Coulomb Force Between Two Dirac Monopoles

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2511.01889
• Title: Coulomb force between two Dirac monopoles
• Author: Alberto G. Rojo (Oakland University)
• Classification: physics.class-ph (Classical Physics)
• Publication Date: October 25, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.01889

Abstract

The model of magnetic monopoles proposed by Paul Dirac in 1931 has long been a subject of theoretical interest in physics because of its potential to explain the quantization of electric charge. While much attention has been given to non-Dirac monopoles, Dirac's model, which involves an infinitely thin solenoid known as a Dirac string, presents subtleties in the interaction between monopoles. In this paper, we show that the force between two Dirac monopoles obeys a Coulomb-like interaction law. This derivation offers an instructive exercise in fundamental electromagnetism concepts and is appropriate for undergraduate and early graduate-level students.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem to be Addressed: This research aims to demonstrate that the interaction between Dirac magnetic monopoles obeys a Coulomb-type force law, a result that is not intuitive when the Dirac string is included.
2. Importance of the Problem:
   • The Dirac magnetic monopole model has been an important theoretical construct since its proposal in 1931 because it can explain electric charge quantization, a fundamental empirical fact
   • Magnetic monopoles play important roles in multiple theoretical physics fields including quantum field theory, grand unified theories, and gauge symmetry
   • Although magnetic monopoles have not been experimentally discovered, their theoretical study has profound significance
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • For non-Dirac magnetic monopoles (satisfying ∇·B = μ₀gδ(x)), the Coulomb interaction is relatively intuitive
   • However, for Dirac magnetic monopoles involving an infinitely thin Dirac string, the Coulomb nature of their interaction is not sufficiently apparent
4. Research Motivation: To provide a pedagogically friendly derivation method suitable for undergraduate and graduate students to understand fundamental electromagnetism concepts, while revealing the essential nature of Dirac monopole interactions.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a Simplified Method for Dirac String Field Calculation: By modeling magnetic monopoles as semi-infinite magnetic dipole lines, a simpler alternative to traditional vector potential-based calculations is provided
2. Rigorously Proved Coulomb Interaction of Dirac Magnetic Monopoles: Through direct force calculation methods, it is demonstrated that static Coulomb force naturally emerges between Dirac magnetic monopoles
3. Provided Educational Value: Offers useful exercises for electromagnetism courses, helping students understand magnetic monopole behavior at both conceptual and computational levels
4. Established Concrete Examples of Electromagnetic Duality: Through analogy with potential difference calculations for charges in electric fields, the monopole interaction force is elegantly derived

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

The task of this paper is to derive the interaction force between two Dirac magnetic monopoles and prove that it obeys Coulomb's law in the form: $F = \frac{\mu_0}{4\pi} \frac{g_1 g_2}{r^2} \hat{r}$ where $g_1$, $g_2$ are magnetic charges and $r$ is the distance between the two monopoles.

Model Architecture

1. Field Model of the Dirac String

The Dirac magnetic monopole is modeled as:

• A semi-infinite thin solenoid, described as a line (or string) γ
• When the cross-sectional area A→0 and the number of turns per unit length n→∞, while keeping InA = g finite
• The corresponding magnetization is: $M(x) = g\hat{k}\delta(x)\delta(y)\theta(-z)$

2. Magnetic Field Calculation

Through the relation B(x) = μ₀(M(x) + H(x)) and ∇·B = 0, we obtain: $\nabla \cdot H(x) = -\nabla \cdot M(x) = g\delta(x)$

Therefore, the H field has the form of a point charge: $H(x) = \frac{g}{4\pi} \frac{x}{|x|^3}$

The complete magnetic field of the Dirac string is: $B_γ(x) = \frac{\mu_0}{4\pi} g \frac{x}{|x|^3} + \mu_0 g \delta(x)\delta(y)\theta(-z)\hat{z}$

3. Interaction Force Calculation

Based on the force formula for a magnetic dipole in a magnetic field: $F = \nabla(m \cdot B(x))$

For two Dirac strings γ₁ (with endpoint at the origin) and γ₂ (with endpoint at position x), the string γ₂ can be viewed as a continuous magnetic dipole line with dipole moment density g₂.

Technical Innovations

1. Magnetic Dipole Line Modeling: Innovatively interprets the Dirac string as a semi-infinite magnetic dipole line, avoiding complex vector potential calculations
2. Electromagnetic Duality Analogy: Cleverly utilizes known results from potential difference calculations for charges in electric fields, obtaining monopole interactions through mathematical correspondence
3. Separated Calculation Strategy: Decomposes the Dirac string field into monopole field and string field components, with only the monopole field part contributing to distant interactions

Experimental Setup

This paper is purely theoretical and does not involve experimental verification. All calculations are based on the classical electromagnetism theoretical framework.

Theoretical Verification Methods

1. Mathematical Consistency Check: Verifies that the divergence of the magnetic field is zero, confirming through surface integrals surrounding the origin that the total magnetic flux is zero
2. Asymptotic Behavior Analysis: Checks whether far-field behavior conforms to the expected monopole field behavior
3. Symmetry Verification: Ensures that results satisfy required physical symmetries

Main Results

Core Derivation Results

Through line integral calculation: $F_{2,1} = -\frac{\mu_0}{4\pi} g_1 g_2 \nabla \int_{γ_2} \frac{d\ell \cdot x'}{|x'|^3}$

Utilizing the analogy with electrostatic potential difference calculation: $\Delta V = -\frac{q}{4\pi\epsilon_0} \int_γ \frac{d\ell \cdot x'}{|x'|^3}$

For a semi-infinite line, $\Delta V = -q/(4\pi\epsilon_0 r)$, therefore: $F_{2,1} = \frac{\mu_0}{4\pi} g_1 g_2 \frac{\hat{r}}{r^2}$

Physical Significance

1. Coulomb-type Interaction: Demonstrates that Dirac magnetic monopoles indeed obey a Coulomb interaction law similar to electric charges
2. Transparency of the Dirac String: Despite its presence, the Dirac string makes no contribution to the long-range interaction force
3. Electromagnetic Duality: Embodies the deep theoretical symmetry between electricity and magnetism

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Dirac's Original Work (1931): Proposed the concept of magnetic monopoles and their relationship to charge quantization
2. Jackson's Classical Textbook: Provides traditional calculation methods based on vector potential
3. Modern Developments: Applications of magnetic monopoles in gauge field theory and grand unified theories

Uniqueness of This Paper's Contribution

• Provides a more intuitive derivation pathway compared to traditional vector potential methods
• Emphasizes pedagogical value, suitable for students at different levels
• Reveals deeper physical connections through electromagnetic duality analogy

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Dirac magnetic monopoles obey Coulomb's interaction law, with the form $F = \frac{\mu_0}{4\pi} \frac{g_1 g_2}{r^2} \hat{r}$
2. The Dirac string does not affect long-range interactions, although its presence is necessary to ensure Maxwell's equations hold
3. Concrete manifestation of electromagnetic duality: magnetic charge interactions have the same mathematical form as electric charge interactions

Limitations

1. Pure Theoretical Construction: Magnetic monopoles have not yet been experimentally discovered
2. Classical Treatment: Does not address quantum effects and relativistic corrections
3. Static Approximation: Only considers interactions in the static case

Educational Value

This derivation provides valuable resources for electromagnetism teaching, helping students:

• Understand the concepts and properties of magnetic monopoles
• Master computational techniques for electromagnetic fields
• Recognize the symmetry and beauty of electromagnetic theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: Provides a more concise and intuitive derivation pathway compared to traditional methods
2. Mathematical Rigor: The derivation process is logically clear with correct mathematical treatment
3. Pedagogical Friendliness: Suitable for students at different levels with excellent educational value
4. Physical Insight: Reveals deep connections of electromagnetic duality

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applicability: Due to the theoretical nature of magnetic monopoles, practical application value is limited
2. Narrow Scope: Only considers static cases without addressing dynamic effects
3. Verification Difficulty: Lacks possibility of experimental verification

Impact

1. Educational Impact: Provides new perspectives and methods for electromagnetism teaching
2. Theoretical Value: Deepens understanding of Dirac monopole properties
3. Methodological Contribution: Demonstrates effective approaches to solving complex physics problems through analogy

Applicable Scenarios

• Advanced electromagnetism course instruction
• Magnetic monopole-related calculations in theoretical physics research
• Theoretical studies of electromagnetic duality

References

The paper cites the following important literature:

1. P. Dirac's original paper (1931) - Foundational work in magnetic monopole theory
2. Jackson's Classical Electrodynamics - Classical electromagnetism textbook
3. Modern magnetic monopole research - Including applications in gauge field theory and topological physics

Although this paper addresses theoretical constructions, through elegant mathematical derivation and clear physical imagery, it provides valuable educational resources for understanding the fundamental properties of magnetic monopoles, exemplifying the perfect combination of mathematical beauty and physical insight in theoretical physics research.