Vector Nematodynamics with Symmetry-driven Energy Exchange

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.24177
• Title: Vector Nematodynamics with Symmetry-driven Energy Exchange
• Author: L. M. Pismen (Department of Chemical Engineering, Technion - Israel Institute of Technology)
• Classification: cond-mat.soft, physics.flu-dyn
• Publication Date: October 28, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.24177

Abstract

This paper reviews the inadequacies of existing nematic dynamics theories and proposes a novel approach based on local symmetry between simultaneous rotation of nematic orientation and flow. The method establishes the relationship between these two without reducing the problem to near-equilibrium conditions or invoking Onsager relations. Within a vector theory framework with variable modulus, energy exchange is achieved through antisymmetric interactions between nematic orientation and flow, avoiding spurious instabilities in the absence of active input.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem to be Addressed: Existing nematic dynamics theories contain fundamental defects, particularly in describing the interaction between nematic orientation and flow, relying on near-equilibrium assumptions and Onsager reciprocal relations, leading to theoretical predictions that contradict experimental observations.
2. Importance of the Problem: Nematic dynamics has broad applications in active matter research, including biological tissues, cells, bacterial colonies, and biofilms. The constituent units of these systems are macroscopic, differing from traditional molecular nematic liquid crystals, yet existing theories remain based on classical molecular-scale theory.
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches:
   • Classical Ericksen-Leslie (EL) theory using director as order parameter suffers from normalization issues
   • Tensor-based order parameter theories, while improving certain aspects, still rely on near-equilibrium relations
   • Application of Onsager relations is physically unreasonable, mixing variables with different parities under time reversal
   • Spurious instabilities emerge under certain conditions
4. Research Motivation: Establish a nematic dynamics theory independent of equilibrium assumptions, describing the interaction between nematic orientation and flow through local symmetry principles.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed vector order parameter-based nematic dynamics theory, avoiding director normalization issues and tensor theory complexity
2. Established energy exchange mechanism based on local rotational symmetry, independent of Onsager relations
3. Introduced antisymmetric viscous stress concept, describing nematic-flow interactions
4. Demonstrated that the new theory avoids spurious instabilities, ensuring stability of passive systems
5. Provided complete mathematical framework for 2D and 3D cases

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Establish a system of dynamical equations describing the coupled evolution of orientation and velocity fields in nematic fluids, requiring:

• Energy conservation
• Avoidance of spurious instabilities
• Independence from near-equilibrium assumptions
• Applicability to both active and passive systems

Model Architecture

1. Vector Order Parameter Description

In 2D, using vector order parameter q = (q₁, q₂), where:

• q₁ = n₁² - n₂² = cos(2θ)
• q₂ = 2n₁n₂ = sin(2θ)

In 3D, through coupled construction: q̃ᵢ = εᵢⱼₖnⱼñₖ

2. Lagrangian Density

3D elastic energy density:

Lq = ½[K₁(div q)² + K₂(q·curl q)² + K₃(q×curl q)²]

2D case:

Lq = ½[K₁(div q)² + K₂(curl q)²]

3. Dynamical Equations

Nematic orientation evolution:

∂ₜq = Γh + ϖ

where:

• h is the molecular field: hᵢ = ∂L/∂qᵢ + ∂ⱼπⱼᵢ
• ϖ = 2A⁻·q is the flow-induced rotation term

4. Hydrodynamic Equations

Generalized Navier-Stokes equation:

ρDₜvᵢ = ∂ᵢ(η⁺A⁺ⱼₗ - 2η⁻εⱼₖA⁻ₖₗ)qₗ - ∂ᵢp

Technical Innovations

1. Local Symmetry Principle: Energy exchange mechanism based on local symmetry of simultaneous rotation of nematic orientation and flow
2. Antisymmetric Stress: Introduction of antisymmetric viscous stress σ⁻ᵢⱼ = -2η⁻ᵢⱼₖA⁻ₖₗqₗ
3. Energy Conservation: Ensures total enthalpy H = E + F - ∫p dx decreases at equilibrium
4. Advantages of Vector Method: More intuitive than tensor methods, avoids normalization issues of director methods

Experimental Setup

Theory Verification Methods

Linear stability analysis employed to verify theoretical correctness:

1. 2D Planar Geometry: Perturbations around base state q₁ = 1, q₂ = 0
2. Fourier Expansion: Perturbations expanded as qᵢ = ε∫q̂ᵢ(k)e^(ik·x)dk
3. Stream Function Method: Incompressible flow described using stream function Ψ

Analysis Framework

Through symmetric and antisymmetric parts of strain tensor:

A± = ½(∂ᵢvⱼ ± ∂ⱼvᵢ)

linearized equation systems are established.

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Stability Analysis

For 2D case, linearized hydrodynamic equation:

ρDₜΨ̂ = -(½η⁺cos²2θ + iη⁻cosθ)Ψ̂

Key Discoveries:

• Real part ensures decay of convective perturbations (standard symmetric viscous effect)
• Imaginary part induces oscillatory decay, embodying nematic-flow interaction
• System remains stable with no spurious instabilities

2. 3D Extension

Using vector stream function vᵢ = εᵢⱼₖ∂ⱼΨₖ for 3D incompressible flow, similarly ensuring system stability.

Comparison with Traditional Theories

• EL Theory: Contains arbitrary "tumbling parameter," causing spurious instabilities in certain parameter ranges
• Tensor Theory: While improving certain aspects, still relies on Onsager relations
• Present Theory: Avoids spurious instabilities, ensuring stability of passive systems

Related Work

Classical Theories

1. Ericksen-Leslie Theory 10-12: Classical director-based approach
2. Tensor Theory 13,14,19: Using tensor order parameter Q_ij = ϱ(nᵢnⱼ - δᵢⱼ/d)
3. Frank Elasticity Theory 18: Describing nematic elasticity

Active Matter Applications

Widely applied to:

• Biological tissues 1-3
• Cellular systems 4,5
• Bacterial colonies 6-8
• Biofilms 9

Theoretical Critiques

Brand et al. 15 pointed out problems with Onsager relation application; authors' previous work 16,17 identified spurious instability issues.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Established new nematic dynamics theory based on local rotational symmetry rather than Onsager relations
2. Introduced antisymmetric viscous stress, correctly describing nematic-flow interactions
3. Avoided spurious instabilities, ensuring theoretical physical validity
4. Provided unified 2D and 3D framework

Limitations

1. Scope of Application: Primarily for uniaxial nematics; biaxial cases require further extension
2. Parameter Determination: Determination of antisymmetric viscosity coefficient η⁻ requires experimental verification
3. Complex Geometries: Applications under complex boundary conditions require further study

Future Directions

1. Active Systems: Extend theory to far-from-equilibrium active systems
2. Experimental Verification: Experimental determination of newly introduced material parameters
3. Numerical Simulation: Develop computational methods based on new theory
4. Biological Applications: Verify theoretical predictions in specific biological systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Proposes novel theoretical framework avoiding fundamental defects of traditional methods
2. Mathematical Rigor: Provides complete mathematical derivations and stability analysis
3. Physical Reasonableness: Based on symmetry principles with clear physical picture
4. Practical Value: Provides more reliable theoretical foundation for active matter research

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient Experimental Verification: Lacks experimental data supporting theoretical predictions
2. Parameter Physical Meaning: Physical interpretation and measurement methods of newly introduced parameters need clarification
3. Application Scope: Primarily theoretical; practical effectiveness remains to be verified
4. Relationship to Existing Results: Requires reassessment of extensive research based on traditional theories

Impact Potential

1. Theoretical Contribution: May trigger fundamental revolution in nematic dynamics theory
2. Application Prospects: Significant implications for active matter and biophysics fields
3. Methodological Value: Symmetry-based methods potentially generalizable to other systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Active Nematic Systems: Bacterial suspensions, active polymers, etc.
2. Biological Tissues: Epithelial cell layers, muscle tissue, etc.
3. Soft Matter Systems: Liquid crystal polymers, colloidal suspensions, etc.
4. Theoretical Research: Nematic phase transitions, pattern formation, and other fundamental problems

References

The paper cites 21 important references covering classical nematic dynamics theory, recent developments, and active matter applications, providing solid foundation for theoretical development.

Overall Assessment: This is a theoretically significant paper proposing a novel theoretical framework for nematic dynamics. While experimental verification requires strengthening, its theoretical innovation and profound analysis of traditional method defects give it potentially major impact. This work may open new directions for soft matter physics and active matter research.