A generalized Frankel conjecture via the Yang-Mills flow

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2511.04003
• Title: A generalized Frankel conjecture via the Yang-Mills flow
• Author: Jiangtao Li (University of California, San Diego)
• Classification: math.DG (Differential Geometry)
• Publication Date: November 7, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.04003v1

Abstract

This paper introduces a new curvature condition on compact Kähler manifolds—2-positive bisectional curvature—and derives a characterization theorem for manifolds with 2-positive bisectional curvature. This result can be viewed as a variant of the classical Frankel conjecture and its generalizations.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

This paper investigates the geometric classification of compact Kähler manifolds, particularly through curvature conditions to characterize special complex geometric structures.

Problem Significance

1. Classical Background: The Frankel conjecture is a milestone result in complex differential geometry, resolved by Siu and Yau in 1980, proving that compact Kähler manifolds with positive bisectional curvature are biholomorphic to complex projective space CP^n.
2. Theoretical Importance: This problem connects differential geometry and algebraic geometry, and is crucial for understanding the geometric structure of Fano manifolds.
3. Generalization Value: Multiple directions of generalization have been pursued:
   • Non-compact case: Yau's uniformization conjecture
   • Compact case: Siu's characterization of complex projective spaces and smooth quadric hypersurfaces, Mok's research on non-negative bisectional curvature

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Siu's m-positivity requires non-negative bisectional curvature, limiting applicability
2. Existing results primarily address positive or non-negative bisectional curvature; intermediate cases are understudied
3. Lack of a unified framework for handling weakened curvature conditions

Research Motivation

The author introduces 2-positive bisectional curvature, a new curvature condition that is weaker than positive bisectional curvature but stronger than Ricci positivity, filling a gap in the spectrum of curvature conditions. The key innovation is not requiring global non-negativity of bisectional curvature.

Core Contributions

1. Introduction of New Curvature Condition: Defines 2-positive bisectional curvature, requiring that for any point x and holomorphic tangent vector U, the sum of the two smallest eigenvalues of R(U,Ū) is positive.
2. Complete Classification Theorem (Theorem 1.3):
   • For n=2: M^2 is biholomorphic to a del Pezzo surface
   • For n≥3: M^n is biholomorphic to CP^n or a smooth complex quadric hypersurface Q^n
3. Methodological Innovation: First application of Hamilton's tensor maximum principle to Yang-Mills flow, establishing a key maximum principle (Corollary 3.5).
4. Explicit Calculations: Provides direct computation of bisectional curvature for the complex quadric hypersurface Q^n as a Hermitian symmetric space, proving it possesses 2-positive bisectional curvature.
5. Generalization Framework: Proposes the general concept of m-positive bisectional curvature and establishes lower bounds for the pseudo-index.

Detailed Methodology

Problem Setup

Input: n-dimensional compact Kähler manifold (M^n, g) whose Kähler metric g satisfies the 2-positive bisectional curvature condition
Output: Biholomorphic classification of M
Constraints: n≥2, manifold is compact

Core Technical Route

1. Definition of Curvature Condition (Section 2)

For any tangent vector U∈T_xM at a point x on the holomorphic tangent bundle TM, R(U,Ū) is a Hermitian operator with real eigenvalues: $\lambda_1(x,U) \leq \lambda_2(x,U) \leq \cdots \leq \lambda_n(x,U)$

Definition 2.1: (M,g) has 2-positive bisectional curvature if and only if $\lambda_1(x,U) + \lambda_2(x,U) > 0, \quad \forall x \in M, \forall U \in T_xM$

2. Construction of Examples

• Case n=2: 2-positivity is equivalent to Ricci positivity; by Yau's theorem, all del Pezzo surfaces (Fano surfaces) admit metrics with 2-positive bisectional curvature.
• Complex Quadric Hypersurface Q^n:
  • Represented as homogeneous space: $Q^n \cong SO(n+2,\mathbb{R})/(SO(n,\mathbb{R})\times SO(2,\mathbb{R}))$
  • Tangent space identified as $M_{2\times n}(\mathbb{R})$
  • Metric: $g(X,Y) = \text{Tr}(XY^T)$
  • Curvature formula (Equation 2.5): $R(X,Y)Z = ZY^TX + XY^TZ - ZX^TY - YX^TZ$

Lemma 2.2 provides explicit expressions for bisectional curvature (Equation 2.6), proving through case analysis that Q^n possesses non-negative and 2-positive bisectional curvature.

3. Yang-Mills Flow Theory (Section 3)

Basic Setup:

• (E,h): rank r complex vector bundle over M with Hermitian metric
• A: integrable unitary connection
• Yang-Mills energy: $YM(A) = \int_M |F_A|^2 \text{vol}_g$
• Yang-Mills equation: $D_A^* F_A = 0$

Yang-Mills Flow (Equation 3.3): $\frac{\partial A}{\partial t} = -D_A^* F_A$

Key Results:

• Theorem 3.1 (Donaldson): Long-time existence
• Theorem 3.2 (Råde, Daskalopoulos): Convergence on Riemann surfaces

4. Application of Hamilton's Maximum Principle

Lemma 3.3: Evolution equation for curvature form $\frac{\partial F_A}{\partial t} = -\Delta_{D_A} F_A$

By Kähler identities, $\sqrt{-1}\Lambda_\omega F_A$ satisfies: $\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\sqrt{-1}\Lambda_\omega F_A = \Delta(\sqrt{-1}\Lambda_\omega F_A)$

Corollary 3.5 (Core Innovation):

1. If $\sqrt{-1}\Lambda_\omega F_A$ is ε 2-positive at t=0, it remains so for all t≥0
2. If $\sqrt{-1}\Lambda_\omega F_A$ is quasi-2-positive at t=0, it becomes strictly 2-positive for all t>0

Proof Strategy:

• Construct convex set $C_\varepsilon(E)$ consisting of ε 2-positive Hermitian endomorphisms
• Verify convexity: use the convexity of $\lambda_1 + \lambda_2 = \inf_{|v_1|=|v_2|=1, \langle v_1,v_2\rangle=0} (\langle Uv_1,v_1\rangle + \langle Uv_2,v_2\rangle)$
• Apply Hamilton's tensor maximum principle (Theorem 3.4)

Proof of Main Theorem (Section 4)

Strategy: Transform the problem into pseudo-index estimation

Pseudo-Index Definition (Definition 4.1): $i(M) = \inf\{-K_M \cdot C : C \text{ is a rational curve}\}$

Key Lemma (Theorem 4.2, Miyaoka, Dedieu-Höring): If M^n is an n-dimensional Fano manifold with i(M)≥n, then M is biholomorphic to CP^n or Q^n.

Proof Steps:

1. Take a rational curve C on M, normalize to obtain $f: \mathbb{CP}^1 \to C \subseteq M$
2. Consider pullback bundle $E = f^*TM$ with Chern connection A_0
3. Evolve along Yang-Mills flow, converging to Yang-Mills connection A_∞
4. Lemma 4.3: $\sqrt{-1}\Lambda_\omega F_{A_\infty}$ is parallel
5. By Kobayashi-Hitchin correspondence, obtain decomposition: $E \cong \mathcal{O}(a_1) \oplus \cdots \oplus \mathcal{O}(a_n)$ where $a_1 \leq a_2 \leq \cdots \leq a_n$ are integer eigenvalues
6. Key Estimate: By Corollary 3.5, $a_1 + a_2 \geq 1$
7. Since $T\mathbb{CP}^1 \otimes \mathcal{O}(D) \cong \mathcal{O}(2+k) \subseteq E$ (D is the zero divisor of f), we have $a_n \geq 2$
8. For n≥3, compute the anti-canonical degree: $-K_M \cdot C = \sum_{i=1}^n a_i = (a_1+a_2) + (a_3+\cdots+a_n) \geq 1 + (n-3) + 2 = n$
9. Therefore $i(M) \geq n$, completing the proof by Theorem 4.2

Technical Innovations

1. Innovation in Curvature Condition

• Weakened Hypothesis: Does not require global non-negative bisectional curvature, only that the sum of the two smallest eigenvalues is positive
• Distinction from Siu's m-positivity: Siu's definition requires non-negativity; this approach is more flexible
• Geometric Intuition: For n=2, 2-positivity reduces to Ricci positivity, reflecting the naturalness of the condition

2. Methodological Breakthrough

• First Application: First application of Hamilton's maximum principle to Yang-Mills flow
• Bridging Role: Connects Ricci flow techniques with Yang-Mills flow theory
• Preservation of Properties: Proves that 2-positivity is preserved along Yang-Mills flow, which is key to the analysis

3. Computational Techniques

• Symmetric Space Method: Directly utilizes Cartan decomposition to compute curvature of Q^n
• Group Action Simplification: Uses isometry group action to reduce computation to special cases
• Explicit Formulas: Provides complete explicit expressions for bisectional curvature (Equation 2.6)

4. Integration of Algebraic and Differential Geometry

• Pseudo-Index Connection: Establishes bridge between curvature conditions and algebraic geometric invariants
• Kobayashi-Hitchin Correspondence: Uses stability theory to analyze vector bundle structure
• Synthetic Method: Integrates analytic, geometric, and algebraic techniques

Experimental Setup

This is a pure mathematics theoretical paper with no numerical experiments or datasets. All results are rigorous mathematical proofs.

Theoretical Verification

1. Example Verification: Explicitly computes that del Pezzo surfaces and Q^n satisfy 2-positive bisectional curvature
2. Logical Completeness: Every theorem has complete proofs
3. Authoritative References: Relies on established theories by Donaldson, Miyaoka, and others

Experimental Results

Main Theoretical Results

Theorem 1.3 (Main Theorem): Let n≥2. An n-dimensional compact Kähler manifold M^n admits a metric with 2-positive bisectional curvature if and only if:

1. For n=2, M^2 is biholomorphic to a del Pezzo surface
2. For n≥3, M^n is biholomorphic to CP^n or Q^n

Corollary 2.3: Q^n has non-negative bisectional curvature with at most one zero eigenvalue for R(U,Ū), and in particular possesses 2-positive bisectional curvature.

Corollary 3.5 (Maximum Principle):

1. ε 2-positivity is preserved along Yang-Mills flow
2. Quasi-2-positivity becomes strict 2-positivity at positive times

Proposition 5.3 (Generalization): If M^n has m-positive bisectional curvature and n>m, then $i(M) \geq n - m + 2$

Theoretical Significance

1. Unified Framework: Places Frankel conjecture and Siu's results in a unified perspective
2. Technical Contribution: Establishes new tools for Yang-Mills flow (maximum principle)
3. Generalization Potential: The m-positivity concept provides foundation for further research

Related Work

Classical Results

1. Frankel Conjecture (1961): Conjectured that compact Kähler manifolds with positive bisectional curvature are CP^n
2. Siu-Yau Theorem (1980): Resolved Frankel conjecture
3. Siu's Generalization (1980): Characterized CP^n and smooth quadric hypersurfaces
4. Mok's Work (1988): Non-negative bisectional curvature case, yielding Hermitian symmetric spaces

Non-compact Case

• Yau Uniformization Conjecture: Non-compact manifolds with positive bisectional curvature are C^n
• Liu's Result (2016): Proved conjecture under maximal volume growth assumption

Weakened Curvature Conditions

1. Orthogonal Bisectional Curvature (Gu-Zhang 2010, Feng-Liu-Wan 2017): Frankel conjecture holds under this condition
2. Orthogonal Ricci Curvature (Ni-Wang-Zheng 2021):
   • Definition: $\text{Ric}^\perp(X) = \text{Ric}(X,\bar{X}) - H(X)$
   • Complete classification in dimension 3 as CP^3 or Q^3
   • Weaker than m-positivity

Positioning of This Work

• Horizontal Comparison: 2-positivity lies between positive bisectional curvature and Ricci positivity
• Vertical Generalization: Proposes general framework for m-positivity
• Methodological Innovation: Introduces Yang-Mills flow techniques to classification problems

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. 2-positive bisectional curvature provides a new classification perspective for Kähler manifolds
2. Yang-Mills flow combined with maximum principle is an effective tool for studying curvature conditions
3. Pseudo-index is a key bridge connecting differential and algebraic geometry

Limitations

1. Dimension Restriction: Results are complete for n≥3, but for n=2 only existence of del Pezzo surfaces is given
2. Curvature Assumptions: Still requires relatively strong positivity conditions
3. Method Limitations: Relies on special properties of Yang-Mills flow on Riemann surfaces

Future Directions (Section 5)

1. Complete Theory of m-positivity

Question: Does the converse of Proposition 5.3 hold? That is, if $i(M) \geq n-m+2$, does M admit m-positive bisectional curvature metric?

• Known to hold for m=1,2 by results in this paper
• m=3 may be handled using Fujita classification
• General case remains open

2. Geometric Analysis Methods for Classification Theory

When pseudo-index <n-1, algebraic geometry lacks complete classification; suggested approaches:

• Use geometric analysis methods like Kähler-Ricci flow based on m-positivity
• Develop new differential geometric classification techniques

3. Relationship with Other Curvature Conditions

• Orthogonal Ricci curvature (NWZ21) is weaker than all m-positivity for m<n
• Understanding m-positivity aids study of high-dimensional orthogonal Ricci curvature manifolds

4. Verification for Specific Fano Manifolds

Check whether manifolds in Fujita's list admit 3-positive bisectional curvature metrics

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation

• Novel Concept: 2-positive bisectional curvature fills a gap in the spectrum of curvature conditions
• Technical Breakthrough: First application of Hamilton's maximum principle to Yang-Mills flow is groundbreaking
• Unified Perspective: Incorporates multiple classical results into a unified framework

2. Methodological Rigor

• Complete Proofs: All main results have detailed rigorous proofs
• Technical Depth: Synthesizes differential geometry, algebraic geometry, and geometric analysis
• Precise Calculations: Curvature calculations for Q^n are completely explicit and verifiable

3. Mathematical Elegance

• Natural Generalization: Reduction to Ricci positivity for n=2 demonstrates concept naturalness
• Symmetry Exploitation: Clever use of group actions simplifies calculations
• Clear Structure: Logical progression from definitions through examples to applications

4. Academic Value

• Interdisciplinary Connections: Bridges Ricci flow, Yang-Mills theory, and algebraic geometry
• Inspiration for Future Work: m-positivity framework provides direction for subsequent research
• Methodological Contribution: Maximum principle technique may have broader applications

Weaknesses

1. Technical Limitations

• Dimension Dependence: For n=2, only existence is obtained via Yau's theorem, lacking unified treatment
• Riemann Surface Specificity: Key reliance on convergence of Yang-Mills flow on 1-dimensional complex manifolds; high-dimensional generalization is difficult
• Still Strong Condition: Although weakening positive bisectional curvature, 2-positivity remains a relatively strong restriction

2. Incompleteness of Results

• Incomplete Classification: For n=2, del Pezzo surfaces admit multiple types; no refined classification provided
• Partial Sufficiency: Main proof establishes necessity; sufficiency relies partly on known examples
• Open Inverse Problem: Converse relationship between m-positivity and pseudo-index remains unresolved

3. Limited Scope of Application

• Compactness Assumption: Methods strongly depend on compactness
• Kähler Restriction: Does not address more general complex manifolds or nearly Kähler manifolds
• Special Geometry Focus: Primarily addresses Fano manifolds; non-Fano cases not discussed

4. Technical Details

• Maximum Principle Verification: Verification of convex set conditions in Corollary 3.5 is correct but somewhat technical
• Algebraic Geometry Dependence: Key use of results by Miyaoka and others; limited original algebraic geometry content
• Computational Complexity: Proof of Lemma 2.2 involves extensive matrix calculations

Impact Assessment

Contribution to the Field

1. Conceptual Contribution: Introduces 2-positivity and m-positivity, enriching curvature condition theory
2. Methodological Contribution: Yang-Mills flow maximum principle may become a standard tool
3. Problem Formulation: Section 5 proposes multiple valuable research directions

Practical Value

• Theoretical Tool: Provides new criteria for studying Kähler manifolds
• Computational Method: Symmetric space curvature calculation techniques are generalizable
• Classification Framework: m-positivity and pseudo-index relationship may systematize Fano manifold research

Reproducibility

• Theoretically Verifiable: All proofs are logically clear and independently verifiable
• Computationally Reproducible: Q^n curvature calculations are completely explicit
• Clear Dependencies: Referenced results are clearly sourced for easy verification

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research

• Complex Geometry Classification: Study geometric structures of special Kähler manifolds
• Curvature Flow Theory: Develop Yang-Mills flow and Kähler-Ricci flow techniques
• Algebraic Geometry: Study Fano manifolds through differential geometric methods

2. Related Problems

• Yau Uniformization Conjecture: Non-compact case may benefit from similar approaches
• Hermitian Metric Existence: Determine whether manifolds admit specific curvature metrics
• Moduli Space Theory: Geometry of Yang-Mills connection moduli spaces

3. Generalization Directions

• Other Curvature Conditions: Study k-positive curvature operators, etc.
• Generalized Geometry: Extend to nearly Kähler or generalized Kähler manifolds
• Quantum Geometry: Possible connections to mirror symmetry

Key References

1. SY80 Siu-Yau: Original paper resolving Frankel conjecture
2. Siu80 Siu: Curvature characterization of CP^n and quadric hypersurfaces
3. Mok88 Mok: Uniformization theorem for non-negative bisectional curvature
4. Don85 Donaldson: Long-time existence for Yang-Mills flow
5. Ham86 Hamilton: Tensor maximum principle
6. Miy04, DH17 Miyaoka, Dedieu-Höring: Pseudo-index characterization theorem
7. NWZ21 Ni-Wang-Zheng: Research on orthogonal Ricci curvature

Summary

This paper successfully generalizes the classical Frankel conjecture by introducing 2-positive bisectional curvature as a new geometric condition. The main innovation lies in applying Hamilton's maximum principle to Yang-Mills flow, establishing preservation of curvature positivity, and completing the classification through pseudo-index estimates. The paper demonstrates technical depth, logical rigor, and provides new tools and perspectives for Kähler geometric classification theory. While subject to dimension restrictions and methodological limitations, the proposed m-positivity framework and open problems point directions for future research, possessing significant theoretical value and inspirational significance.