Salt crystallization and deliquescence triggered by humidity cycles in nanopores

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.27309
• Title: Salt crystallization and deliquescence triggered by humidity cycles in nanopores
• Authors: Hugo Bellezza, Marine Poizat, Olivier Vincent
• Classification: cond-mat.soft cond-mat.mes-hall cond-mat.mtrl-sci
• Publication Date: November 3, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.27309

Abstract

This study investigates the response of nanoscale porous materials containing sodium chloride solutions to relative humidity (RH) cycles. Compared to pure fluids, these adsorption isotherms exhibit significantly wider hysteresis, with shapes determined by salt crystallization and deliquescence rather than capillary condensation and Kelvin evaporation. Deliquescence and crystallization shift substantially relative to bulk values, occurring at anomalously low relative humidity. The research systematically analyzes the effects of pore diameter and salt content, employing confined thermodynamics, osmotic effects, and classical nucleation theory to explain the findings.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

The core problem addressed is understanding the phase transition behavior of salt solutions in nanoscale confined environments during humidity cycles, particularly the crystallization and deliquescence processes.

Significance

1. Environmental Science: The evolution of sea salt aerosols affects cloud formation and radiative forcing, representing one of the largest uncertainties in climate models
2. Engineering Applications: Salt crystallization cycles cause material damage, posing challenges for civil engineering, cultural heritage preservation, and underground gas storage
3. Technological Applications: Important implications for desalination, gas separation membranes, energy conversion, and water harvesting technologies

Limitations of Existing Research

• Most studies focus on millimeter to micrometer scales, with limited understanding of nanoscale confinement
• Lack of a consistent framework simultaneously describing humidity-induced crystallization and deliquescence
• Incomplete predictive theory for hysteresis behavior of salt-containing fluids in nanoporous systems

Research Motivation

To establish systematic understanding of salt solution phase transitions in nanoconfined environments, providing theoretical foundations for diverse applications from atmospheric science to materials engineering.

Core Contributions

1. Discovery of New Phase Transition Mechanisms: Demonstrates that RH hysteresis in nanopores is controlled by deliquescence and crystallization rather than capillary condensation and evaporation of pure fluids
2. Revelation of Extreme Confinement Effects: Observes crystallization and deliquescence occurring at record-low RH values, far below bulk values
3. Establishment of Theoretical Framework: Employs confined thermodynamics, osmotic effects, and modified classical nucleation theory (CNT) to explain experimental phenomena
4. Clarification of Nucleation Mechanisms: Demonstrates that crystallization occurs through kinetic nucleation rather than spatial hindrance limitation
5. Provision of Quantitative Predictions: Establishes quantitative relationships between pore diameter and salt content on phase transition RH

Methodology Details

Task Definition

To investigate water adsorption/desorption behavior of sodium chloride solutions in nanoporous materials during relative humidity cycles, quantifying critical RH for crystallization and deliquescence and their dependence on pore diameter and salt content.

Experimental Architecture

Sample Preparation

• Nine mesoporous samples: porous silicon (poSi) and anodic aluminum oxide (AAO)
• Average pore diameter range: <4 nm to 20 nm
• Samples as thin transparent porous structures (thickness 5-75 μm)

Measurement Technique: White Light Interferometry (WLI)

Principle:

• Analyzes reflected light spectrum I(λ) utilizing interference between top and bottom reflections
• Spectrum exhibits periodicity in wavenumber k = 2π/λ
• Fourier transform directly yields optical path length: L = 2nHp
• Water evaporation and condensation alter refractive index n, causing L changes

Mathematical Expression:

Kelvin-Laplace equation: ΔPc = (kBT/vw)lnHc
Kelvin radius: rK = -2σw/ΔPc

Humidity Control System

• Custom vacuum chamber with precise water vapor pressure control
• Relative humidity: H = p/psat(T), T = 25°C
• Cycling rate: a = dH/dt ≃ 10⁻⁴-10⁻³ s⁻¹

Theoretical Models

Thermodynamic Equilibrium Equations

Liquid-vapor equilibrium condition:

Ψ(H) = ΔPc(rK) - Π(m)

where Ψ = kBTlnH/vw is the water vapor potential, Π(m) is the osmotic pressure of the solution.

Derived key equation:

-lnH = rℓ/rK + α₀φS(m)  (Equation 1)

where:

• S = m/m₀ is the supersaturation
• rℓ = 2σwvw/(kBT) ≃ 1.05 nm
• α₀ = Mwm₀

Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT)

Critical radius:

r* = 2σcℓvc / [νkBTln(γS) + ΔPc(rK)Δv]  (Equation 2)

Kinetic nucleation condition:

γS = γ∞S∞ exp(-ΔPc(rK)Δv/νkBT)  (Equation 3)

Technical Innovations

1. In-situ Characterization: WLI simultaneously measures pore diameter (rK) and salt concentration (mi)
2. Theoretical Unification: Unifies spatial hindrance and kinetic nucleation within CNT framework
3. Confinement Effect Quantification: Describes confinement effects through Kelvin radius rK rather than geometric pore diameter rp
4. Parameter-free Predictions: Deliquescence model contains no fitting parameters; crystallization fitted with single parameter (S∞)

Experimental Setup

Sample Parameters

• Material Type: Porous silicon (poSi) and anodic aluminum oxide (AAO)
• Pore Diameter Range: <4 nm to 20 nm
• Salt Concentration Range: 0 < mi ≤ 6.15 mol/kg (NaCl saturation concentration)
• Sample Number: 9 samples with different pore diameters

Measurement Conditions

• Temperature: 25°C
• Humidity Range: 0-100% RH
• Cycle Duration: 0.5-5 hours
• Reproducibility: Multiple measurements per isotherm
• Total Measurements: Over 500 independent isotherms

Evaluation Metrics

• Crystallization RH: Relative humidity of solution→crystal transition
• Deliquescence RH: Relative humidity of crystal→solution transition
• Hysteresis Width: Difference between deliquescence and crystallization RH
• Supersaturation: S = m/m₀

Experimental Results

Major Findings

1. Significant Confinement Effects

• Deliquescence Shift: In 6.4 nm pores, deliquescence RH decreases from bulk value of 75.3% to approximately 65%
• Crystallization Shift: Crystallization RH drops to approximately 35%, far below literature-reported minimum values (40-45%)
• Hysteresis Widening: Salt-containing samples show much wider hysteresis than pure water cases

2. Concentration Independence

Key Finding: Crystallization and deliquescence RH are independent of initial salt concentration mi, explained through thermodynamic equilibrium of Equation (1).

3. Pore Diameter Dependence

Quantitative Relationships:

• Crystallization and deliquescence RH decrease with decreasing pore diameter
• Linear relationship in -lnH vs 1/rK plot
• Excellent agreement between theoretical predictions and experimental data

Theoretical Validation

Deliquescence Prediction

Spatial hindrance model (r* = rK) perfectly predicts deliquescence data:

• No fitting parameters
• Consistent with three-phase equilibrium thermodynamic theory
• Confirms deliquescence corresponds to unstable equilibrium state

Crystallization Prediction

Kinetic nucleation model successfully explains crystallization data:

• Fitting parameter: S∞ = 2.2 ± 0.2
• Consistent with maximum supersaturation of bulk homogeneous nucleation
• Excludes spatial hindrance limitation mechanism

Numerical Results Summary

Related Work

Pure Fluid Phase Transitions in Confinement

• Hysteresis in mesoporous materials typically explained as equilibrium evaporation and metastable condensation
• Recent studies question this simple picture, considering disorder, percolation, pore blocking, and other factors

Salt Solution Confinement Research

• Jain et al. (2019): Proposed spatial hindrance crystallization mechanism
• Talreja-Muthreja et al. (2022): Reported deliquescence shifts from curvature-induced thermodynamic constant corrections
• This Work: First to provide consistent framework simultaneously describing crystallization and deliquescence

Nucleation Theory Development

• Modifications of classical CNT in confined environments
• Distinction between homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation
• Uncertainties in surface energy and kinetic prefactors

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Mechanism Transition: RH hysteresis of salt-containing fluids in nanoporous materials is controlled by deliquescence/crystallization rather than capillary condensation/evaporation
2. Extreme Confinement Effects: Crystallization and deliquescence occur at record-low RH values, far below bulk values
3. Nucleation Mechanism: Crystallization occurs through kinetic homogeneous nucleation rather than spatial hindrance limitation
4. Theoretical Unification: Confined thermodynamics, osmotic effects, and CNT successfully explain all observed phenomena

Limitations

1. Single Salt Species: Only NaCl studied; behavior of other salts may differ
2. Single Pore Model: Theory based on single pore modeling; does not account for pore size distribution and connectivity
3. Surface Effects: Assumes homogeneous nucleation; insufficient consideration of pore wall-crystal interactions
4. Extremely Small Pores: Applicability of continuum methods at molecular scales (rK < 1 nm) questionable

Future Directions

1. Material Expansion: Explore effects of different surface chemistry, wettability, and salt types
2. Smaller Pore Diameters: Investigate phase transitions under extreme confinement
3. Network Effects: Consider pore size distribution, connectivity, and transport in extended systems
4. Application Development: Develop humidity-responsive materials and new characterization methods for porous materials

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Excellent Experimental Design: WLI technique enables in-situ, quantitative measurements with precise experimental control
2. Rigorous Theory: Based on first-principles thermodynamics with clear mathematical derivations
3. Sufficient Data: Over 500 isotherms with strong statistical significance
4. Clear Mechanisms: Clearly distinguishes and explains different mechanisms of deliquescence and crystallization
5. Predictive Capability: Theoretical models possess quantitative predictive power

Weaknesses

1. Parameter Uncertainty: Crystal-liquid interfacial energy σcℓ exhibits large uncertainty (30-90 mN/m)
2. Simplified Assumptions: Homogeneous nucleation assumption may be oversimplified
3. Applicability Range: Theory's applicability at extremely small pore diameters requires verification
4. Complex Systems: Does not account for complexity of real porous materials (distribution, defects, etc.)

Impact

1. Scientific Contribution: Provides new theoretical framework for phase transitions in confined environments
2. Application Value: Important guidance for materials science, environmental science, and engineering applications
3. Methodological Significance: WLI technique generalizable to other confined fluid systems
4. Interdisciplinary Impact: Connects condensed matter physics, materials science, and atmospheric science

Applicable Scenarios

1. Materials Design: Development of humidity-responsive and smart porous materials
2. Environmental Monitoring: Prediction of atmospheric aerosol behavior and climate modeling
3. Engineering Protection: Development of salt damage prevention and cultural heritage preservation strategies
4. Industrial Applications: Optimization of desalination, gas separation, and energy storage systems

References

This paper cites 54 important references, covering:

• Aerosol phase transition research in atmospheric science
• Phase transition thermodynamics in confined environments
• Classical nucleation theory and applications
• Porous material characterization techniques
• Experimental studies of salt crystallization and deliquescence

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality research paper with important contributions in experimental techniques, theoretical analysis, and scientific discoveries. The research is systematic and thorough, with reliable conclusions that significantly advance the relevant field.