2025-11-25T11:31:18.098851

Some q-fractional order difference sequence spaces

Yaying, Baliarsingh, Hazarika
This paper intends to develop a $q$-difference operator $\nabla^{(γ)}_q$ of fractional order $γ$, and give several intriguing properties of this new difference operator. Our main focus remains on the construction of sequence spaces $\ell_p(\nabla^{(γ)})$ and $\ell_\infty (\nabla^{(γ)})$, at the same time comparing these spaces with those already exist in the literature. Apart from obtaining Schauder basis, we determine $α$-, $β$-, and $γ$-duals of the newly defined spaces. A section is also devoted for characterizing matrix classes $(\ell_p(\nabla^{(γ)}),\mathfrak X),$ where $\mathfrak X$ is any of the spaces $\ell_\infty,$ $c,$ $c_0$ and $\ell_1$.
academic

Some q-fractional order difference sequence spaces

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2511.17538
  • Title: Some q-fractional order difference sequence spaces
  • Authors: Taja Yaying (Dera Natung Government College), Pinakadhar Baliarsingh (KIT, Institute of Mathematics and Applications), Bipan Hazarika (Gauhati University)
  • Classification: math.FA (Functional Analysis)
  • Submission Date: November 6, 2025
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.17538

Abstract

This paper develops the q-difference operator ∇q(γ)\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q of fractional order γ\gamma and presents several important properties of this new difference operator. The main work focuses on constructing sequence spaces ℓp(∇(γ))\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}) and ℓ∞(∇(γ))\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}), while comparing these spaces with existing spaces in the literature. In addition to obtaining Schauder bases, the paper determines the α\alpha-dual, β\beta-dual, and γ\gamma-dual of the newly defined spaces. A dedicated section characterizes the matrix classes (ℓp(∇(γ)),X)(\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}),\mathfrak{X}), where X\mathfrak{X} is any one of the spaces ℓ∞\ell_\infty, cc, c0c_0, and ℓ1\ell_1.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problems

This paper aims to address the following core problems:

  1. Construction of fractional-order q-difference operators: Extending classical fractional-order difference operators to the q-calculus framework
  2. Definition of new sequence spaces: Defining and studying the structure of corresponding sequence spaces based on this operator
  3. Characterization of space properties: Determining the topological properties, dual spaces, and matrix transformations of these spaces

Importance of the Problems

  1. Theoretical value: q-calculus has important applications in multiple mathematical fields including combinatorics, approximation theory, special functions, and hypergeometric functions
  2. Unified framework: By introducing the parameter q, multiple existing results can be unified and generalized
  3. Application prospects: q-theory is gradually gaining attention in summability theory and sequence space research

Limitations of Existing Methods

  1. Integer-order restriction: Existing research on q-difference sequence spaces primarily focuses on integer orders (such as ∇q(2)\nabla^{(2)}_q, ∇q(r)\nabla^{(r)}_q)
  2. Limitations of classical difference operators: Traditional fractional-order difference operators ∇(γ)\nabla^{(\gamma)} do not include the q-parameter
  3. Lack of unified theory: A more general framework is needed to unify fractional-order and q-theory

Research Motivation

The authors' motivation stems from the following observations:

  • The q-integer sequence [k]q[k]_q converges to 11−q\frac{1}{1-q} (rather than diverging to infinity), leading to the emergence of new spaces
  • Recent research on integer-order q-difference spaces (Yaying et al., 2022-2023) demonstrates the potential of this direction
  • Successful applications of fractional-order difference operators (Baliarsingh and Dutta, 2015) inspired combining them with q-theory

Core Contributions

The main contributions of this paper include:

  1. Introduction of fractional-order q-difference operators: First-time definition of the q-difference operator for fractional order γ∈(0,1)\gamma \in (0,1): (∇q(γ)g)j=∑k=0∞(−1)kq(k2)Γq(γ+1)[k]q!Γq(γ−k+1)gj−k(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q g)_j = \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} (-1)^k q^{\binom{k}{2}} \frac{\Gamma_q(\gamma+1)}{[k]_q!\Gamma_q(\gamma-k+1)} g_{j-k}
  2. Construction of new sequence spaces: Definition and study of sequence spaces ℓp(∇q(γ))\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q) and ℓ∞(∇q(γ))\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)
  3. Proof of topological properties:
    • Demonstrated that these spaces are BK-spaces (Banach coordinate spaces)
    • Determined explicit expressions for Schauder bases
    • Established isomorphic relationships with classical spaces
  4. Complete characterization of dual spaces: Computed explicit forms of α\alpha-dual, β\beta-dual, and γ\gamma-dual
  5. Matrix transformation characterization: Provided necessary and sufficient conditions for matrix classes (X(∇q(γ)),Y)(X(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q), Y), encompassing 12 different combinations
  6. Unification of existing results: Through special parameter choices, multiple known sequence space theories can be recovered

Detailed Methodology

Basic Concepts

q-integers and q-binomial coefficients

For q∈(0,1)q \in (0,1) and i∈Z+i \in \mathbb{Z}^+, the q-integer is defined as: [i]q=∑j=0i−1qj=1−qi1−q[i]_q = \sum_{j=0}^{i-1} q^j = \frac{1-q^i}{1-q}

The q-binomial coefficient is defined as: (μν)q=[μ]q![μ−ν]q![ν]q!\binom{\mu}{\nu}_q = \frac{[\mu]_q!}{[\mu-\nu]_q![\nu]_q!}

q-Gamma function

The q-Gamma function possesses the following properties:

  1. Γq(t+1)=[t]qΓq(t)\Gamma_q(t+1) = [t]_q \Gamma_q(t) (q-recurrence relation)
  2. Γq(t+1)=[t]q!\Gamma_q(t+1) = [t]_q! for positive integers tt
  3. lim⁡q→1−Γq(t)=Γ(t)\lim_{q \to 1^-} \Gamma_q(t) = \Gamma(t) (convergence to classical Gamma function)

Definition of Fractional-order q-difference Operator

Definition: The fractional-order q-difference operator ∇q(γ):ω→ω\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q : \omega \to \omega is defined as: (∇q(γ)g)j=∑k=0∞(−1)kq(k2)Γq(γ+1)[k]q!Γq(γ−k+1)gj−k(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q g)_j = \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} (-1)^k q^{\binom{k}{2}} \frac{\Gamma_q(\gamma+1)}{[k]_q!\Gamma_q(\gamma-k+1)} g_{j-k}

Expanded form: (∇q(γ)g)j=gj−[γ]qgj−1+q[γ]q[γ−1]q[2]q!gj−2+⋯(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q g)_j = g_j - [\gamma]_q g_{j-1} + q\frac{[\gamma]_q[\gamma-1]_q}{[2]_q!} g_{j-2} + \cdots

Special Cases

This operator encompasses several important special cases:

  1. γ=1\gamma = 1: Reduces to the classical first-order backward difference operator ∇\nabla(∇q(1)g)j=gj−gj−1(\nabla^{(1)}_q g)_j = g_j - g_{j-1}
  2. γ=2\gamma = 2: Second-order q-difference operator (∇q(2)g)j=gj−[2]qgj−1+qgj−2(\nabla^{(2)}_q g)_j = g_j - [2]_q g_{j-1} + q g_{j-2}
  3. γ=r∈Z+\gamma = r \in \mathbb{Z}^+: Integer-order q-difference operator (∇q(r)g)j=∑k=0r(−1)kq(k2)(rr−k)qgj−k(\nabla^{(r)}_q g)_j = \sum_{k=0}^{r} (-1)^k q^{\binom{k}{2}} \binom{r}{r-k}_q g_{j-k}
  4. q→1−q \to 1^-: Converges to classical fractional-order difference operator ∇(γ)\nabla^{(\gamma)}

Basic Properties of the Operator

Theorem 2.1 (Linearity): The operator ∇q(γ)\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q is linear.

Theorem 2.2 (Non-multiplicativity): In general, ∇q(μ)⋅∇q(ν)≠∇q(μ+ν)\nabla^{(\mu)}_q \cdot \nabla^{(\nu)}_q \neq \nabla^{(\mu+\nu)}_q

The authors verify this through a counterexample with μ=ν=1/2\mu = \nu = 1/2.

Lemma 2.1 (Inverse operator): Define the inverse operator (∇q(−γ)g)j=∑k=0∞(−1)kΓq(1−γ)[k]q!Γq(1−γ−k)gj−k(\nabla^{(-\gamma)}_q g)_j = \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} (-1)^k \frac{\Gamma_q(1-\gamma)}{[k]_q!\Gamma_q(1-\gamma-k)} g_{j-k}

Then ∇q(γ)∇q(−γ)=I=∇q(−γ)∇q(γ)\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q \nabla^{(-\gamma)}_q = I = \nabla^{(-\gamma)}_q \nabla^{(\gamma)}_q

Construction of Sequence Spaces

Definition: The sequence spaces ℓp(∇q(γ))\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q) and ℓ∞(∇q(γ))\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q) are defined as:

ℓp(∇q(γ))={g=(gj)∈ω:∇q(γ)g∈ℓp}\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q) = \left\{ g = (g_j) \in \omega : \nabla^{(\gamma)}_q g \in \ell_p \right\}

ℓ∞(∇q(γ))={g=(gj)∈ω:∇q(γ)g∈ℓ∞}\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q) = \left\{ g = (g_j) \in \omega : \nabla^{(\gamma)}_q g \in \ell_\infty \right\}

Matrix Representation

The operator can be represented as a lower triangular matrix:

(-1)^{j-k} q^{\binom{j-k}{2}} \frac{\Gamma_q(\gamma+1)}{[j-k]_q!\Gamma_q(\gamma-j+k+1)}, & 0 \leq k \leq j \\ 0, & k > j \end{cases}$$ **Transformation relations**: - Forward transformation: $h_j = \sum_{k=0}^{j} d^{\gamma}_{jk}(q) g_k$ - Inverse transformation: $g_j = \sum_{k=0}^{j} (-1)^{j-k} \frac{\Gamma_q(-\gamma+1)}{[j-k]_q!\Gamma_q(-\gamma-j+k+1)} h_k$ ## Topological Properties and Structure Theory ### BK-space Structure **Theorem 2.3**: 1. For $1 \leq p < \infty$, $\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ is a BK-space with norm: $$\|g\|_{\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)} = \left( \sum_{j=0}^{\infty} |(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q g)_j|^p \right)^{1/p}$$ 2. For $0 < p < 1$, $\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ is a complete p-normed space 3. $\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ is a BK-space with norm: $$\|g\|_{\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)} = \sup_{j \in \mathbb{Z}^+_0} |(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q g)_j|$$ **Theorem 2.4 (Isomorphic relationships)**: For $X \in \{\ell_p, \ell_\infty\}$, we have $X(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q) \cong X$ ### Schauder Basis **Theorem 2.5**: Define the sequence $\zeta^{(k)}(q) = (\zeta^{(k)}_j(q))$ as: $$\zeta^{(k)}_j(q) = \begin{cases} (-1)^{j-k} \frac{\Gamma_q(-\gamma+1)}{[j-k]_q!\Gamma_q(-\gamma-j+k+1)}, & 0 \leq k \leq j \\ 0, & \text{otherwise} \end{cases}$$ Then: 1. $\{\zeta^{(k)}(q)\}_{k \in \mathbb{Z}^+_0}$ is a Schauder basis for $\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ 2. Each $g \in \ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ has a unique representation: $$g = \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} h_k \zeta^{(k)}(q)$$ where $h_j = (\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q g)_j$ 3. $\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ does not have a Schauder basis ## Dual Space Theory ### Definition of Dual Spaces For a sequence space $X$, define: - **$\alpha$-dual**: $X^{\alpha} = M(X, \ell_1)$ (termwise products in $\ell_1$) - **$\beta$-dual**: $X^{\beta} = M(X, cs)$ (termwise products with convergent series) - **$\gamma$-dual**: $X^{\gamma} = M(X, bs)$ (termwise products with bounded series) ### $\alpha$-dual **Theorem 3.1**: Define the set $$S(q) = \left\{ a : \sup_{J \in \mathcal{Z}} \sup_{k} \left| \sum_{j \in J} (-1)^{j-k} \frac{\Gamma_q(-\gamma+1)}{[j-k]_q!\Gamma_q(-\gamma-j+k+1)} a_j \right|^p < \infty \right\}$$ $$S_{(p')}(q) = \left\{ a : \sup_{J \in \mathcal{Z}} \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} \left| \sum_{j \in J} (-1)^{j-k} \frac{\Gamma_q(-\gamma+1)}{[j-k]_q!\Gamma_q(-\gamma-j+k+1)} a_j \right|^{p'} < \infty \right\}$$ Then: $$\{\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)\}^{\alpha} = \begin{cases} S(q), & 0 < p \leq 1 \\ S_{(p')}(q), & 1 < p < \infty \end{cases}$$ $$\{\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)\}^{\alpha} = S_{(1)}(q)$$ ### $\beta$-dual and $\gamma$-dual **Theorems 3.2 and 3.3**: Define sets $T_1(q), T_2(q), T_3(q), T_4(q)$ involving limit existence and series convergence conditions, then: $$\{\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)\}^{\beta} = \begin{cases} T_1(q) \cap T_3(q), & 0 < p \leq 1 \\ T_1(q) \cap T_2(q), & 1 < p < \infty \end{cases}$$ $$\{\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)\}^{\beta} = T_1(q) \cap T_4(q)$$ $$\{\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)\}^{\gamma} = \begin{cases} T_3(q), & 0 < p \leq 1 \\ T_2(q), & 1 < p < \infty \end{cases}$$ ## Matrix Transformation Characterization ### Main Theorem **Theorem 4.1 (Core characterization theorem)**: Let $X \in \{\ell_p, \ell_\infty\}$. Then $\Phi = (\phi_{jk}) \in (X(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q), Y)$ if and only if: 1. $\Psi^{(j)} = (\psi^{(j)}_{mk}) \in (X, c)$ for all $j \in \mathbb{Z}^+_0$ 2. $\Psi = (\psi_{jk}) \in (X, Y)$ where the transformation matrices are defined as: $$\psi^{(j)}_{mk} = \begin{cases} \sum_{v=k}^{m} (-1)^{v-k} \frac{\Gamma_q(-\gamma+1)}{[v-k]_q!\Gamma_q(-\gamma-v+k+1)} \phi_{jv}, & 0 \leq k \leq m \\ 0, & k > m \end{cases}$$ $$\psi_{jk} = \sum_{v=k}^{\infty} (-1)^{v-k} \frac{\Gamma_q(-\gamma+1)}{[v-k]_q!\Gamma_q(-\gamma-v+k+1)} \phi_{jv}$$ ### Specific Matrix Classes **Lemma 4.1**: The paper completely characterizes 12 matrix classes $(X, Y)$ through Table 1, where: - $X \in \{\ell_1(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q), \ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q), \ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)\}$ - $Y \in \{\ell_1, c_0, c, \ell_\infty\}$ Each case provides necessary and sufficient conditions through combination numbering (e.g., "1 & 11" denotes the combination of conditions (4.5), (4.6), and (3.7)). ### Application Corollaries The paper also provides several corollaries: **Corollary 4.2**: Characterizes $(X, \ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q))$ and $(X, \ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q))$, where $X \in \{\ell_1, c_0, c, \ell_\infty\}$ **Corollary 4.3**: Characterizes matrix transformations to series spaces $\{bs, cs, cs_0\}$ **Corollary 4.4**: Characterizes matrix transformations to q-Cesàro sequence spaces **Corollary 4.5**: Characterizes matrix transformations between fractional-order q-difference spaces ## Related Work ### Classical Difference Sequence Spaces 1. **Kızmaz (1981)**: First introduced difference spaces $c_0(\Delta)$, $c(\Delta)$, $\ell_\infty(\Delta)$ 2. **Et (1993)**: Extended to second-order differences $\Delta^2$ 3. **Başar and Altay (2003)**: Studied the space $bv_p = (\ell_p)_{\nabla}$ 4. **Et and Çolak (1995), Malkowsky and Parashar (1997)**: Studied $r$-order difference spaces ### Fractional-order Difference Spaces 1. **Baliarsingh and Dutta (2015)**: Introduced fractional-order difference operator $\nabla^{(\gamma)}$ $$(\nabla^{(\gamma)}g)_j = \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} (-1)^k \frac{\Gamma(\gamma+1)}{k!\Gamma(\gamma-k+1)} g_{j-k}$$ 2. **Dutta and Baliarsingh (2014)**: Studied paranormed fractional-order difference spaces 3. **Özger (2019)**: Studied compactness of $\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)})$ 4. **Yaying (2022)**: Studied Riesz fractional-order difference spaces ### q-difference Sequence Spaces 1. **Demiriz and Şahin (2016), Yaying et al. (2021)**: Introduced spaces generated by q-Cesàro matrices 2. **Yaying et al. (2022)**: Studied second-order q-difference spaces $X_{\nabla^{(2)}_q}$, where $$(\nabla^{(2)}_q g)_j = g_j - (1+q)g_{j-1} + qg_{j-2}$$ 3. **Yaying et al. (2023)**: Studied $r$-order q-difference spaces $c_0(\nabla^{(r)}_q)$ and $c(\nabla^{(r)}_q)$ $$(\nabla^{(r)}_q g)_j = \sum_{k=0}^{r} (-1)^k q^{\binom{k}{2}} \binom{r}{k}_q g_{j-k}$$ 4. **Ellidokuzoğlu and Demiriz (2023)**: Studied $\ell_p(\Delta^r_q)$ spaces ### Innovation of This Paper This paper is the first to combine **fractional-order** and **q-theory**, filling a research gap and unifying all the above special cases. ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. **Successful construction of fractional-order q-difference operators**: $\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q$ is a natural generalization of classical fractional-order operators and integer-order q-operators 2. **Complete space theory**: - Demonstrated that $\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ and $\ell_\infty(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ are BK-spaces - Determined explicit forms of Schauder bases - Computed all dual spaces 3. **Complete characterization of matrix transformations**: Provided necessary and sufficient conditions for 12 matrix classes 4. **Unification**: Through parameter selection, at least 5 classes of known sequence space theories can be recovered ### Limitations 1. **Parameter restrictions**: The paper primarily considers true fractions $\gamma \in (0,1)$; the case $\gamma > 1$ is not sufficiently discussed 2. **Non-multiplicativity**: The operator does not satisfy $\nabla^{(\mu)}_q \cdot \nabla^{(\nu)}_q = \nabla^{(\mu+\nu)}_q$, which limits applications of certain algebraic properties 3. **Computational complexity**: The conditions for dual spaces and matrix classes involve complex q-Gamma functions and infinite series, making practical verification difficult 4. **Application scenarios**: The paper does not provide concrete application examples or numerical instances 5. **Convergence conditions**: The convergence conditions for the infinite series in the operator definition are not discussed in detail ### Future Directions The paper explicitly proposes in its conclusion: 1. **Extension to convergence spaces**: Similar study of properties of $c(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ and $c_0(\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q)$ 2. **Spectral theory**: Determining the spectrum of operator $\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q$ on $\ell_1$ 3. **Higher-order generalizations**: Considering the case $\gamma > 1$ 4. **Application research**: Applying the theory to approximation theory, summability theory, and other fields ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Strong theoretical innovation** - First systematic combination of fractional calculus with q-theory, opening a new research direction - Natural operator definition that includes multiple important special cases as limiting cases - Construction of inverse operator (Lemma 2.1) is an important theoretical contribution 2. **Complete and systematic results** - Forms a complete theoretical system from operator definition, space construction, topological properties to dual spaces and matrix transformations - Very detailed characterization of dual spaces ($\alpha$-, $\beta$-, $\gamma$-duals) - All 12 matrix transformation cases are characterized, demonstrating strong completeness 3. **Mathematical rigor** - Clear logical flow in theorem proofs using standard functional analysis techniques - Full utilization of properties of triangular matrices and existing lemmas - Verification of special cases enhances result credibility 4. **Unification and generalizability** - Can recover at least 5 classes of known results through parameter selection - Provides a unified theoretical framework for subsequent research - Systematic presentation in Tables 1 and 2 facilitates application 5. **Clear writing** - Sufficient background introduction starting from q-calculus fundamentals - Standardized notation system with clear definitions - Logical structure and smooth flow ### Weaknesses 1. **Lack of concrete examples** - No numerical examples or calculations of specific sequences - Dual space conditions are overly abstract and difficult to understand intuitively - Missing diagrams or visual aids 2. **Insufficient convergence discussion** - Convergence conditions for infinite series in operator definition not analyzed in detail - No characterization of convergence domain - Insufficient discussion of which sequence classes the operator is defined on 3. **Impact of non-multiplicativity** - Theorem 2.2 indicates non-multiplicativity but does not deeply analyze its consequences - May limit applications of certain theories (e.g., semigroup theory) 4. **Unclear application orientation** - Strong theoretical focus but no clear practical application scenarios - Connections with other mathematical branches (e.g., approximation theory, differential equations) not established - Lack of practical examples for motivation 5. **Technical details** - Some proofs (e.g., Theorem 2.3) marked as "customary practice" and omitted, potentially affecting completeness - Many references to q-Gamma function properties without detailed derivations - Condition numbering system in Table 1 (conditions 1-13), while concise, is not user-friendly on first reading 6. **Insufficient comparative analysis** - Limited specific comparisons with classical fractional-order spaces $\ell_p(\nabla^{(\gamma)})$ - Effects of parameter q not demonstrated through examples - Inclusion relationships between spaces under different parameter choices not discussed ### Impact Assessment **Contribution to the field**: - **High**: Fills the theoretical gap in fractional-order q-difference sequence spaces - Provides foundational framework and tools for subsequent research - Unifies multiple existing results with strong theoretical value **Practical value**: - **Moderate**: Currently primarily theoretical contributions; practical applications not yet developed - Potential application fields: q-approximation theory, quantum calculus, discrete fractional-order equations **Reproducibility**: - **High**: Clear definitions and theorem statements with complete proof logic - However, lacks code or numerical verification; actual computation may be difficult **Expected impact**: - Likely to become foundational literature for fractional-order q-sequence space theory - Will inspire subsequent research on spectral theory, compact operators, approximation properties - May be applied to research on q-differential and q-integral equations ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Theoretical mathematics research** - Sequence space theory in functional analysis - Operator theory and spectral theory - Theoretical development of q-calculus 2. **Potential application fields** - **Quantum calculus**: q-parameter related to quantum group theory - **Discrete fractional-order systems**: Solution spaces of fractional-order difference equations - **Signal processing**: Design of discrete fractional-order filters - **Combinatorics**: q-analogues of combinatorial identities - **Approximation theory**: Convergence analysis of q-Bernstein operators 3. **Further research directions** - Spectral theory: Determining spectrum of $\nabla^{(\gamma)}_q$ on different spaces - Compactness: Characterization of compact operators - Applications: Applying theory to specific mathematical physics problems ### Comprehensive Evaluation This is a **theoretically strong paper with complete and systematic results** in functional analysis. The authors successfully combine fractional calculus with q-theory, constructing a new operator class and conducting in-depth research on corresponding sequence spaces. The paper's main value lies in: 1. **Pioneering nature**: First systematic study of fractional-order q-difference sequence spaces 2. **Completeness**: Forms a complete system from basic definitions to advanced properties (duals, matrix transformations) 3. **Unification**: Incorporates multiple existing results into a unified framework Main shortcomings include lack of concrete examples and application orientation, making the theory appear quite abstract. Supplementing numerical examples, convergence analysis, and practical applications would significantly enhance the paper's impact. For researchers in **functional analysis and sequence space theory**, this is an important reference worth careful study; for **applied mathematics** researchers, new tools can be obtained, but further application theory development is needed. **Recommendation Index**: ★★★★☆ (4/5) - Theoretical contribution: ★★★★★ - Practical value: ★★★☆☆ - Readability: ★★★★☆ - Completeness: ★★★★★ ## Selected Important References [1] A. Alotaibi, T. Yaying, S.A. Mohiuddine, **Sequence spaces and spectrum of q-difference operator of second order**, Symmetry, 14(6) (2022), 1155. [7] F. Başar, B. Altay, **On the space of sequences of p-bounded variation and related matrix mappings**, Ukrainian Mathematical Journal, 55 (2003), 136-147. [8] P. Baliarsingh, S. Dutta, **A unifying approach to the difference operators and their applications**, Bol. Soc. Paran. Mat. 33 (2015), 49-57. [10] S. Demiriz, A. Şahin, **q-Cesàro sequence spaces derived by q-analogues**, Adv. Math. 5(2) (2016), 97–110. [16] V. Kac, P. Cheung, **Quantum Calculus**, Springer, New York, (2002). [22] F. Özger, **Characterisations of compact operators on ℓp−type fractional sets of sequences**, Demonstr. Math., 52 (2019), 105-115. [26] T. Yaying, B. Hazarika, S.A. Mohiuddine, M. Et, **On sequence spaces due to lth order q-difference operator and its spectrum**, Iran. J. Sci. 47 (2023), 1271-1281.