Toward more performant eye safe lasers: effect of increasing sensitizer amount in Yb3+,Er3+:YAG transparent ceramic on its spectral characteristics

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.21243
• Title: Toward more performant eye safe lasers: effect of increasing sensitizer amount in Yb3+,Er3+:YAG transparent ceramic on its spectral characteristics
• Authors: Agnieszka Szysiak, Robert Tomala, Helena Węglarz, Juraj Kajan, Mirosław Słobodzian, Mykhailo Chaika
• Classification: cond-mat.mtrl-sci (Materials Science)
• Institutions: Institute of Microelectronics and Photonics (Poland), Graphene Energy Company, Institute of Low Temperature and Structure Research of the Polish Academy of Sciences, University of Žilina (Slovakia), and others
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.21243

Abstract

This study focuses on developing efficient Er³⁺,Yb³⁺:YAG eye-safe lasers, an important objective in modern laser technology. The paper systematically investigates the effect of Yb³⁺ ion concentration on the spectral characteristics of Er³⁺,Yb³⁺:YAG transparent ceramics. Four samples with different Yb³⁺ ion concentrations were prepared via solid-state reaction sintering, revealing the influence of Yb³⁺ ions on microstructure and sintering processes. The study found that high concentrations of Yb³⁺ ions lead to the formation of Y³⁺-rich impurity phases and cause segregation of Er³⁺, Yb³⁺, and Si⁴⁺ into these phases. By analyzing changes in emission spectral shape and ion lifetime, the modifications in spectral characteristics are attributed to enhanced energy transfer efficiency between Yb³⁺ and Er³⁺ ions. Internal quantum efficiency was calculated, and an optimal Er³⁺/Yb³⁺ ion ratio was proposed.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of Eye-Safe Lasers: Lasers at 1.5 μm wavelength are considered eye-safe because light in this spectral region is absorbed by the anterior segment of the eye (cornea) and does not reach the retina. Despite its significance, the efficiency of 1.5 μm lasers remains far from optimal.
2. Inherent Limitations of Er³⁺ Ions: Er³⁺-based materials are the primary active elements for 1.5 μm lasers; however, Er³⁺ ions suffer from small absorption cross-sections and low direct pumping efficiency. As Er³⁺ concentration increases, inter-ionic energy transfer efficiency improves, but the probability of non-radiative recombination processes simultaneously increases, resulting in reduced luminescence efficiency in highly doped materials.
3. Yb³⁺ Co-doping Solution: Yb³⁺ ions possess large absorption cross-sections and efficient energy transfer capabilities, forming donor-acceptor pairs with Er³⁺, and represent the most effective basis for 1.5 μm lasers to date.

Research Motivation

Enhance the laser efficiency of Er³⁺,Yb³⁺:YAG materials by increasing the energy transfer efficiency from Yb³⁺ to Er³⁺. Energy transfer efficiency primarily depends on the donor-acceptor distance, following an inverse sixth-power law. By optimizing Yb³⁺ and Er³⁺ ion concentrations, the inter-ionic distance can be modulated; however, a balance must be found between improving energy transfer efficiency and suppressing non-radiative relaxation processes.

Core Contributions

1. Systematic investigation of Yb³⁺ concentration effects on material structure: Discovered that high Yb³⁺ concentrations (20 at.%) lead to Y³⁺-rich impurity phase formation and ion segregation phenomena
2. Elucidation of Yb³⁺ concentration regulation mechanisms on spectral characteristics: Through emission spectral shape changes and lifetime measurements, clarified the physical mechanisms underlying enhanced energy transfer efficiency
3. Establishment of structure-property relationships: Quantitatively correlated lattice parameter variations and bond length distortions with spectral characteristic changes
4. Proposal of optimal doping ratios: Based on internal quantum efficiency calculations, proposed an optimization strategy where Er³⁺/Yb³⁺ ratio should be ≤1/10
5. Guidance for high-quality ceramic preparation: Discovered that different compositions require precise adjustment of sintering aid concentrations to achieve high transparency

Methodology Details

Material Preparation

Solid-State Reaction Sintering (SRS) Process:

• Raw materials: High-purity Al₂O₃ (>99.99%), Y₂O₃ (>99.90%), Er₂O₃ (>99.999%), Yb₂O₃ (>99.99%)
• Sintering aid: Laboratory-prepared TAOS (SiO₂.₅N(CH₃)₄₈ ·~ 60∙H₂O)
• Process flow: Ball milling (2h) → Freeze granulation → Cold isostatic pressing (120 MPa) → Calcination (950°C) → Vacuum sintering (1750°C, 6h) → Air annealing (1600°C, 2h)

Sample Design

Four samples were prepared with fixed Er³⁺ concentration at 0.5 at.% and varying Yb³⁺ concentrations:

• Er(0.5)Yb(<0.01): <0.01 at.%
• Er(0.5)Yb(5): 5 at.%
• Er(0.5)Yb(10): 10 at.%
• Er(0.5)Yb(20): 20 at.%

Characterization Techniques

1. Structural characterization: XRD phase analysis, Rietveld refinement, SEM morphology, EDS compositional analysis
2. Optical properties: UV-VIS-NIR transmission spectroscopy, fluorescence spectroscopy, lifetime measurements
3. Quantum efficiency: Integrating sphere measurement of internal quantum efficiency (IQE)

Experimental Setup

Testing Conditions

• Excitation source: 940 nm InGaAs laser diode
• Detectors: R928P photomultiplier tube (visible region), R5509-72 photomultiplier tube (near-infrared region)
• Testing environment: Room temperature (300 K)
• Spectral resolution: 0.5 nm

Analysis Methods

• Rietveld refinement: Crystal structure analysis using FullProf Suite software package
• Lifetime fitting: Single exponential function for Yb³⁺, special double exponential function for Er³⁺
• IQE calculation: Based on integrating sphere measurements of emission spectra in the 900-1600 nm range

Experimental Results

Structural Analysis Results

Lattice Parameter Variations:

• Lattice parameters decrease linearly with increasing Yb³⁺ concentration: 12.0048(1) Å → 11.9891(1) Å
• Consistent with Vegard's law, confirming successful substitution of Y³⁺ by Yb³⁺ in the YAG lattice
• Dodecahedral site bond length distortion increases from 0.017% to 0.059%

Microstructural Evolution:

• Average grain size: 18(8) μm, with no significant differences among samples
• Grain boundary pores appear in Er(0.5)Yb(10) and Er(0.5)Yb(20) samples
• Irregular Y₂O₃ impurity phase (0.5-2.5 μm) forms in Er(0.5)Yb(20) sample, containing segregated Er³⁺, Yb³⁺, and Si⁴⁺

Optical Transparency

Transmittance Variations:

• Transmittance at 1100 nm: 81% → 81% → 78% → 47%
• Transparency reduction caused by: increased residual porosity + impurity phase scattering
• High Yb³⁺ concentration reduces sintering aid effectiveness

Luminescence Spectral Characteristics

Yb³⁺ Emission Spectrum:

• Main emission peak position unchanged (1028.7 nm), but spectral shape significantly altered
• High-energy side (967.1 nm) intensity decreased: 0.41 → 0.1
• Low-energy side (1046.8 nm) intensity increased: 0.1 → 0.31
• Attributed to enhanced Yb³⁺→Er³⁺ energy transfer efficiency

Er³⁺ Emission Spectrum:

• Main emission peak: 1530.8 nm (⁴I₁₃/₂→⁴I₁₅/₂ transition)
• Peak position essentially unchanged, with slight red shift (~0.2 nm) in Er(0.5)Yb(20) sample
• Upconversion emission: green light (520-560 nm) and red light (640-680 nm)

Fluorescence Lifetime Measurements

Yb³⁺ Lifetime:

• Increases with concentration: 0.76 ms → 1.16 ms
• Indicates increased probability of reverse Er³⁺→Yb³⁺ energy transfer

Er³⁺ Lifetime:

• ⁴I₁₃/₂ energy level lifetime (τd) essentially unchanged: ~0.95 ms
• ⁴I₁₁/₂ energy level lifetime (τg) increases: 0.011 ms → 0.083 ms
• Confirms enhanced Yb³⁺→Er³⁺ energy transfer efficiency

Internal Quantum Efficiency

Overall IQE: Er(0.5)Yb(5) 50% → Er(0.5)Yb(10) 45% → Er(0.5)Yb(20) 43%

Er³⁺ IQE: Er(0.5)Yb(5) 23% → Er(0.5)Yb(10) 21% → Er(0.5)Yb(20) 16%

Results indicate that Er³⁺ luminescence efficiency decreases with increasing Yb³⁺ concentration, with optimal Er³⁺/Yb³⁺ ratio ≤1/10.

Related Work

This research builds upon prior work in the following areas:

1. YAG transparent ceramic preparation techniques: Solid-state reaction sintering, sintering aid optimization
2. Rare-earth ion energy transfer theory: Förster theory, radiative trapping effects
3. Eye-safe laser development: Er³⁺-based laser materials, co-doping strategies
4. Spectroscopic analysis methods: Stark level splitting, crystal field theory

Compared to existing research, the innovation of this work lies in systematically correlating material structure, preparation processes, and spectral performance, providing clear optimization guidance for practical laser applications.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Structure-property relationships: Increased Yb³⁺ concentration leads to lattice contraction and increased bond length distortion, affecting the spectral characteristics of ions
2. Energy transfer mechanisms: Spectral shape changes and lifetime measurements confirm that increased Yb³⁺ concentration enhances Yb³⁺→Er³⁺ energy transfer efficiency
3. Optimal doping ratio: Based on IQE analysis, for 0.5 at.% Er³⁺ doping, the optimal Er³⁺/Yb³⁺ ratio is ≤1/10
4. Preparation process optimization: Different compositions require precise adjustment of TAOS concentration to avoid impurity phase formation and transparency degradation

Limitations

1. Single Er³⁺ concentration: Only 0.5 at.% Er³⁺ was studied; optimal ratios at higher Er³⁺ concentrations may differ
2. Fixed sintering conditions: Sintering parameters for different compositions were not systematically optimized
3. Absence of laser performance data: Lacks actual laser device performance test data
4. Incomplete mechanistic explanation: Relative contributions of energy transfer and radiative trapping effects require further clarification

Future Directions

1. Investigate optimal Er³⁺/Yb³⁺ ratios at different Er³⁺ concentrations
2. Optimize sintering process parameters for different compositions
3. Conduct actual laser device performance testing
4. Conduct in-depth investigation of energy transfer microscopic mechanisms

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Scientific research design: Systematic concentration gradient design with multi-faceted characterization methods
2. In-depth mechanistic analysis: Combined structural analysis, spectroscopic measurements, and lifetime studies to establish clear structure-property relationships
3. High practical value: Provides clear guidance for actual laser material design
4. High data quality: Detailed experimental data with reasonable analytical methods

Weaknesses

1. Limited sample number: Only four samples; concentration gradients could be more refined
2. Missing temperature dependence: Testing only at room temperature; lacks temperature-dependent studies
3. Insufficient theoretical models: Lacks quantitative energy transfer theoretical models
4. Insufficient application verification: Requires actual laser device testing for validation

Impact

Academic Value:

• Provides important structure-property relationship insights for rare-earth doped transparent ceramics
• Energy transfer mechanism research has universal guiding significance

Application Prospects:

• Directly guides optimization of eye-safe laser materials
• Provides reference for other rare-earth co-doped systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Eye-safe lasers: 1.5 μm lasers for ranging, communications, medical and other applications
2. Material design: Compositional optimization of other rare-earth co-doped transparent ceramics
3. Process development: Guidance for transparent ceramic sintering process optimization

References

The paper cites 43 relevant references, covering:

• Transparent ceramic preparation techniques
• Rare-earth ion spectroscopy
• Energy transfer theory
• Laser materials and devices

Important references include classical works on Förster energy transfer theory, YAG ceramic sintering mechanisms, and Er-Yb energy transfer dynamics.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality materials science research paper that systematically investigates the effect of Yb³⁺ concentration on the spectral characteristics of Er³⁺,Yb³⁺:YAG transparent ceramics, establishing clear structure-property relationships and providing important guidance for eye-safe laser material optimization. The research methodology is scientific, data are detailed, conclusions are reliable, and the work possesses significant academic value and application prospects.