HOLISMOKES XIX: SN 2025wny at $z=2$, the first strongly lensed superluminous supernova

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.21694
• Title: HOLISMOKES XIX: SN 2025wny at $z=2$, the first strongly lensed superluminous supernova
• Authors: Stefan Taubenberger, Ana Acebron, Raoul Cañameras, Ting-Wan Chen, Aymeric Galan, Claudio Grillo, and 43 additional co-authors
• Classification: astro-ph.CO (Cosmology), astro-ph.HE (High Energy Astrophysics), astro-ph.SR (Solar and Stellar Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: October 27, 2025
• Journal: Astronomy & Astrophysics
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.21694

Abstract

This paper reports imaging and spectroscopic observations of supernova SN 2025wny, associated with the lensing candidate PS1 J0716+3821. Photometric monitoring from Lulin Observatory and Maidanak Observatory confirms multiple point-like images, consistent with SN 2025wny being strongly gravitationally lensed by two foreground galaxies. Optical spectroscopy of the brightest image obtained with the Nordic Optical Telescope and the University of Hawaii 88-inch Telescope determines a redshift of $z_s = 2.008 \pm 0.001$ based on narrow absorption lines from the supernova host galaxy's interstellar medium. At this redshift, the spectrum of SN 2025wny is consistent with a Type I superluminous supernova. The supernova exhibits high ejecta temperatures and relatively weak spectral lines compared to similar objects. The redshift of the fainter "perturber" galaxy in the lensing system is measured for the first time as $z_p = 0.375 \pm 0.001$, in perfect agreement with the main deflector redshift $z_d = 0.3754$ confirmed by DESI spectroscopy.

Research Background and Motivation

Tension in Hubble Constant Measurements

A critical issue in contemporary cosmology is the persistent tension between measurements of the Hubble constant $H_0$, particularly between the local distance ladder method from the SH0ES project and the early universe inference from Planck cosmic microwave background observations. This discrepancy highlights gaps in our cosmological understanding and underscores the need for independent detection methods.

Importance of Strongly Lensed Supernovae

Astrophysical transient phenomena (such as supernovae) that are strongly gravitationally lensed by foreground galaxies or galaxy clusters provide a particularly powerful method for measuring $H_0$ and other cosmological parameters. Time delays between multiple magnified images, combined with lens models of the total mass distribution, directly measure the time-delay distance, enabling independent determination of $H_0$ without reliance on the distance ladder or early universe measurements.

Rarity of Strongly Lensed Supernovae

Due to the rarity of strongly lensed supernovae, the time-delay method has been primarily validated through lensed quasars. While the discovery of strongly lensed supernovae has progressed rapidly over the past decade, most systems are lensed by galaxy clusters, with only two systems lensed by individual galaxies, and these systems have very short time delays (≲1 day), unsuitable for precision cosmological measurements.

Core Contributions

1. First Discovery: Discovery and confirmation of the first galaxy-scale strongly lensed superluminous supernova SN 2025wny, with time-delay characteristics suitable for cosmological measurements
2. Precise Redshift Measurements: Spectroscopic determination of the supernova redshift $z_s = 2.008 \pm 0.001$ and the perturber lens galaxy redshift $z_p = 0.375 \pm 0.001$
3. Supernova Classification: Confirmation of SN 2025wny as a Type I superluminous supernova (SLSN-I), among the most distant spectroscopically confirmed SLSNe
4. Method Validation: Verification of the effectiveness of the HOLISMOKES project's lensed supernova search strategy
5. Cosmological Application: Provision of a new system for independent Hubble constant measurement, with predicted time delays in the range of days to weeks

Methodology Details

Discovery Strategy

The discovery of SN 2025wny is based on the HOLISMOKES project's systematic search strategy:

1. Systematic classification of 3 billion sources in the Pan-STARRS 3π survey using deep learning
2. Selection of high-quality strong lens candidates
3. Continuous positional cross-matching with public ZTF alert streams

Observational Methods

Imaging Observations

• Lulin Observatory: 1-meter telescope (LOT) imaging in gri bands
• Maidanak Observatory: 1.5-meter telescope imaging in VRI bands
• Other Facilities: COLIBRI telescope, Wide Field Survey telescope, Wendelstein Observatory, etc.

Spectroscopic Observations

• Nordic Optical Telescope (NOT): ALFOSC spectroscopy at two epochs
  • October 11, 2025: grism 4, resolution R~350, wavelength range 3300-9700Å
  • October 19, 2025: grism 18, resolution R~1000, wavelength range 3450-5350Å
• University of Hawaii 88-inch Telescope: SNIFS integral field spectrograph

Data Processing Methods

Image Processing

• Standard bias subtraction, dark current correction, and flat-field correction
• Template subtraction using AutoPhOT
• PSF photometry using Moffat functions

Spectral Processing

• Standard spectroscopic reduction pipeline using IRAF
• Wavelength calibration using HeNe arc spectra verified with night sky emission lines
• Flux calibration using standard star observations

Experimental Setup

Observational Data

• Imaging Data: Multi-wavelength gri/VRI band images from multiple observatories
• Spectroscopic Data: Optical spectra from NOT and UH88 telescopes
• Reference Data: Pan-STARRS1 and CFHT archival images

Analysis Tools

• Spectral Analysis: SNID, GELATO, NGSF and other supernova classification codes
• Photometric Analysis: AutoPhOT differential photometry
• Template Matching: Comparison with known SLSN spectra

Redshift Determination Method

Redshift determination through identification of narrow absorption lines in the host galaxy's interstellar medium:

• C IV λλ1548, 1551
• C II λλ1335, 1336
• Mg II λλ2796, 2803

Experimental Results

Lens System Confirmation

• Successfully identified four strongly lensed images (A, B, C, D), arranged in decreasing brightness
• Image A r-band magnitude: 19.6 mag
• Difference images clearly show multiple transient images

Redshift Measurement Results

• Supernova Redshift: $z_s = 2.008 \pm 0.001$
• Primary Lens Galaxy G1: $z_d = 0.3754$ (DESI confirmed)
• Perturber Galaxy G2: $z_p = 0.375 \pm 0.001$ (first measurement in this study)

Supernova Properties

• Classification: Type I Superluminous Supernova (SLSN-I)
• Ejecta Temperature: ≥17,000 K
• Spectral Features: Best match with SNLS-06D4eu, but with weaker and more blueshifted carbon lines

Photometric Results

Magnitude measurements for image A at different wavelengths:

• V band: 20.31 ± 0.02 mag
• R band: 19.48 ± 0.01 mag
• I band: 19.17 ± 0.01 mag

Scientific Significance and Discoveries

Supernova Physics

SN 2025wny exhibits typical characteristics of SLSN-I:

• Extremely high UV luminosity sustained for weeks
• Spectral energy distribution peak at 1300-2300Å (rest-frame)
• UV brightness 1-2 orders of magnitude higher than other SN types

Lens System Characteristics

• Lensing system composed of two galaxies (G1+G2)
• Expected time delays in the range of days to weeks
• Suitable for precision cosmological measurements

Detection Probability Analysis

Although SLSNe are extremely rare in the local universe, they may be more readily discovered in strong lens systems:

• SLSNe are approximately 2 magnitudes brighter than typical Type Ia supernovae
• At z≳1.5, optical observations correspond to rest-frame UV, where SLSNe are extremely bright
• If ordinary Type Ia supernovae were substituted, their observed brightness would decrease by 5-6 magnitudes

Related Work

History of Strongly Lensed Supernovae

• SN Refsdal: First discovered strongly lensed supernova (Kelly et al. 2015)
• iPTF16geu and SN Zwicky: Only two known galaxy-scale lens systems, but with excessively short time delays
• Galaxy Cluster Lens Systems: Most known strongly lensed supernovae are lensed by galaxy clusters

HOLISMOKES Project

The project aims to:

1. Measure the Hubble constant through supernova lens time-delay measurements
2. Utilize lens time delays as a cosmic time machine to constrain supernova progenitor properties

Superluminous Supernova Research

• Discovery History: First identified as a distinct category by Quimby et al. (2011)
• Physical Mechanisms: Massive star explosions or magnetar formation and spin-down
• Observational Characteristics: Extremely high UV brightness, slowly evolving light curves

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. SN 2025wny is the first confirmed galaxy-scale strongly lensed superluminous supernova
2. This system possesses time-delay characteristics suitable for cosmological measurements (days to weeks)
3. Precise redshifts of all relevant objects have been successfully measured
4. The deep learning-based lensed supernova search strategy has been validated

Cosmological Prospects

• Continued photometric monitoring will provide time-delay measurements
• Combined with lens mass modeling, independent measurement of the Hubble constant is possible
• Provides a new independent probe for addressing the Hubble tension

Future Observational Plans

• Follow-up observations with the Hubble Space Telescope (Program ID 17611) and James Webb Space Telescope (Program ID 5564)
• Continued monitoring by multiple ground-based observatories
• High-resolution imaging for detailed lens mass modeling

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Significant Discovery: First discovery of a galaxy-scale lensed supernova suitable for cosmology, with milestone significance
2. Comprehensive Observations: Coordinated observations from multiple observatories with high data quality
3. Rigorous Analysis: Redshift measurements based on multiple absorption lines with reliable results
4. Methodological Innovation: Validation of the effectiveness of systematic search strategies
5. Scientific Value: Provides important new tools for cosmological and supernova physics research

Technical Highlights

1. Multi-wavelength Imaging: Complete light curve data obtained across multiple bands
2. Spectroscopic Confirmation: Precise classification and redshift determination through high-quality spectroscopy
3. Systematic Analysis: Complete characterization of all components of the lens system

Limitations

1. Limited Sample: Single object only; more similar discoveries needed to validate results
2. Pending Time-Delay Measurement: Actual time-delay measurements are still underway
3. Model Dependence: Cosmological applications require precise lens mass models

Impact Assessment

1. Disciplinary Impact: Opens new frontiers in lensed supernova cosmology
2. Methodological Contribution: Provides search templates for future large-scale surveys
3. Technical Advancement: Demonstrates the power of multi-observatory collaborative observations

Applicable Scenarios

1. Cosmological Research: Independent measurement of the Hubble constant
2. Supernova Physics: Study of high-redshift SLSN properties
3. Lens Modeling: Mass distribution studies of complex lens systems
4. Survey Strategy: Guidance for future projects such as LSST

Future Outlook

With the imminent commencement of LSST operations, approximately 10 cosmologically suitable lensed Type Ia supernovae are expected to be discovered annually. A sample of approximately 20 lensed supernovae would enable measurement of $H_0$ with 1% precision, which is crucial for resolving the Hubble tension. As the first such discovery, SN 2025wny lays the foundation for this exciting research field.

Note: Following tradition, the paper's authors affectionately refer to SN 2025wny as "SN Winny," reflecting the astronomical community's commemorative tradition for significant discoveries.