Failure of the Goldstone Theorem for Vector Fields and Boundary-Mode Proliferation in Hyperbolic Lattices

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2511.16328
• Title: Failure of the Goldstone Theorem for Vector Fields and Boundary-Mode Proliferation in Hyperbolic Lattices
• Authors: Daniel Sela, Nan Cheng, Kai Sun (University of Michigan)
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall (Condensed Matter Physics - Mesoscopic and Nanoscale Structures)
• Publication Date: November 20, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.16328v1

Abstract

Hyperbolic lattices extend crystalline order to curved space, where negative curvature and exponentially growing boundaries reshape collective excitations beyond Euclidean intuition. This paper advances research from scalar fields to vector fields on hyperbolic lattices, using phonons as an example, demonstrating that the Goldstone theorem fails for vector fields in hyperbolic lattices. Unlike in Euclidean crystals where the Goldstone theorem guarantees gapless acoustic phonon modes, hyperbolic lattices with coordination number z > 2d exhibit finite bulk phonon gaps. The study identifies the root cause of this failure: Goldstone modes belong to non-unitary irreducible representations of the translation group and thus cannot form gapless excitation branches. Further investigation reveals that when boundaries are included, the bulk gap is filled with extensive numbers of low-frequency boundary modes.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

The core problem addressed in this paper is: How do collective excitations of vector fields (such as phonons) in hyperbolic lattices with negative curvature deviate from the classical picture in Euclidean crystals, and in particular, does the Goldstone theorem still hold?

Problem Significance

1. Deep Connection Between Geometry and Physics: Hyperbolic lattices provide an ideal platform for studying physical phenomena in negatively curved spaces, bridging condensed matter physics, topology, and geometry.
2. Testing Theoretical Foundations: The Goldstone theorem is a cornerstone of spontaneous symmetry breaking theory. Its validity in curved spaces directly concerns the universality of fundamental physical principles.
3. Discovery of New Physics: Hyperbolic lattices possess two unique geometric features—negative curvature and finite boundary-to-volume ratio—which may lead to novel physical phenomena absent in Euclidean space.
4. Broad Application Prospects: Hyperbolic lattices have been realized in quantum error correction codes, holographic simulations, circuit quantum electrodynamics, and photonic systems. Understanding their fundamental excitations is crucial for practical applications.

Limitations of Existing Research

1. Focus on Scalar Fields: Existing hyperbolic lattice research primarily concentrates on scalar fields (such as spins in magnetic systems), with insufficient study of vector fields.
2. Neglect of Boundary Effects: Most studies employ periodic boundary conditions, overlooking the physical effects of the exponentially large boundaries inherent to hyperbolic lattices.
3. Methodological Limitations: Traditional hyperbolic band theory requires determining all high-dimensional irreducible representations of the translation group, which is computationally infeasible for vector fields.

Research Motivation

The core motivation of this paper is to explore two key questions:

1. Effect of Curvature on Vector Fields: Vector fields directly sense curvature through parallel transport (holonomy effect), fundamentally different from scalar fields.
2. Role of Extensive Boundaries: The boundary-to-volume ratio of hyperbolic lattices remains finite in the thermodynamic limit, necessitating reconsideration of bulk-boundary correspondence concepts.

Core Contributions

The main contributions of this paper include:

1. Discovery of Goldstone Theorem Failure: First demonstration that in hyperbolic lattices with coordination number z > 2d, despite spontaneous breaking of translational symmetry, the bulk phonon spectrum exhibits a finite gap, and the Goldstone theorem no longer guarantees gapless modes.
2. Revelation of Group-Theoretic Root Cause: Identification that Goldstone modes belong to three-dimensional non-unitary irreducible representations of the translation group, and thus are topologically disconnected from the unitary representation manifold defining bulk energy bands.
3. Development of New Computational Method: Proposal of a spectral moments-based method to probe low-frequency phonon density of states and gaps, overcoming the computational infeasibility of traditional hyperbolic band theory.
4. Revelation of Boundary-Mode Proliferation: Demonstration that the bulk gap of finite hyperbolic lattices is filled with extensive numbers of boundary modes, with zero-frequency modes themselves occupying a finite fraction on the boundary.
5. Establishment of "Insulator-Conductor" Duality: Demonstration that hyperbolic lattices exhibit "insulating bulk-conducting boundary" characteristics at low frequencies, similar to topological insulators but with completely different mechanisms.
6. Extension of Theoretical Universality: The developed moment method is applicable not only to hyperbolic lattices but also generalizable to fractals and disordered materials and other uniform systems with long-range order.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Research Object: Phonon systems on hyperbolic lattices {p,q}, where p is the number of edges per face and q is the coordination number at each vertex.

Physical Model:

• M point masses of mass m located at lattice nodes
• Adjacent nodes connected by Hooke springs with stiffness k_e
• Each node has d=2 orthogonal translational degrees of freedom

Core Tasks:

1. Determine whether the bulk phonon spectrum exhibits a zero-frequency gap
2. Calculate the density of states ρ(E) behavior in the low-frequency region
3. Analyze the number and distribution of boundary modes in finite systems

Theoretical Framework

Physical Picture of Goldstone Theorem Failure

In Flat Space:

• Goldstone modes (uniform translation) belong to unitary representations of the translation group
• These zero-energy modes appear in the bulk spectrum (e.g., acoustic branch at k=0)
• Form gapless excitation branches

In Curved Space:

• Phonon displacements are vector fields undergoing non-trivial parallel transport
• Goldstone mode transformations obey three-dimensional non-unitary irreducible representations
• Topologically disconnected from the unitary representation manifold
• Although zero-energy deformations still exist, they cannot guarantee gapless spectrum

Group-Theoretic Analysis

The eigenvalues E of the dynamical matrix D determine phonon frequencies through E = mω². For infinite lattices, translational symmetry implies:

Unitary Representation → Bulk modes (bounded amplitude in space)
Non-unitary Representation → Boundary/corner modes (exponentially growing or decaying amplitude)

Goldstone mode transformation under translation:

g·v_i = Σ_j g_{ji}v_j

where g ∈ SO(1,2) is a hyperbolic translation, and the representation matrix g_ is non-unitary.

Spectral Moments Method

Basic Definition

The n-th order spectral moment is defined as:

⟨E^n⟩ = ∫₀^∞ E^n ρ(E)dE = (1/M)Σ_i[(D^n)_{i1,i1} + (D^n)_{i2,i2}]/2

In the thermodynamic limit, focusing on bulk nodes, by translational symmetry:

⟨E^n⟩ = [(D^n)_{i1,i1} + (D^n)_{i2,i2}]/2

where i can be any bulk node.

Key Insight: Since the model has only nearest-neighbor coupling, (D^n)_{ij,ij} counts the total weight of closed loops of length n starting and ending at node i's degree of freedom j.

Gap Detection Technique

Define the weighted moment:

ℰ_n = ∫₀^E₀ (1 - E/E₀)^n ρ(E)dE

The weight function (1 - E/E₀)^n forms an increasingly sharp peak near E=0 as n increases, making the method sensitive to low-energy density of states.

Assumed Gap Structure:

ρ(E) = {
  0,                    if E < Δ
  const × (E - Δ)^r,    if Δ < E ≪ E₀
}

Through Weierstrass approximation theorem expansion:

ρ(E) = Σ_j c_j[(E/E₀ - Δ/E₀)/(1 - Δ/E₀)]^(r+j)

Define ℱ_n = ℰ_/ℰ_n, expanding as n → ∞:

ℱ_n = 1/(1-Δ/E₀) + (1+r)/(1-Δ/E₀) · 1/n + c₁(1+r)/[c₀(1-Δ/E₀)] · 1/n² + O(1/n³)

Gap Extraction: By fitting the data set {ℱ_n}_^{N₁}, where N₀ and N₁ are chosen sufficiently large so that higher-order corrections are negligible, the gap Δ is extracted.

Method Verification

Benchmark tests on Euclidean lattices:

• Triangular Lattice: Theory ρ(E) ∝ const, fitting yields Δ = 0, r = 0.0411±0.0557 ✓
• Square Lattice: Theory ρ(E) ∝ E^(-1/2), fitting yields Δ = 0, r = -0.5018±0.0018 ✓

Computational Implementation

Real-Space Method ({3,7} Lattice)

1. Construct 8-layer finite {3,7} lattice
2. Select central node ensuring loops of length <15 do not touch boundary
3. Calculate diagonal elements of finite dynamical matrix D_e
4. For central node: D^n = D_e^n (n ≤ 15)

Loop-Counting Method ({8,8} Lattice)

Exploit block structure of dynamical matrix:

D = D₀⊗Σ_t|t⟩⟨t| + Σ_j(D_j^R⊗Σ_t|t⟩⟨tγ_j|) + Σ_j(D_j^L⊗Σ_t|tγ_j⟩⟨t|)

where γ_j are generators of the translation group. Efficiently compute spectral moments through enumeration of weighted loops.

Technical Innovations

1. Bypassing High-Dimensional Representation Calculations: Traditional methods require determining all irreducible representations (infinitely many); the moment method requires only local information.
2. Low-Frequency Accuracy: Compared to continued fraction techniques that lose precision at low frequencies, the moment method specifically probes near zero frequency through weight functions.
3. Model Selection Strategy: Use leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV) to optimize expansion order k, balancing bias-variance tradeoff.
4. Statistical Rigor: Employ weighted nonlinear least squares with weights w_n = Var(ℱ_n)^(-1), statistically optimal.
5. Universality: Method depends only on closed loops, applicable to any uniform system with long-range order.

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

Hyperbolic Lattice Types:

1. {3,7} Lattice: Triangular faces, coordination number 7 (overconstrained, z=7 > 2d=4)
2. {7,3} Lattice: Heptagonal faces, coordination number 3 (underconstrained, z=3 < 2d=4)
3. {8,8} Lattice: Octagonal faces, coordination number 8 (overconstrained)

Physical Parameters

• Spring stiffness: k_e = 1
• Particle mass: m = 1
• Cutoff energy: E₀ = 6 (triangular lattice), E₀ = 2 (square lattice), E₀ = 9.1984k_e ({3,7} lattice)

Computational Details

Moment Calculation:

• Calculate moments up to 15th order (N₁ = 15)
• Fitting data range: {ℱ_n}_^{15} (N₀ = 8)
• Confidence level: 99%

Finite-Size Analysis:

• {3,7} lattice: up to 8 layers
• System size N from tens to hundreds of nodes
• Boundary mode analysis: statistical fraction of modes below gap

Gap Non-Negativity Constraint

Ensure Δ ≥ 0 through parametrization Δ/E₀ = e^(-u).

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Bulk Gap of {3,7} Lattice

Numerical Fitting Result:

Δ/E₀ = 0.0687 ± 0.0007

Corresponding phonon frequency gap:

ω_g = (0.795 ± 0.004)√(k_e/m)

Physical Significance: The infinite {3,7} lattice exhibits insulating bulk behavior at zero frequency, with density of states ρ(ω) = 0 for ω < ω_g.

2. {8,8} Lattice Confirmation

Using the loop-counting method, confirms that the {8,8} lattice likewise exhibits finite bulk gap, validating the universality of the phenomenon.

3. Comparative Analysis of {7,3} Lattice

Fitting Result: ω_g = 0 (gapless)

Maxwell Counting Argument:

• Degrees of freedom per node: d = 2
• Coordination number: z = 3
• Average constraints: z/2 = 3/2 < 2 (underconstrained)
• Conclusion: Floppy modes exist, supporting zero and low-frequency excitations

Key Condition: Bulk gap requires both negative curvature and overconstraint (z > 2d).

Boundary-Mode Proliferation

Zero-Mode Counting Argument

For non-triangular hyperbolic {p,q} lattices, lower bound on zero-mode fraction:

f_lower = 1 - n_e/(2n_v)

where n_e is the number of edges and n_v is the number of nodes.

Key Finding: Even as layer number approaches infinity, this fraction remains non-zero (see Figure 3a).

Numerical Results for {3,7} Lattice

Fraction of modes below gap f(N) as function of system size N:

• Asymptotic value: f → 5-6% (Figure 3b)
• Evidence: f(N)log(N) → ∞, ruling out power-law decay f(N) ~ N^(-α)

Statistical Significance: Number of boundary modes scales with system size (extensive), not subextensive.

Spatial Distribution of Boundary Modes

Figure 3c shows typical eigenmodes within the gap:

• Amplitude squared decays exponentially with distance from center
• Weight concentrated in boundary region
• Characteristic length scale determined by curvature radius R

Rigidity Analysis Theorem

Theorem: If G is a finite planar graph where one face has ≥3 edges and all other faces have ≥4 edges, then G is not 2-rigid.

Proof Key:

2|V| - |E| ≥ 3 + 1/2 > 3

By lemma (dimension of rigidity zero modes ≤ 3), non-trivial zero modes exist.

Application: Non-triangular hyperbolic lattices necessarily support extensive zero modes.

Summary of Experimental Findings

1. Gap Universality: All hyperbolic lattices with z > 2d exhibit bulk gaps
2. Boundary Filling: Bulk gaps in finite systems are completely filled by extensive boundary modes
3. Zero-Frequency Condensation: Zero-frequency modes themselves occupy finite fraction on boundary, analogous to Bose-Einstein condensation
4. "Insulator-Conductor" Duality: At low frequencies, bulk is insulating while boundary is conducting

Related Work

Hyperbolic Lattice Theory

1. Hyperbolic Band Theory 1-6:
   • Maciejko & Rayan (2021-2022): Establish foundations of hyperbolic Bloch theory
   • Cheng et al. (2022): Hyperbolic bands in mechanical networks
   • Lenggenhager et al. (2023): Non-Abelian semimetals
2. Hyperbolic Topological States 7-12:
   • Liu et al. (2022): Topological insulators
   • Zhang et al. (2022-2023): Higher-order topological phases
   • Chen et al. (2024): Topological pumping
3. Scalar Field Studies 13,14,26,27:
   • Spin liquids, Anderson localization
   • Primarily use periodic boundary conditions

Experimental Implementations

1. Circuit QED 19: Kollár et al. (2019) - First experimental realization
2. Circuit Networks 20,21: Lenggenhager, Chen et al. (2022-2023)
3. Photonic Systems 22-24: Huang et al. (2024)

Advantages of This Work Over Related Work

1. First Systematic Study of Vector Fields: Fills important gap in hyperbolic lattice research
2. Reveals New Physical Mechanism: Goldstone theorem failure originates from non-unitary representations
3. Develops New Computational Method: Moment method overcomes high-dimensional representation calculation obstacles
4. Emphasizes Boundary Physics: First quantitative analysis of extensive boundary modes

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Goldstone Theorem Failure: In hyperbolic lattices with z > 2d, despite spontaneous breaking of translational symmetry, the bulk phonon spectrum exhibits finite gap ω_g ≠ 0.
2. Group-Theoretic Root Cause: Failure originates from Goldstone modes belonging to three-dimensional non-unitary irreducible representations of the translation group, topologically disconnected from unitary representations (bulk modes).
3. Necessary Conditions: Gap appearance requires both negative curvature and overconstraint (z > 2d).
4. Boundary Dominance: In finite systems, extensive boundary modes fill the bulk gap, with zero-frequency modes occupying finite fraction on boundary.
5. Methodological Contribution: Spectral moment method depends only on local information and can be generalized to fractals, disordered materials, and other systems.

Limitations

1. Model Simplification: Considers only nearest-neighbor Hooke springs; real materials may have more complex interactions.
2. Two-Dimensional Restriction: Theory primarily targets 2D hyperbolic lattices; higher-dimensional generalization requires further study.
3. Exact Gap Values: Moment method provides numerical estimates; analytical expressions remain to be developed.
4. Finite-Size Extrapolation: Thermodynamic limit behavior of boundary mode fraction requires verification on larger systems.
5. Experimental Correspondence: Theoretical predictions of gaps and boundary modes require direct experimental observation.

Future Directions

1. Topological Phonon States: Explore topological phases and boundary states of phonons in hyperbolic lattices.
2. Nonlinear Effects: Study nonlinear phonon dynamics at large amplitudes.
3. Quantum Effects: Consider effects of quantum fluctuations on Goldstone modes.
4. Experimental Implementation: Direct measurement of phonon gaps and boundary modes on photonic/circuit platforms.
5. Generalization to Other Systems:
   • Phonons in fractal structures
   • Disordered materials (jammed solids, hyperuniform disordered solids)
   • Other vector fields (electromagnetic fields, stress fields)
6. Higher-Dimensional Hyperbolic Spaces: Vector field behavior in three-dimensional and higher-dimensional hyperbolic lattices.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth

• Challenge to Fundamental Principles: Questions and corrects the applicability of the Goldstone theorem in curved space, touching the foundations of symmetry breaking theory.
• Group-Theoretic Rigor: Precisely explains physical phenomena through non-unitary representations of SO(1,2), with complete mathematical arguments.
• Multi-Scale Insights: Establishes clear connections from microscopic (loops) to macroscopic (density of states).

2. Methodological Innovation

• Computational Breakthrough: Moment method cleverly bypasses the infinite-dimensional difficulty of irreducible representations with strong practicality.
• Statistical Rigor: Complete analysis including LOOCV model selection, weighted least squares, and error propagation.
• Strong Universality: Method generalizable to broad classes of uniform systems.

3. Physical Insights

• Novel Physics: Extensive boundary modes and zero-frequency "condensation" transcend Euclidean intuition.
• Clear Conditions: Precisely delineates necessary conditions for gap appearance (negative curvature + overconstraint).
• Elegant Comparative Design: Comparison between {3,7} and {7,3} lattices is conceptually sophisticated.

4. Writing Quality

• Clear Logic: Progression from physical picture → group theory → numerical methods → results is well-structured.
• Effective Visualization: Figures 1-3 effectively convey key concepts and results.
• Comprehensive Supplementary Material: All technical details thoroughly explained.

Weaknesses

1. Absence of Experimental Verification

• All results based on numerical calculations; lacks experimental data support.
• Recommendation: Collaborate with experimental groups to verify on circuit or photonic platforms.

2. Lack of Analytical Gap Expression

• No analytical formula for ω_g as function of {p,q}.
• Numerical fitting depends on parameter choices (E₀, N₀, N₁).

3. Finite-Size Scaling

• Asymptotic behavior of boundary mode fraction f(N) lacks theoretical prediction.
• Maximum system size of hundreds of nodes; larger systems computationally expensive.

4. Deeper Physical Mechanism

• Physical consequences of non-unitary representations could be further elucidated.
• Quantitative relationship between gap and curvature/coordination number not established.

5. Application Scenarios

• Lacks discussion of how to realize/observe phenomenon in real materials.
• Connection to topological physics could be explored more deeply.

Impact

Contribution to Field

1. Theoretical Foundation: Corrects fundamental theorem statement in curved space, affecting symmetry breaking theory.
2. New Research Direction: Opens systematic study of vector fields in hyperbolic lattices.
3. Methodological Contribution: Spectral moment method may become standard tool.

Practical Value

1. Quantum Information: Phonon engineering in hyperbolic lattice quantum error correction codes.
2. Acoustic Devices: Utilize gaps to design acoustic insulators.
3. Photonics: Analogous effects in photonic crystals.

Reproducibility

• High: Detailed method description and comprehensive supplementary material.
• Recommendation: Public code and data release would further enhance reproducibility.

Applicable Scenarios

Direct Application

1. Hyperbolic Lattice Platforms: Circuit QED, photonic lattices, acoustic metamaterials
2. Theoretical Research: Curved-space quantum field theory, topological physics

Generalized Applications

1. Fractal Materials: Sierpinski gaskets, fractal networks
2. Disordered Systems: Jammed solids, glassy states
3. Metamaterials: Five-fold symmetric quasicrystals, aperiodic structures
4. Cosmology: Topological defect phonons in early universe

Limitations

• Requires long-range order (translational symmetry)
• Assumes nearest-neighbor coupling
• Classical (non-quantum) phonons

Key References

1 Maciejko & Rayan, Sci. Adv. 7 (2021) - Hyperbolic Bloch theory
3 Cheng et al., PRL 129 (2022) - Hyperbolic bands in mechanical networks
19 Kollár et al., Nature 571 (2019) - First experimental realization
26 Mosseri & Vidal, PRB 108 (2023) - Scalar field moment method
29 Goldstone, Nuovo Cimento 19 (1961) - Original Goldstone theorem
31 Cheng et al., PRL 133 (2024) - Universal spectral moment theorem

Overall Assessment: This is an exceptionally strong work in theoretical depth, methodological innovation, and physical insight. It challenges the applicability of fundamental physical theorems in curved space, develops new computational tools, and predicts novel physical phenomena. Although lacking experimental verification, the theoretical foundation is solid and expected to significantly impact hyperbolic lattice research, potentially inspiring new directions in curved-space quantum field theory and topological physics. Recommendation: 9/10