phi)}_{\alpha\beta\gamma}}{\Lambda^3}\phi(N_R^c d_{R\alpha})(u_{R\beta}^c d_{R\gamma})$

Variant IV: Right-handed neutrinos + light vector boson (d=7)

$O_1^{Z'} = \frac{c^{(1,Z')}_{\alpha\beta\gamma}}{\Lambda^3}Z'_\mu(N_R\gamma^\mu d_{R\alpha})(u_{R\beta}^c d_{R\gamma})$

Technical Innovations

1. Dimension reduction strategy: Introduction of light BSM particles reduces the operator dimension for invisible neutron decay from d=12 to d=7-9
2. Symmetry analysis: Rational allocation of baryon and lepton numbers avoids dangerous d=6 operators that would produce significant two-body decays
3. Complete decomposition: Systematic decomposition of all relevant operators using diagrammatic methods to identify all possible UV completions

Experimental Setup

Current Experimental Constraints

• Kamiokande (1993): 4.9×10²⁶ years
• SNO: 2×10²⁹ years
• KamLAND: 5.8×10²⁹ years
• SNO+ (latest): 9.0×10²⁹ years

Future Experimental Prospects

• JUNO: 5×10³¹ years
• THEIA: 4×10³² years
• Hyper-Kamiokande: Significant improvement

Evaluation Metrics

Constraints on new physics energy scale Λ are primarily imposed through half-life limits, while LHC searches constrain new particle masses in UV models.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Energy Scale Sensitivity Comparison

Sensitivity of different experiments to new physics energy scale Λ:

Important Finding: π⁰ Constraint

The paper identifies an important experimental constraint: any operator producing invisible neutron decay simultaneously produces the four-body decay n→π⁰ + missing energy. Estimates show:

$\Gamma(n\to\pi^0\bar{N}_i\bar{N}_j\bar{N}_k) \simeq \frac{1}{3.3\times 10^{32}\text{yr}}\left(\frac{245\text{TeV}}{\Lambda}\right)^{10}$

This constraint may be stronger than the invisible decay itself, with important implications for future search strategies.

Ultraviolet Completion Results

The paper systematically analyzes tree-level decompositions of all operators, finding:

• Total of 11 mediator particles: 4 scalars, 4 fermions, 3 vectors
• Multiple topological structures: Including two main topologies designated as type A and type B
• Symmetry requirements: Special symmetry arrangements needed to avoid dangerous low-dimensional operators

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Weinberg (1980): First proposal of d=12 operators for invisible neutron decay
2. Early studies: Invisible decay in extra dimensions and left-right symmetric models
3. Recent developments: Connection between dark neutron decay and neutron lifetime anomalies

Novelty of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to systematically investigate the method of reducing operator dimensions by adding light BSM particles and provides complete UV analysis.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Observational significance: Observation of invisible neutron decay would strongly suggest the existence of new neutral degrees of freedom
2. Necessary condition: All models require neutral fermions similar to right-handed neutrinos
3. Experimental strategy: The n→π⁰ + missing energy search may be more sensitive than direct invisible decay searches

Limitations

1. Model dependence: Requires specific symmetry arrangements to avoid dominance of two-body decays
2. Experimental challenges: Technical difficulties in background suppression and signal extraction
3. Theoretical uncertainties: Precision limitations in nuclear matrix element calculations

Future Directions

1. Experimental improvements: Precise measurements from next-generation experiments such as Hyper-Kamiokande
2. Theoretical refinement: More accurate nuclear matrix element calculations
3. Model building: More natural UV completion models

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong systematicity: Comprehensive analysis of four different BSM extension scenarios
2. Technical depth: Complete operator decomposition and UV analysis
3. Rich phenomenology: Connection between theoretical predictions and experimental searches
4. Important discovery: Identification of potential constraining role of π⁰ mode

Weaknesses

1. Model complexity: Requires complex symmetry arrangements to achieve desired phenomenology
2. Experimental feasibility: Some predicted energy scales are too high for near-term verification
3. Background analysis: Relatively simplified treatment of experimental backgrounds

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new theoretical framework for invisible neutron decay research
2. Experimental guidance: Important reference for future experiment design
3. Cross-disciplinary connection: Connects nucleon decay, neutrino physics, and new physics searches

Applicable Scenarios

This research applies to:

1. Nucleon decay searches in large underground experiments
2. New physics searches at high-energy colliders such as the LHC
3. Theoretical research in neutrino physics and light new physics

References

The paper cites 138 references, spanning from classical GUT theory to the latest experimental results, reflecting the complete development history and current research frontiers of the field.

Summary: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that systematically investigates the possibility of achieving low-dimensional invisible neutron decay through light BSM particles. The paper not only provides complete theoretical analysis but also delivers important phenomenological predictions, with significant value for both theoretical development and experimental searches in this field.