Caustic crossings in giant arcs with extended dark matter objects

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2511.20761
• Title: Caustic crossings in giant arcs with extended dark matter objects
• Authors: Djuna Croon, Benedict Crossey, Jose Maria Diego, Bradley J. Kavanagh, Jose Maria Palencia
• Institutions: Durham University (UK), Instituto de Fisica de Cantabria (Spain)
• Classification: astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA, hep-ph
• Submission Date: November 25, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.20761

Abstract

This paper investigates caustic crossings observed in giant arcs behind galaxy clusters, which provide a powerful tool for detecting dark matter substructure. While previous work focused primarily on point-like lenses (such as primordial black holes), this work extends the framework to extended dark objects (EDOs), including ultracompact minihalos formed from the collapse of primordial overdensities. The authors establish an analytical model for EDO microlensing embedded within galaxy cluster macrolensing potentials, deriving the corresponding caustic curves and light curves. The study demonstrates that, depending on the EDO size relative to the effective Einstein radius, they can produce additional narrow caustic curves, leading to new features in light curves. Applying this framework to the MACS J1149 LS1 "Icarus" event, the authors constrain EDOs with radii up to $10^7 R_\odot$. Results show that caustic crossing events can detect EDOs at larger physical scales, complementing Galactic microlensing searches.

Research Background and Motivation

Scientific Problem

The core question addressed is: How can caustic crossing events in galaxy cluster gravitational lensing be utilized to constrain the properties and abundance of extended dark objects (EDOs)?

Research Significance

1. New Observational Window: The 2017 discovery of MACS J1149 LS1 ("Icarus") marked the first observation of an individual star at cosmological distance through gravitational lensing, opening new pathways for dark matter detection.
2. Dark Matter Candidates: Multiple theoretically predicted dark matter forms possess finite spatial scales, including:
   • Ultracompact minihalos (UCMHs)
   • Boson stars
   • Axion miniclusters
3. Complementary Detection: Traditional Galactic microlensing searches rapidly lose sensitivity to large-scale extended objects, while galaxy cluster caustic crossing events can detect dark objects at much larger physical scales.

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Point Source Assumption: Previous work primarily focused on point-like lenses such as primordial black holes, unable to describe dark matter objects with finite spatial extent.
2. Limited Detection Range: Galactic microlensing searches have small Einstein radii (parsec scales), restricting the physical scales of detectable EDOs.
3. Missing Theoretical Framework: Lack of systematic analytical framework to describe extended lens microlensing effects in macrolensing backgrounds.

Research Motivation

The authors' core insight is that galaxy clusters' strong tangential magnification ($\mu_t \sim 100$) and cosmological distances effectively amplify the Einstein radius, enabling caustic crossing events to detect EDOs at physical scales far exceeding those accessible to traditional microlensing searches (reaching $10^7 R_\odot$ scales).

Core Contributions

1. Analytical Model Framework: Establishes a complete analytical model describing the microlensing effects of extended dark objects embedded in galaxy cluster potentials, generalizing the Chang-Refsdal configuration.
2. Caustic Structure Analysis: Derives the caustic structures produced by EDOs, discovering that specific mass distributions can produce additional narrow caustics, leading to new features in light curves.
3. Effective Einstein Radius: Defines the efficiency factor $\epsilon_{\rm EDO}$ and effective Einstein radius $\bar{R}_E^{\rm EDO}$ for extended lenses, quantifying the reduced lensing power of EDOs compared to point lenses.
4. Icarus Event Constraints: Applies the framework to analyze the MACS J1149 LS1 Icarus event, providing constraints on EDO abundance at different radii, demonstrating detectability up to $10^7 R_\odot$.
5. Complementary Parameter Space: Demonstrates that the EDO parameter space probed by galaxy cluster caustic crossings complements Galactic microlensing searches, providing new tools for dark matter research.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Inputs:

• Mass distribution of extended dark object $\rho(r)$
• Macrolens convergence $\bar{\kappa}$ and shear $\bar{\gamma}$
• Source star trajectory $(u_1(t), u_2(t))$

Outputs:

• Caustic curves (in source plane)
• Critical curves (in lens plane)
• Time-varying magnification $\mu(t)$ (light curve)

Constraints:

• Constant convergence and shear approximation (valid near critical curves)
• Point source approximation (or finite source effects considered)

Model Architecture

1. Normalized Mass Distribution

Define the normalized projected mass distribution on the lens plane: $m(\tau) \equiv \frac{M(\tau\theta_E)}{M}$

where $M(\theta) = 2\pi D_L^2 \int_0^\theta d\theta' \theta' \Sigma(\theta')$, $\Sigma(\theta)$ is the projected surface density, and $\theta_E$ is the point lens Einstein angle.

2. Lens Equation

In normalized coordinates $\tau \equiv \theta/\theta_E$ and $u \equiv \beta/\theta_E$, the lens equation for an extended lens is:

$u_1 = \frac{\tau_1}{\mu_r} - \frac{\tau_1}{\tau^2}m(\tau)$$u_2 = \frac{\tau_2}{\mu_t} - \frac{\tau_2}{\tau^2}m(\tau)$

where $\mu_r^{-1} = 1-\bar{\kappa}+\bar{\gamma}$ and $\mu_t^{-1} = 1-\bar{\kappa}-\bar{\gamma}$ are the radial and tangential macrolensing magnifications, respectively.

3. Magnification Matrix

The inverse magnification is given by the Jacobian determinant:

$\mu^{-1} = \left|\left(\frac{1}{\mu_r} - \kappa^{\mu l}(\tau)\right)\left(\frac{1}{\mu_t} - \kappa^{\mu l}(\tau)\right) - \gamma^2_{\mu l,t}(\tau) - \left(\frac{1}{\mu_r}-\frac{1}{\mu_t}\right)\gamma_{\mu l,t}(\tau)\cos 2\phi\right|$

where the local convergence, mean convergence, and tangential shear of the microlens are defined as: $\kappa^{\mu l}(\tau) \equiv m'(\tau)/2\tau$$\bar{\kappa}^{\mu l}(\tau) \equiv m(\tau)/\tau^2$$\gamma_{\mu l,t}(\tau) \equiv \bar{\kappa}^{\mu l}(\tau) - \kappa^{\mu l}(\tau)$

4. Critical Curves and Caustics

Critical curves are determined by $\mu^{-1}=0$. For the $\cos 2\phi = 1$ direction:

Primary Critical Curve (point-like): $\tau^2 - \mu_t m(\tau) = 0 \quad \text{...(8)}$

Secondary Critical Curve (EDO-specific): $\tau^2 - \mu_r(\tau m'(\tau) - m(\tau)) = 0 \quad \text{...(9)}$

When $\kappa^{\mu l} > \gamma_{\mu l,t}$ (local convergence exceeds tangential shear), equation (9) can produce additional critical curves.

Technical Innovations

1. Effective Einstein Radius

Define the EDO efficiency factor by solving equation (8): $\epsilon_{\rm EDO}^2 - m(\epsilon_{\rm EDO}\sqrt{\mu_t}) = 0$

The effective Einstein radius is: $\bar{R}_E^{\rm EDO} = \epsilon_{\rm EDO}\sqrt{\mu_t}\theta_E D_L = \epsilon_{\rm EDO}\sqrt{\frac{4GM\mu_t}{c^2}\frac{D_L D_{LS}}{D_S}}$

For point lenses, $\epsilon_{\rm EDO}=1$; for extended objects, $\epsilon_{\rm EDO}<1$ quantifies the reduced lensing power.

2. Point-Like Lens Behavior Criterion

The condition for an EDO to behave like a point lens is: $\tau_m \equiv \frac{R_{\rm lens}}{R_E} \lesssim \sqrt{\mu_t}$

This shows how the macrolens tangential magnification effectively extends the scale range of "point-like" behavior.

3. Multiple Caustic Structures

For shallow-core mass distributions (e.g., boson stars), a double caustic structure appears when $\tau_m \sim 2$:

• Outer caustic corresponds to the primary critical curve
• Inner caustic corresponds to the secondary critical curve
• Source star crossing produces 5 images (rather than 4 for point lenses)

When $\tau_m \sim \sqrt{\mu_t}$, the two caustics approach each other, appearing as a single symmetric spike in the light curve.

Experimental Setup

Observational Data

MACS J1149 LS1 "Icarus" Event:

• Redshift: $z = 1.49$
• Observed peak magnitude: $m_{\rm peak} \sim 26$
• Macrolens parameters: $\mu_t \sim 100$, $\mu_r \sim 3$
• Source star radius upper limit: $R_{\rm source} \lesssim 260 R_\odot$ (based on finite source effect duration <10 days)
• Einstein angle: $\theta_E = 1.8 \times 10^{-6}(M/M_\odot)^{1/2}$ arcsec
• Lens distance: $D_L = 6.4$ kpc arcsec$^{-1}$

EDO Mass Distribution Models

The paper examines multiple EDO models (reference 23):

1. Boson Stars: Shallow-core distribution, $\kappa^{\mu l} \approx \bar{\kappa}^{\mu l}$
2. NFW Profile: Standard dark matter halo distribution
3. Other Dense Distributions: Mass distributions with varying steepness

The characteristic radius is defined as $R_{90}$: the radius containing 90% of total mass.

Constraint Methods

1. Minimum Peak Magnitude

Based on maximum magnification from finite source effects: $\mu_{\rm max} \approx \mu_t\mu_r\sqrt{\frac{\theta_E}{\sqrt{\mu_t}\beta_R}}$

Converting to peak magnitude: $m_{\rm peak,min} \approx 25.1 - 0.625\log_{10}\left(\frac{M}{M_\odot}\right) - 1.875\log_{10}\left(\frac{\mu_t}{100}\right)$

2. Optical Depth and Saturation Condition

Define the optical depth of EDOs: $\Theta_{\rm EDO} = \frac{\Sigma}{M}\pi\bar{R}_E^{\rm EDO\,2} = \frac{\Sigma}{M}\pi\epsilon_{\rm EDO}^2\mu_t R_E^2$

Saturation occurs when $\Theta_{\rm EDO} \sim 1$, corresponding to saturation tangential magnification: $\mu_{t,{\rm sat},{\rm EDO}} \simeq f_{\rm co}^{-1}\epsilon_{\rm EDO}^{-2}$

where $f_{\rm co} \equiv \Sigma/\Sigma_{\rm crit}$ is the surface density fraction of compact objects, and $\Sigma_{\rm crit} = 2.4 \times 10^3 M_\odot$ pc$^{-2}$.

3. Constraint Conditions

By requiring: $m_{\rm peak,min}\big|_{\mu_t=\mu_{t,{\rm sat}}} = 26$

solve for the upper limit on $f_{\rm co}$.

Mass Range Partitioning

1. $M < 2M_\odot$: Assume Icarus is explained by intracluster light (ICL) stars (conservative assumption $M=2M_\odot$)
2. $M \geq 2M_\odot$: Assume DM lens explanation, constraints weaken with increasing mass
3. Low Mass Cutoff: When microcaustic is smaller than source star size, $\theta_E/\mu_t < \beta_R$, constraints become ineffective

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Caustic Structure and Light Curves

Figure 1 displays caustic structures and light curves for boson star lensing:

$\tau_m = 2$ Case (left panel):

• Double caustic structure appears (inner and outer)
• Light curve shows two additional narrow spike features
• Peak spacing depends on source star trajectory
• Feature width is very narrow (possibly days or shorter), presenting observational challenges

$\tau_m = 22 \approx \sqrt{\mu_t}$ Case (right panel):

• Two caustics compressed in $u_2$ direction
• Appears as single symmetric spike in light curve
• Differs from point lens double-peak structure

$\tau_m \gg \sqrt{\mu_t}$ Case:

• Caustics completely disappear
• EDO too diffuse to produce significant magnification

2. Efficiency Factor

Figure 2 shows the efficiency factor $\epsilon_{\rm EDO}$ variation with normalized radius $R_{90}/\sqrt{\mu_t}R_E$ for different EDO models:

• $R_{90} \leq \sqrt{\mu_t}R_E$: $\epsilon_{\rm EDO} \approx 1$, EDO behaves as point lens
• $R_{90} > \sqrt{\mu_t}R_E$: $\epsilon_{\rm EDO}$ drops rapidly, lensing efficiency decreases
• Different mass distributions show different decline rates; shallow-core distributions (boson stars) decline slowest

3. Icarus Event Constraints

Figure 3 provides constraints on compact object fraction $f_{\rm co}$:

Point Lenses (dashed line):

• $M \sim 1M_\odot$: $f_{\rm co} \lesssim 10^{-2}$
• $M \sim 10^3M_\odot$: $f_{\rm co} \lesssim 10^{-1}$
• Consistent with Ref. 4 results (differences mainly from assumed ICL mass)

Extended Dark Objects (colored solid lines, different radii):

• $R_{90} = 10^4 R_\odot$: Constraints similar to point lenses
• $R_{90} = 10^5 R_\odot$: Constraints weaken by 0.5-1 order of magnitude at $M \sim 1-100M_\odot$
• $R_{90} = 10^6 R_\odot$: Constraints significantly weaken at $M \sim 10-1000M_\odot$
• $R_{90} = 10^7 R_\odot$: Constraints effective only for $M \gtrsim 100M_\odot$

Key Findings:

1. Detectable EDO radii far exceed Galactic microlensing searches (latter limited to $R \lesssim 10^3 R_\odot$)
2. Macrolens $\sqrt{\mu_t}$ enhancement factor extends effective detection radius by ~$\sqrt{100}=10$ times
3. Cosmological distance further increases Einstein radius

Parameter Space Analysis

Local to Cosmological Fraction Conversion

Relationship between local compact object fraction $f_{\rm co}$ and cosmological dark matter fraction $f_{\rm DM}$: $f_{\rm DM} = \frac{f_{\rm co} - f_*}{s}$

where $f_* \equiv \Sigma_*/\Sigma_{\rm tot}$ is the ICL star fraction, and $s \equiv \Sigma_{\rm DM}/\Sigma_{\rm tot}$ is the local dark matter fraction.

For "clean" giant arcs (avoiding bright galaxies):

• $f_* \sim 0.003-0.01$
• $s \sim 0.94-0.99$
• Therefore: $f_{\rm DM} \approx [0.92-0.97]f_{\rm co} < f_{\rm co}$

This means constraints in Figure 3 can be directly converted to dark matter fraction constraints (numerically similar).

Physical Interpretation

Saturation Mechanism

When optical depth $\Theta_{\rm EDO} \sim 1$, effective Einstein radii of microlenses begin overlapping:

• Source star splits into numerous microimages
• Total magnification becomes insensitive to source position relative to macrolens caustics
• High magnification regions shift from critical curve vicinity to more distant locations

Finite Source Effects

When $\theta_E/\mu_t < \beta_R$:

• Microcaustic smaller than source angular size
• Lensing signal smeared out, cannot reach maximum magnification
• Sets lower limit on constrainable mass

Related Work

Caustic Crossing Star Observations

1. MACS J1149 LS1 "Icarus" 1-3: First individual star detection at cosmological distance ($z=1.49$)
2. "Earendel" 7,8: $z=6.2$, $\mu > 4000$ (JWST observations)
3. "Godzilla" 41: Sunburst Arc ($z=2.37$), $\mu \sim 600$
4. "Spock" 42: MACS J0416, $\mu \sim 400$
5. "Mothra" 43: Possibly $\mu \sim 6000$
6. Dragon arc 9: Over 40 microlensing events (JWST data)

Point Lens Constraints

• Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) 10-12: Extensively studied dark matter candidate
• Oguri et al. (2018) 4: First PBH constraints from Icarus
• Palencia et al. (2024) 5: Improved constraint methods

Extended Dark Object Theory

1. Ultracompact Minihalos (UCMHs) 13-15: Formed from primordial overdensity collapse
2. Boson Stars 16,17: Scalar field condensate
3. Axion Miniclusters 18-22: Axion dark matter clump structures

Galactic Microlensing Searches

• Croon et al. (2020) 23,24: Systematic framework for EDO microlensing
• Bai et al. (2020) 33: OGLE/MOA data constraints
• Croon & Sevillano (2024) 34: Recent constraint review

Advantages over Previous Work:

1. Larger detection scales ($10^7 R_\odot$ vs. $10^3 R_\odot$)
2. Cosmological distance provides larger Einstein radius
3. Macrolens $\sqrt{\mu_t}$ enhancement effect

Lensing Theory

• Chang & Refsdal (1979) 27: Classical work on macro+microlensing combination
• Witt (1990) 30: Caustic structures
• Schechter & Wambsganss (2002) 32: Microlensing statistics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Analytical Framework: Establishes a complete EDO microlensing analytical model, generalizing the Chang-Refsdal configuration for point lenses.
2. New Caustic Features: Discovers that specific EDOs (e.g., shallow-core boson stars) can produce additional narrow caustics, leading to new spike features in light curves—potential observational signatures of EDOs.
3. Effective Einstein Radius: Quantifies EDO lensing power relative to point lenses through efficiency factor $\epsilon_{\rm EDO}$, establishing systematic constraint methods.
4. Icarus Constraints: Provides constraints on EDOs with radii up to $10^7 R_\odot$, demonstrating that caustic crossing events probe physical scales far exceeding Galactic microlensing searches.
5. Complementary Parameter Space: Galaxy cluster caustic crossing detection of EDOs complements traditional methods, providing new dimensions for dark matter research.

Limitations

1. Model Assumptions

• Constant convergence and shear approximation: Valid only near critical curves; actual $\mu_t \propto \theta_h^{-1}$ ($\theta_h$ is distance to critical curve)
• Point source approximation: Finite source effects may further modify signals, particularly for narrow caustics
• Single EDO: Actual scenarios may involve multiple EDO superposition, increasing complexity

2. Observational Uncertainties

• $\mu_t$ Dependence: Constraints strongly depend on $\mu_t$ from lens models; Icarus $\mu_t$ uncertainty reaches order of magnitude
• ICL Mass Assumption: Assuming $M_{\rm ICL}=2M_\odot$ is conservative (typical ICL stars are 0.1-1$M_\odot$), affecting low-mass constraints
• Single Event: Constraints based on single Icarus event difficult to assess systematic errors

3. Analysis Depth

• Underutilized Secondary Caustics: Efficiency definition considers only primary caustic (equation 8), not fully exploiting secondary caustic (equation 9) constraint power
• Observational Feasibility: Additional caustic timescales may be very short, but paper lacks quantitative analysis of detection probability for different observation cadences
• Mass Function: Considers only monochromatic mass distribution; extended mass function constraints require further research

4. Comparison with Other Methods

• Axion Minicuster Fluctuations 45: Briefly mentioned but not thoroughly compared for detection capability and complementarity
• Other Galaxy Cluster Events: Mentions Godzilla, Earendel, etc., but doesn't systematically apply this framework

Impact

1. Field Contributions

• Pioneering Work: First systematic study of EDO signals in galaxy cluster caustic crossings, establishing theoretical foundation for the field
• New Parameter Space: Demonstrates detectability of $10^7 R_\odot$ scale EDOs, filling detection space gaps
• Methodological Contribution: Effective Einstein radius and efficiency factor concepts generalizable to other macro+microlensing systems

2. Practical Value

• Near-term Applications: JWST observations of Dragon arc (Cycles 5-7) will directly test predictions
• Future Facilities: Provides theoretical guidance and analysis tools for Roman and LSST time-domain surveys
• Dark Matter Constraints: Offers new constraint pathways for ultracompact minihalos, axion miniclusters, and other dark matter candidates

3. Reproducibility

• Analytical Formulas: Provides complete analytical expressions for easy application
• Public Tools: References EDObounds code 37, enhancing reproducibility
• Clear Methods: Constraint methodology clearly presented, easily generalizable to other events

Applicable Scenarios

1. Ideal Application Scenarios

• High-$\mu_t$ Giant Arcs: Systems with $\mu_t \sim 10^3-10^4$ significantly extend detectable EDO scales
• Multiple Image Structures: Systems like Dragon arc enabling precise lens model determination
• Long-term Monitoring: Multi-cycle JWST observations accumulating statistical samples

2. Complementary Detection

• Galactic Microlensing: Detects $R \lesssim 10^3 R_\odot$ EDOs
• Galaxy Cluster Caustic Crossings: Detects $10^3-10^7 R_\odot$ EDOs (this work)
• Axion Minicuster Fluctuations: Detects $M \sim 10^{-15}-10^{-8}M_\odot$ diffuse ensembles 45

3. Limited Scenarios

• Low-$\mu_t$ Systems: $\mu_t \lesssim 10$ shows weak $\sqrt{\mu_t}$ enhancement
• High Stellar Density Regions: ICL star contributions may overwhelm DM signals
• Rapid Transients: Insufficient observation cadence to capture narrow caustic features

Selected References

Key Observational Papers

• 1 Kelly et al. (2015): Icarus discovery paper
• 2 Kelly et al. (2018): Icarus detailed analysis
• 3 Diego et al. (2018): Icarus lens modeling
• 8 Welch et al. (2022): Earendel ($z=6.2$) discovery
• 9 Fudamoto et al. (2025): Dragon arc 40+ events

Theoretical Foundation

• 4 Oguri et al. (2018): First PBH constraints from Icarus
• 23,24 Croon et al. (2020): EDO Galactic microlensing framework
• 27 Chang & Refsdal (1979): Classical macro+microlensing work

Dark Matter Candidates

• 13-15 Ultracompact minihalos theory
• 18-22 Axion miniclusters theory
• 26 Bringmann et al. (2025): Ultracompact minihalos and caustic crossings

Complementary Methods

• 45 Dai & Miralda-Escudé (2020): Axion minicuster surface density fluctuations

Summary

This paper represents pioneering work on detecting extended dark objects in galaxy cluster gravitational lensing, establishing a rigorous analytical framework, predicting observable new features, and providing specific constraints on the Icarus event. The core innovation reveals the $\sqrt{\mu_t}$ enhancement effect of macrolenses, extending detectable EDO scales to $10^7 R_\odot$, filling parameter space gaps in dark matter detection. While current constraints are limited by $\mu_t$ uncertainties and single-event statistics, JWST and other facilities will rapidly improve this situation. The paper establishes theoretical foundations for future statistical analyses, possessing significant scientific value and application prospects.